Sorry to take the conversation off of Herman and back onto the potential MLB recruit we may have just snagged, but...
Originally Posted by Mr Janny
I agree. I don't want to hype them too much, either. But I'm not saying that 2-3 years from now, all these guys are going to be stars. What I'm saying is that 2-3 years from now, I hope we will look back to these recruits and see that they became the backbone of a defensive unit that allows us to hold our own against the best of the Big 12, and get to that 7-9 win consistency that we all are hoping for.
This makes tons of sense to me, we seem to be getting guys who look the part more this year which helps us out from a physical development stand point. These players don't have to sit in the bench with the exclusive job of hitting the weights during the week. Sure they will have to gain strength and so-on but they may be able to contribute more immediately.
Originally Posted by swarthmoreCY
Reread my post. By not excusing Herman's performance with "he is doing the best he can with what one could expect him to get at ISU" I am doing exactly the opposite your accusation.
I am suggesting that Herman's ability to get players does not appreciably change coming off of 2-10 or 5-7. Year 1 you sell PT and hope. Year 3 you sell progress and I suppose results (although I am not sure 5-7 is much different than 2-10 to a 17 year-old in Texas/Florida).
I'm pretty after year 3 you sell Paul f'ing Rhoads pretty hard. He has been getting ISU free marketing for a while now. Not sure if there are too many kids out there playing high school ball anywhere who don't know who Paul Rhoads is.
Can you quantify the effect turnovers have had on our scoring this year? My guess: around 6-7 points/game. A lot of our turnovers were also due to inexperience. The offense this year is light years more effective than last year's was. I expect a huge jump next year in scoring because of the added experience.
I believe one turnover results in approximately 3 and half ppg loss, but that may be an NFL stat. Can't recall clearly. Maybe Khaal is around to help us with that?
Sounds a lot like McD's tenure...
Depends on how much data one needs to make a decision. Some people are better at speculating than others.
Basketball and football are two completely different things, especially in terms of how long it takes. First, you have about 4 times as many players to all play together not counting injuries which are more prevalent in football. Second, you need to develop kids for much longer to get them ready
Things for you to understand about football:
-2nd to last in the conference in TOs
-last in pass efficiency
-2nd to last in 3rd down conversions
-last in red-zone offense
-2nd to last in ppg
I would think even someone of your football intellect would understand the offense is not performing to the level ISU needs it to.
Please show me where I said the last one? Again, first year D-1 QBs which should be expected in year 3 and ISU. There is also a pretty inexperienced Oline, young RBs and new receivers just scratching the surface. You also have to realize we play in the best offense league in the country so rankings may or may not be a good measuring stick for Tom Herman.
6 years is a ridiculously long amount of time to make a determination on a coordinator.
I don't think so. Not with a complete system overhaul and a tough place to recruit to. If we just look at the QB position which is, a lot of times an offenses limiting factor:
Year 1-Staff scrambles and takes Capello
Year 2-You get Barnett, he redshirts
Year 3-Barnett is your starter mid way through the season, Richarson RSing
Year 4-You are still starting a 2nd year QB, perhaps a sophomore
Year 5-This should probably be a year you need to see results
Year 6- Profit
All content owned by CycloneFanatic.com - All rights reserved 2005-09. By viewing this website you agree to the Terms of Service, Site Rules and Legal Disclaimer. The words, views, images and opinions expressed or provided by users do not reflect the opinions or views of CycloneFanatic.com or Iowa State University. The names, words, symbols, and graphics representing Iowa State University are trademarks and copyrights of the University protected by the trademark and copyright laws of the United States of America and other countries and are used on this web site under license from the University. Original site design, premise & construction by Jeremy Lind.