Jeff's Pizza Shop

SeattleClone · 03-07-2008, 05:06 PM

Menu looks delicious, but lacking one item. This business does not appear to serve beer, which is very key to enjoying pizza. Maybe they will add that later, like Es Tas did.

Speaking of Es Tas, are they serving food in their new location yet? They weren't a couple weeks ago, but I'm hoping they are by now. Planning to hit it the 'Tas tomorrow before the game.

mwitt · 03-07-2008, 05:11 PM

Better than pokey sticks? That's a bold statement.

scottie33 · 03-07-2008, 05:31 PM

Originally Posted by mwitt

Better than pokey sticks? That's a bold statement.

Haha, I know. We usually get two of the largest boxes and sometimes 4 of the largest boxes. I think next week were going to have to go with the smotheralla...kind of sounds like mozzeralla being said by a person with a really bad lisp.

mwitt · 03-07-2008, 05:36 PM

Originally Posted by scottie33

Haha, I know. We usually get two of the largest boxes and sometimes 4 of the largest boxes. I think next week were going to have to go with the smotheralla...kind of sounds like mozzeralla being said by a person with a really bad lisp.

I was thinking about pokeys tonight because my Catholic self can't eat meat. Do you know what these smotherellas are priced? Sizes? Sauce it comes with? Gumby's now charges to get sauce with theirs, and it's annoying.

Aclone · 03-08-2008, 10:33 AM

I've decided that it is obviously a very cool place, and I'll have too hit it the next time I'm in Ames. But parking must be a problem.

*another guy named Jeff

superfan · 03-08-2008, 10:35 AM

Originally Posted by SeattleClone

Menu looks delicious, but lacking one item. This business does not appear to serve beer, which is very key to enjoying pizza. Maybe they will add that later, like Es Tas did.

Speaking of Es Tas, are they serving food in their new location yet? They weren't a couple weeks ago, but I'm hoping they are by now. Planning to hit it the 'Tas tomorrow before the game.

Was there last night. Yes, they are serving food.

superfan · 03-08-2008, 10:44 AM

Originally Posted by mwitt

I was thinking about pokeys tonight because my Catholic self can't eat meat. Do you know what these smotherellas are priced? Sizes? Sauce it comes with? Gumby's now charges to get sauce with theirs, and it's annoying.

Gumby's Pokey Stix:

10" : $8.99
12" : $9.99
14" : $12.99
16" : $13.99
20" : $19.99

Sauce extra

Jeff's Smotherella Sticks:

(Regular : Extra Cheese/Jalapeno/Toppings)

10" : $6.69 : $7.78
12" : $7.69 : $8.98
14" : $9.69 : $11.18
16" : $11.69 : $13.38
20" : $14.69 : $16.78

Not totally sure, but I think sauce is free. Choice of pizza, garlic, ranch, nacho, feta, or bleu cheese.

SeattleClone · 03-08-2008, 10:47 AM

Originally Posted by superfan

Was there last night. Yes, they are serving food.

Thanks Superfan!

Cyclone06 · 03-08-2008, 11:02 AM

Most importanly do they serve by the slice for the late night crowd? Nothing really beats the gyroman, but I'd be tempted to give any pizza a chance at 2am.

superfan · 03-08-2008, 11:09 AM

Originally Posted by Cyclone06

Most importanly do they serve by the slice for the late night crowd? Nothing really beats the gyroman, but I'd be tempted to give any pizza a chance at 2am.

Why yes, yes they do. (I actually think this might wind up being the cornerstone of their business - you can find lots of drunk food in Campustown - subs, gyro, hot dog, tacos, burrito, etc. - but Dominos is the only real pizza competition, and there you have to buy a whole one)

Cydog · 03-08-2008, 11:12 AM

Went to Jeff's last night for a slice. Delicious! $3 for a massive slice of pizza. I'll be hitting this place up again.

nickwc · 03-09-2008, 11:38 PM

ate there last night, pizza was really good, and cheap,

A-town Cy · 03-09-2008, 11:44 PM

Me and 3 of my friends ate there yesterday after the game, we got a big pepperoni pizza and a big smotherella sticks. It was awesome, but then later in the night, we all had stomach aches. We came to conclusion that it had to have been the grease loaded on our smotherella sticks.

ianoconnor · 03-09-2008, 11:48 PM

We went there this weekend, got the meat lovers (forget the actual name)... It was excellent, and it had bison meat on it!!!

mwitt · 03-10-2008, 12:02 AM

Originally Posted by superfan

Gumby's Pokey Stix:

10" : $8.99
12" : $9.99
14" : $12.99
16" : $13.99
20" : $19.99

Sauce extra

Jeff's Smotherella Sticks:

(Regular : Extra Cheese/Jalapeno/Toppings)

10" : $6.69 : $7.78
12" : $7.69 : $8.98
14" : $9.69 : $11.18
16" : $11.69 : $13.38
20" : $14.69 : $16.78

Not totally sure, but I think sauce is free. Choice of pizza, garlic, ranch, nacho, feta, or bleu cheese.

I always get the pick up special with the pokey sticks, so they're cheaper. I had Jeff's last night, and I was very impressed. We got their house party special with a 16" pizza and 14" smotherella sticks. Their italian sausage on their pizza is very good. The smotherella sticks were good and I love the fact that they have that garlic sauce (Gumby's used to), but I still think the pokeys are better. It definitely won't be the last time I have it.