Misc: CF Game #5- INNOCENTS WIN.....!

superfan · 06-20-2008, 12:34 PM

Granted, the whole "he's the detective" thing appears to be holdover from previous games, but saying it after a mafia member was starting to accumulate votes, then randomly accusing someone else (which the executed mafia member followed up with) is just a little too suspicious.

I vote to eliminate CTAClone

rworkman83 · 06-20-2008, 12:38 PM

I'm throwing my vote in earlier today than normal, in hopes of getting something done at work today.

I vote to eliminate CTAClone

It was pretty much decided who was dead yesterday afternoon, then he threw a new name out there to stir things up. Seemed kind of weird to me.

keepngoal · 06-20-2008, 12:44 PM

Originally Posted by l2alphmacchio

From the history of keep's posts (on the rest of the forum), one would gather that he is rather intelligent. But his awkwardness and going back on his comments and stirring things in another direction says one of two things; he's either really bad at this game, or he's mafia.
I will be out the rest of the afternoon, but hopefully will be back sometime before 8.
I vote to eliminate keepngoal

1. Very new to this game, so I am very bad at this game.
2. Extremely hungover.
3. I should put more thought into posting when playing this game.

I am changing my vote to:

I vote to eliminate CTAClone

I am fine with livinthecylifes answers.

- keep

cycloneG · 06-20-2008, 01:42 PM

Wow, I leave for a few hours and accusations start flying. While I do find CTAClone's voting suspicious, I believe the same voting pattern happens every game. I don't believe CTAClone to be mafia, yet. Maybe when CTAClone posts today, I'll have more reason to vote for him.

I vote to eliminate nobody.

keepngoal · 06-20-2008, 01:48 PM

Originally Posted by cycloneG

Wow, I leave for a few hours and accusations start flying. While I do find CTAClone's voting suspicious, I believe the same voting pattern happens every game. I don't believe CTAClone to be mafia, yet. Maybe when CTAClone posts today, I'll have more reason to vote for him.

I vote to eliminate nobody.

this is very strange post if you are an innocent.

1. innocents, IMO, need to try find mafia and must vote to eliminate someone each day.
2. and voting for nobody is similar to voting for a completely new person, as CTA did yesterday.

you are on my watch list for being mafia.

-keep.

cycloneG · 06-20-2008, 01:49 PM

My vote isn't final. It's just an indication of where I'm at now.

CTAClone · 06-20-2008, 02:28 PM

Wow. I love it. Bring it on. Bring it on.

CTAClone · 06-20-2008, 02:42 PM

Originally Posted by superfan

Still, you're a lazy hippie.

Players.....

CycloneG - Voted CyclonesRule (3:57)
12alphacchio - Voted Nobody (4:24)
jdoggivjc - Voted CyclonesRule (3:49)
LivntheCyLife - Voted cycloneman003 (1:27)
cycloneworld - Voted cycloneman003 (12:10) - Rescinded (1:19) - Voted CyclonesRule (1:19)
CycloneRule - Voted Flag Guy (4:26)
Flag Guy - Voted CyclonesRule (7:02)
CTAClone - Voted Livin (12:08) - Rescinded (12:58) - Voted Flag Guy (4:05)
Cyclone62 - Voted CyclonesRule (6:21)
Keepngoal - Did Not Vote
rworkman83 - Voted CyclonesRule (3:31)
CrunchD3 - Voted CyclonesRule (7:31)
Chadm - Voted CyclonesRule (3:14)
cycloneman003 - Did Not Vote
superfan - Voted CyclonesRule (6:10)

When I voted, yes it was pretty clear that CyclonesRule was gonna get voted off, I think he had 4 or 5 votes. Not definite, but there was still 4 hours left in the game. I put another person on the chopping block to get more evidence. Instead, everyone else chose to follow the clearly voted off member.

I highlighted everyone that voted after me. Did you guys decide to jump on the bandwagon to avoid suspicion?

CTAClone · 06-20-2008, 02:45 PM

Originally Posted by LivntheCyLife

I like cycloneworld's suggestion of going after quiet players, and I find it interesting that nobody has jumped on the bandwagon yet. Remember the mafia is always the toughest to generate votes for. Therefore,

I vote to eliminate cycloneman003.

Originally Posted by LivntheCyLife

Oops, I see cycloneworld changed his vote as I was replying. I think I'll stay with mine for now since I think it's good for people to have a couple options on the first day to establish voting patterns.

Livin was leading the charge on being the innocents leader along with Cycloneworld. They were agreeing on points together but when Cycloneworld changed his vote he didn't change his.
Why was that?

