who gets your vote for heisman?

here is my list IN a particular order

Toby Gerhart
Ndamukong Suh
Mark Ingram
Colt McCoy
Tim Tebow

gerhart, suh and ingram all had solid performances to finish the season and attempt to TAKE the heisman. they stepped up on the big stage to finish the season on national TV. the two QB's really failed in that regard.

gerhart has been the most consistent back in the nation the ENTIRE season. he has the most rushing TD's and second most rushing yards per game. he was at his best against the best competition. he beats ingram in every virtually every rushing stat. the only reason ingram is on the same page as gerhart is because he is on a better team, which shouldn't have anything to do with the heisman (although it does, see troy davis).

suh won't win simply because he plays defense, although i would put him right up there with gerhart.

Colt McCoy
Dion Lews
Ndamukong Suh
Toby Gerhart
Mark Ingram

Where's Stanzi?

If it was to award the best player in CFB, Suh would get it.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by IcSyU

If it was to award the best player in CFB, Suh would get it.

---

Yep totally agree, but it will be Ingram

None of the Above

Alexander Robinson

What makes me interested to see about ingram is that no Alabama players has ever won it, he's a sophmore, some of the southeastern published ballots don't list him in top 3

Suh


Gerhart
Ingram
McCoy
Tebow

I don't get the love for Ingram. His numbers aren't eyepopping or anything. You can't give a guy the Heisman because of one good game on prime time tv.

please don't be suh.

It won't anyway it will be toby gerhart.. i bet 1 mil credits on it, so it better be :)

It should be Suh. Offensive and defensive linemen don't get the credit they deserve.

Here is my list

1)Ingram- Great season this year, had a bad game against "the team that shall not be named" due to a hip pointer

2) McCoy- Can't really expect more out of him than you did, another great season and is now playing for his National Championship

3)Gerhart- Great season with Stanford, not flashy just a great solid player

4) Suh- most dominating player just won't go to a defensive player

5) Tebow- Already has his Heisman, had another Tebowess season, filled with fire, isn't scared of anyone.

It should be Suh. He is the definition of domination.

I'd go with Gerhart

Suh is the only one on that list that literally took control of games for his team...well except I-State. :notworthy: