Originally Posted by psychlone99 
The problem with that wish is that Lofton won't come cheap. Look at it from a simple cost/benefit standpoint: It would cost the Cubs next to nothing to get Edmonds, who would probably sign at the league minimum. If he can turn back the clock a couple seasons (which happens quite often just about the time a player appears to washed up), the potential benefit could be significant- a decent hitter against RHP to platoon with Johnson.
If it doesn't work, Edmonds is released, Pie is recalled, and the Cubs are out a little cash. Big deal. This isn't a trading deadline blockbuster that everyone should be worked up about. As a Cubs fan, I think it's worth a shot. What the hell.
I don't pretend that Lofton is THE answer, but your cost/benefit analysis doesn't factor in the clubhouse cancer that Edmonds is/will be. This team is starting to gel and the last thing they need is some cast off from their main rival, known for being a $%!##& teammate throwing a turd in the locker room punch bowl.
I actually think they need to identify a solid third starting pitcher more than they need to identify another lefty bat.