CTAClone · 06-20-2008, 02:49 PM

Originally Posted by CTAClone

Pretty much. Anyways, I like what Cyworld said about going after the quiet players. I'm not sure that cycloneman003 even knows the game is going on right now. He was a late addition and may not have noticed we are playing yet. Maybe a PM from Dags with the link would make sure he finds his way over here.

Originally Posted by cycloneworld

Good point. He hasn't been online since yesterday. I rescind my vote for cycloneman003 and

I vote to eliminate CyclonesRule who has been online today but not said anything.

Who is the one that convinced Cycloneworld to change his vote? And I immediately backed him up in this.

Originally Posted by CTAClone

Not bad reasoning. I like the way you roll, errr I mean roleplay.

CTAClone · 06-20-2008, 02:52 PM

Originally Posted by LivntheCyLife

Right now we have one vote for CyclonesRule and one for cycloneman003. (Both because of their inactivity) We need more voters. Or if you think we shouldn't vote for anybody, vote that way. But at least give us your reasoning. The more the innocents sit back, the easier it is for the mafia to sit back also.

Originally Posted by CTAClone

I think it's two votes for Cyclonesrule now.

The two votes reasoning against me is ridiculous. Who cares if I was counting, it showed I was paying attention to what was going on.

CTAClone · 06-20-2008, 03:07 PM

Originally Posted by l2alphmacchio

Good morning everyone, just want to take the time and thank Dags for opening this up for cycloneworld, and to cycloneworld for hosting the past 4 games.

Originally Posted by l2alphmacchio

I'm pretty sure I was quiet for the first part of last game (had good reasons) and I wasn't mafia, but was just gathering info. I lasted just until the end, and we won that game. Although I'm not arguing with the quiet factor, I just think since its been stated, that the mafia aren't going to hang low anymore (not that they have in the past).

Originally Posted by l2alphmacchio

It is suspicious, but I do believe last game that he stated that he usually leaves his browser open to CF, which explains why he is signed on (I am in no way defending, just giving reasons, nor have I investigated whether or not he has posted) and on another note, I believe he was one of the players that checked the posts after work. I could be wrong, but just saying.

Originally Posted by l2alphmacchio

And another thing, if we lynch him tonight and he IS mafia, I ask of you not to come after me, cause I am an innocent, and I just wanted to get the facts out to people.

Originally Posted by l2alphmacchio

I vote to eliminate nobody

Originally Posted by l2alphmacchio

After re-reading everything this morning after last night's events. I believe that CTAClone is something. Either he is the other mason, or a mafioso in disguise. I believe this because in yesterdays posts he follows cycloneworld like a little puppy dog (nothing against you). So I believe that he might be the other mason or he is a mafioso trying to get on everyones side.
What does everyone else think?

Originally Posted by l2alphmacchio

I voted for no one, just cause I haven't voted for anyone any other first day. I pointed out some reasons as to why not to vote for him, but was proved wrong by keep after I posted. Which I'm happy that I was proved wrong, and I'm glad that we got a mafioso the first night. I can tell you one thing though, I WILL be voting today, and I want to hear from CTA and keep as to why they aren't mafia.

Originally Posted by l2alphmacchio

From the history of keep's posts (on the rest of the forum), one would gather that he is rather intelligent. But his awkwardness and going back on his comments and stirring things in another direction says one of two things; he's either really bad at this game, or he's mafia.
I will be out the rest of the afternoon, but hopefully will be back sometime before 8.
I vote to eliminate keepngoal

Here's a list of the Karate Kid's posts. I don't know why he voted the way he did yesterday. Especially since I believe last game he was an advocate for voting somebody off. I find all his posts suspicious. He also defended CyclonesRule about him leaving his browser open or something. Maybe he did mention that last game or maybe he didn't, I don't remember.

One thing is for sure, he was pretty consistent yesterday after defending CyclonesRule he voted for Nobody. Was doing this to cover his *** for defending one of his cohorts, or did he truly believe what he was saying?

CTAClone · 06-20-2008, 03:11 PM

One more thing about the Karate Kid. After re-reading all his posts and seeing that the second quote was made before any votes were cast, it defends his way of voting. So I may be way off base with my suspicion.

cycloneG · 06-20-2008, 03:13 PM

I think we're running into the same problem we had last game. You two are squabbling with each other and are most likely both innocent. I may be wrong but that's what it seems like to me.

CTAClone · 06-20-2008, 03:33 PM

Originally Posted by superfan

I'd agree with this. I actually was starting to think cycloneworld was mafia, because of his avatar. (Really, think of the bragging rights if you win the game as mafia with WHAT YOU ARE IN YOUR AVATAR.) Guess I was wrong on that one...

That's funny. That would be some good bragging rights. Too bad the Doctor didn't protect him last night like he asked for, but I guess he was kind of suspicious because he was a ring leader. I'm always suspicious of people leading the charge for someone.