Fantasy Football: Trade Weigh In

[cjb1978]

This is the trade that is being proposed to me in a 10 team head-to-head PPR league in which my team and the other team are both 0-2

My Team
A. Rogers
J. Addai
Chicago Def

Other Team
R. Rice
R. Moreno
GB Def

This would leave me with the following players, (Starters going forward are in bold in which we start 2 qb, 2 rb, 3 wr, 1 te, 2 k, & 2 def

QB
C. Palmer
S. Bradford
J. Clausen

RB
Tolbert
A. Foster
J. Charles
R. Rice
R. Moreno

WR
M. Colston
M. Flloyd
D. Thomas
M. Clayton

TE
C. Cooley

K
N. Kaeding
R. Birnos
N. Folk

Def
Phily Def
GB Def

I don't think I am giving up too much as it would allow me to lockdown RB points as I don't have a true starter right now for my RB 2 position. Feedback?

[Clones21]

Why in the world do you have 3 QBs

[azn4cy]

no way you do this deal. look forward to a winless season if you're choosing between bradford, clausen and palmer every week.

[tman24]

I would keep rogers

[BooneCy]

no way you do this deal. look forward to a winless season if you're choosing between bradford, clausen and palmer every week.

Agreed. Rodgers and Addai are some points you are giving up for, IMO, is not equal to what you are getting.

[azn4cy]

Agreed. Rodgers and Addai are some points you are giving up for, IMO, is not equal to what you are getting.

The trade actually looks good by itself, but not for your team.

The weakness of your team is WRs right now. If you had to sacrifice Rodgers, you need to be able to get an top WR to pair with Colston, along with a mid tier QB.

[St810s]

Not a good trade for you. You would handicap yourself at quarterback and overload yourself at running back. No need for all those running back points to rot on your bench.

Maybe counter his trade by subtracting Moreno and adding whoever his starting QB is.

[CY ST8T]

Ray Rice gets you nothing right now and losing a stud like Rodgers kills your QB position. Stupid Trade

[cycopath25]

I say NO

[thatguy]

that would be world class stupid if you made that trade

side note: if you want to play in my league next year let me know.

[ISUCLONES15]

I agree with most everyone else. Bad deal for you. Keep Rodgers and be patient, he will start lighting it up soon.

[MisterTwister]

Don't make the trade man, you have Rodgers, the #1 QB in Fantasy this year.

Run with Foster, Addai, and Moreno this year as your RBs.

The person who asked why you have 3QB, I agree, drop one of those, but more importantly, drop 2 of your 3 kickers. Run with one until his bye week and just pick someone else.

That would free up 3 roster spots and pick up some WRs.

DON'T MAKE THE TRADE!!

[cjb1978]

Not going to make this trade after some further feedback/research. Going to ride Foster/Addai until the end of the season as my two main rb's and see if J. Charles gets the ball more often later this year.

[St810s]

Don't make the trade man, you have Rodgers, the #1 QB in Fantasy this year.

Run with Foster, Addai, and Moreno this year as your RBs.

The person who asked why you have 3QB, I agree, drop one of those, but more importantly, drop 2 of your 3 kickers. Run with one until his bye week and just pick someone else.

That would free up 3 roster spots and pick up some WRs.

DON'T MAKE THE TRADE!!

He said in his original post that his league STARTS 2 QB's and 2 kickers.

[chuckd4735]

Bad idea to accept/take that trade. If there is another Fantasy player under preforming more than Ray Rice this year I'd be surprised.