CF Mafia Game #4 - INNOCENTS WIN!!

Flag Guy · 06-09-2008, 04:45 PM

And before people start implicating me one way or the other based on that statement, I've been killed as both mafia and an innocent for taking the same stance. The only thing I'm guilty of is staying the course and ruffling feathers because of it, and I'm tired of feather ruffling. All it gets is me burried

l2alphmacchio · 06-09-2008, 04:46 PM

I believe night starts at 7 tonight, right?

Flag Guy · 06-09-2008, 04:50 PM

That is what I read

Cyclone62 · 06-09-2008, 04:56 PM

Night starts at 7PM tonight. It was in the role PM

d4nim4l · 06-09-2008, 04:57 PM

Originally Posted by jdoggivjc

Are there any real reasons that can be given for voting for someone on the first day? It's generally a crapshoot...

I agree with you but would like to see something along the lines of "good player, too dangerous", "bad player", "can't spell", "hates flowers".

I don't really care. Give me something instead of seemingly drawing a name out of a hat.

Heck, even if someone wanted to kill Flag Guy with the reasoning "always dies early" I would support it more than this.

Or if someone wants to kill CyclongG with "always gets the Detective killed" I would support it. Who knows, that may be our best bet.

Cyclone62 · 06-09-2008, 04:58 PM

I'm leaning toward Crunch right now for his post. Plus, I hate Cap'n Crunch. It always cuts the roof of my mouth. Bastard.

guitarchitect7 · 06-09-2008, 05:00 PM

Originally Posted by Cyano

So...another newb here. I've checked in on the discussions in past rounds, but first time playing and I'm already paranoid about everyone.

D4, if you want something to go off of, this comment is as about as much suspicious as anything else.

This would be something that could be said by mafia to blend as innocent. Although as a newbie, it could just be a comment that comes out wrong. Either way, as far as what has been / will be said, this one caught my eye above others.

Although I don't feel its worthy of lynching because of it, there isn't also much else to go off of either.

isucyfan · 06-09-2008, 05:01 PM

Originally Posted by Cyclone62

Night starts at 7PM tonight. It was in the role PM

Thanks, missed it.

d4nim4l · 06-09-2008, 05:05 PM

Guitar & Cyclone: I would advocate lynching either one of them just because of the nature of their posts. Would I suspect them of messing up this early and tipping us off to their roles? Not really.

However, at least there is some fodder there for us to go off. Regardless of how badly we want to see something that probably isn't there.

Just for the sake of evening things up I am going to cast my vote for Crunch. If CTA takes his vote off or comes up with better logic I will change mine.

I vote to eliminate CrunchD3

isucyfan · 06-09-2008, 05:06 PM

Originally Posted by CrunchD3

new player and as innocent as they come, just trying to keep my head down

This quote was "fingered" quickly by 3 players.

I'm going with our guts, which worked for us in Game 1.

I may be out mowing the lawn around the deadline, so...

I vote to eliminate CrunchD3

Cyano · 06-09-2008, 05:16 PM

Originally Posted by guitarchitect7

D4, if you want something to go off of, this comment is as about as much suspicious as anything else.

This would be something that could be said by mafia to blend as innocent. Although as a newbie, it could just be a comment that comes out wrong. Either way, as far as what has been / will be said, this one caught my eye above others.

Although I don't feel its worthy of lynching because of it, there isn't also much else to go off of either.

And I thought I was just making a comment about the style of the game. My guess was that you are mafia as being one of the few on here that are already starting to point fingers, but then again thats what the mafia would say...I should have just kept my mouth shut...hmmm but maybe thats what the mafia would do too...

isucyfan · 06-09-2008, 05:22 PM

Originally Posted by Cyano

And I thought I was just making a comment about the style of the game. My guess was that you are mafia as being one of the few on here that are already starting to point fingers, but then again thats what the mafia would say...I should have just kept my mouth shut...hmmm but maybe thats what the mafia would do too...

guitarchitect was a finger-pointer in Game 1...I'm just glad he's not pointing fingers at me this time!

CrunchD3 · 06-09-2008, 05:47 PM

wow new guy already getting run off in town. If you guys take a look i really am new to all of this and don't think i could really run a mafia or anything associated with it. sorry for making a post saying keep my head down and drawing some suspicions guess i'd better start looking for a new town say goodbye to an innocent as this is my last post til i go play some ball tonite...my only chance is to vote for BigM and hope somebody votes with me and have my chances come down to random chance.

I vote to eliminate BigM

d4nim4l · 06-09-2008, 05:47 PM

Guitar did the same thing last game. And was Mafia...

jdoggivjc · 06-09-2008, 05:47 PM

That post is awful suspicious...

I vote to eliminate CrunchD3