Rhoads vs Chizik

[isu5000]

Article from Mr Sec that I came across last night. Who’s The Better Coach: AU’s Chizik Or ISU’s Rhoads?

Nothing we havent seen before but a decent little read about which "college football coach is better Rhoads or Chizik?" I think we all know that answer to that question.

[Bader]

wth? Why is Jon Miller doing analysis for Mr SEC?

[redrocket22]

Chiz clearly made a deal with the devil to get Cam and the national title. My question is did JP make a deal with the devil to get rid of both Chiz and Chewie or was this the cosmic tumblers that control the universe finally realizing the injustice of hoisting the Chewie Chiz combo on the Cyclone faithful?

[bos]

Good comparison. But could have done with out the SEC ego stroking throughout.

[klamath632]

Whoever wrote that article claims that Auburn has tougher schedules than ISU because they play in the SEC.

[Al_4_State]

Good comparison. But could have done with out the SEC ego stroking throughout.

Yup. No Mr. SEC, there really isn't that much of a difference between the Big 12 and SEC.

[CyArob]

wth? Why is Jon Miller doing analysis for Mr SEC?

This. Is a good question.

[djkent01]

Don't be surprised when Auburn comes calling on Rhoads at the end of this season. That will answer your question of who is the better coach.

[Haverhill]

I thought Marty Tirrell was the one "diving for loose balls;" looks like Miller is diving for spare change.

[azepp]

Look, there’s no question that Chizik is having to coach in the SEC while Rhoads is in the Big XII. There’s a difference there.

That is correct, but that difference is not enough to justify Chiz's shortcomings when you consider what he said a couple paragraphs before that:

You won’t find Rhoads matching up well with Chizik in the recruiting rankings. Currently, Auburn is #9 in terms of 2013 commitments while Iowa State is #60. Last year, Auburn’s post-signing day rank was #10 in the nation. Iowa State was #87.

[LegendofRodA]

That is correct, but that difference is not enough to justify Chiz's shortcomings when you consider what he said a couple paragraphs before that:

Yep, he pretty much contradicts the argument for Chiz...would you rather have a coach who does more with less or less with more (excluding his National Champion$hip of course)?

[hexodat64]

I thought it was interesting that they noted on SoundOff how since the Cam Newton fiasco, CPR is 10 - 8 and Cheez-it is 9-9