Restaurant holds family "hostage" for refusal to tip
It's the offseason. Might as well have another good discussion on tipping.
Family says restaurant locked them inside over tip refusal | News - Home
Re: Restaurant holds family "hostage" for refusal to tip
Be interested to know what the legalities of not paying the automatic gratuity portion of a check would be.
Re: Restaurant holds family "hostage" for refusal to tip
If it's stated, you gotta pay it. But it's still stupid to auto-add it.
Re: Restaurant holds family "hostage" for refusal to tip
Quote:
If it's stated, you gotta pay it.
Legally? I never really thought about it I guess.
Automatic gratuity for a party of 5 is ridiculous in and of itself, I could see a large party, say 8 or 9 people maybe.
Re: Restaurant holds family "hostage" for refusal to tip
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Hawkeye11en1
If it's stated, you gotta pay it. But it's still stupid to auto-add it.
agreed. The fact that it's become customary is the bad part. I wonder what would happen if a store like HyVee posted a sign outside that said "15% gratuity added for all purchases of greater than $100." How long would that last?
Re: Restaurant holds family "hostage" for refusal to tip
Quote:
Originally Posted by
3TrueFans
Legally? I never really thought about it I guess.
Automatic gratuity for a party of 5 is ridiculous in and of itself, I could see a large party, say 8 or 9 people maybe.
It's illegal to not pay the $9.99 for the burger, just like if it says you have to pay the 17% and you don't. It's part of the bill, part of what you are buying.
Re: Restaurant holds family "hostage" for refusal to tip
Quote:
In the end, the family ended up paying the 17 percent gratuity because they wanted to avoid any further problems.
buncha *******
Re: Restaurant holds family "hostage" for refusal to tip
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Mr Janny
agreed. The fact that it's become customary is the bad part. I wonder what would happen if a store like HyVee posted a sign outside that said "15% gratuity added for all purchases of greater than $100." How long would that last?
Yup, exactly. But it does go both ways. Regulars at bars sometimes think they can leave tabs and pay next time they come in. Can you do that at HyVee? So it's a headache going the other way, too. And then they fail to tip when they come back and pay most of the time. Annoying.
Re: Restaurant holds family "hostage" for refusal to tip
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Mr Janny
agreed. The fact that it's become customary is the bad part. I wonder what would happen if a store like HyVee posted a sign outside that said "15% gratuity added for all purchases of greater than $100." How long would that last?
I work at a restaurant where there's no automatic gratuity. 15% on over $100 would be nice. I hate the feeling of busting my *** (flawless service) for a large amount of people only to be left with nothing.
Re: Restaurant holds family "hostage" for refusal to tip
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Hawkeye11en1
It's illegal to not pay the $9.99 for the burger, just like if it says you have to pay the 17% and you don't. It's part of the bill, part of what you are buying.
True.
Re: Restaurant holds family "hostage" for refusal to tip
A good manager will bend over backwards and remove the tip.
8 out of 10 people who have bad restaurant experiences correct immediately will come back.
A person is likely to tell 7 people about a bad experience at a restaurant.
Re: Restaurant holds family "hostage" for refusal to tip
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Hawkeye11en1
If it's stated, you gotta pay it. But it's still stupid to auto-add it.
You can't force someone to pay a gratuity. I'm sure that's exactly what it's called in that restaurant's policy, too. Call it a surcharge and you can make it mandatory.
But if they call it a gratuity, you don't have to pay it.
Re: Restaurant holds family "hostage" for refusal to tip
Quote:
Originally Posted by
CyFan61
You can't force someone to pay a gratuity. I'm sure that's exactly what it's called in that restaurant's policy, too. Call it a surcharge and you can make it mandatory.
But if they call it a gratuity, you don't have to pay it.
I don't care what you call it, it doesn't matter. If it states it will be added and that you have to pay it, you can call it whatever you want - but you are gonna have to pay it.
Re: Restaurant holds family "hostage" for refusal to tip
Quote:
Originally Posted by
mj4cy
A good manager will bend over backwards and remove the tip.
8 out of 10 people who have bad restaurant experiences correct immediately will come back.
A person is likely to tell 7 people about a bad experience at a restaurant.
I always tell 10.5 people about a bad experience. See, we Amish do everything half again as hard as you do.
7 people? That's for Quakers.
Re: Restaurant holds family "hostage" for refusal to tip
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Hawkeye11en1
If it's stated, you gotta pay it. But it's still stupid to auto-add it.
That's not necessarily true. I had a friend that paid cash on a check once that had gratuity added. His check was like $23 something and he gave the waiter $22 just to mess with him. The waiter saw it, but didn't do anything about it. He was kind of ******, but didn't say anything to my friend about not paying to whole bill.
(yes, he made good on the bill before anyone goes off on my friend.)