All-Time Cyclone Football Roster

**deadeyededric** · 03-14-2010, 01:17 AM

Few more Chris Anthony was 86 i know. Mike Horacek and James Reed.

**MookInLincoln** · 03-14-2010, 01:52 AM

Originally Posted by 82cyclonesfan82

No kidding. And you don't even have Bret Culbertson as one of them.

If there was a quality position player at 10, I would have put him on there but amazingly enough, there really wasn't

I was really close to putting Nik Moser at 9, but I think Jeff Shudak was the best kicker we've ever had

At 37, I went with the fullback from Des Moines over the kicker from Des Moines ... 2007 Iowa doesn't let me forgive 2004 Missouri - sorry

**MookInLincoln** · 03-14-2010, 01:56 AM

Originally Posted by deadeyededric

Ty Whatley was real good, but do his stats support where you have him ranked. Was it him or Groce that came from Pacific after they dropped football? I think it was Pacific.

Ty Wat came from Pacific (thank you to Paul Rhoads) and he was a stud, no doubt ... but Blaise Bryant was a preseason All-American in 1990 (check out the Playboy magazine, he's in there) and only injury at Minnesota (wearing the wrong shoes contributed) kept him from having an amazing senior season after a breakout junior campaign ... I love Ty Wat, but I feel pretty good about taking BB at 21, anyone else have thoughts on this?

**MookInLincoln** · 03-14-2010, 01:58 AM

Originally Posted by deadeyededric

Deandre Jackson for Arnaud. Forgot all about him. One of the best corners we ever had. Injury or not I think I take him over Arnaud.

This was one of the last one's I decided on, and I actually think Jackson deserves the spot, but I thought I would get killed by the current students if I didn't put AA in here ... anyone else says DJ over AA and I'll gladly make that switch

**MookInLincoln** · 03-14-2010, 03:01 AM

Originally Posted by deadeyededric

Few more Chris Anthony was 86 i know. Mike Horacek and James Reed.

86 Anthony was a great player, but Ross was better IMHO

88 Horacek was good, but Dan Johnson played in the league ... I also considered TE Craig Mahoney at this spot

#52 James Reed vs. Brent Curvey - I knew this one would come up and I don't think it will ever be settled ... maybe we could create a poll or something, I love 'em both - personally would have went Reed as he is my era, but board love seems to be in favor of Big Play Curvey

**deadeyededric** · 03-14-2010, 04:37 AM

Originally Posted by MookInLincoln

86 Anthony was a great player, but Ross was better IMHO

88 Horacek was good, but Dan Johnson played in the league ... I also considered TE Craig Mahoney at this spot

#52 James Reed vs. Brent Curvey - I knew this one would come up and I don't think it will ever be settled ... maybe we could create a poll or something, I love 'em both - personally would have went Reed as he is my era, but board love seems to be in favor of Big Play Curvey

Yeah i'll take Curvey over 4 years.

**deadeyededric** · 03-14-2010, 04:42 AM

Originally Posted by MookInLincoln

Ty Wat came from Pacific (thank you to Paul Rhoads) and he was a stud, no doubt ... but Blaise Bryant was a preseason All-American in 1990 (check out the Playboy magazine, he's in there) and only injury at Minnesota (wearing the wrong shoes contributed) kept him from having an amazing senior season after a breakout junior campaign ... I love Ty Wat, but I feel pretty good about taking BB at 21, anyone else have thoughts on this?

Oh definately, I was talking about your 10 recievers list with Whatley. Hell yeah, I used to go up and watch Blaise run for Walden in the short time he played. Heisman hopes till he got hurt and never was the same that one year. I have that Playboy,

one of the few Mom let me keep. And the SI "From Surfer to Cyclone"

**MookInLincoln** · 03-14-2010, 12:00 PM

After sleeping on it, I have inserted Jeff Braswell for Oliver Ross at 51

chalk another one up for the Criner era

**dualthreat** · 03-14-2010, 12:44 PM

shouldn't austin flynn be #13? I realized he switched, but he made his mark with #13. Then you could put steve paris in at #8...

Also, what number was ben bruns? I don't think i saw him on the list.

**MookInLincoln** · 03-14-2010, 12:51 PM

Bruns was 63 - I went with Mike Stensrud

I put Flynn at 8 so he would be on the team ... I had Washington > Flynn > Paris

If you disagree, please let me know your opinion

**CRcyclone6** · 03-14-2010, 01:03 PM

Originally Posted by MookInLincoln

This was one of the last one's I decided on, and I actually think Jackson deserves the spot, but I thought I would get killed by the current students if I didn't put AA in here ... anyone else says DJ over AA and I'll gladly make that switch

make the switch

**MookInLincoln** · 03-14-2010, 01:16 PM

Originally Posted by CRcyclone6

make the switch

Making the switch

**CycloBelle** · 03-14-2010, 04:18 PM

Wow, that was impressive! I was wondering where your thread was going with the who's better questions a while back. How long did you work on this?

**MookInLincoln** · 03-14-2010, 04:25 PM

Originally Posted by CycloBelle

Wow, that was impressive! I was wondering where your thread was going with the who's better questions a while back. How long did you work on this?

Thanks, it really didn't take that long. I put it on the shelf for a while then came back to it yesterday.

I had so much fun doing it that I put one together for iowa today.

I have all the players selected, but I'm struggling to find hometowns for all these hawks I don't know very well. I might just post it without that part.

**MookInLincoln** · 03-14-2010, 05:54 PM

if you know or care about iowa football, here is the link to that one on the in-state rivals forum ...

http://www.cyclonefanatic.com/forum/...ll-roster.html