Here is an idea......
Since there are so many threads, probably hundreds a week, the recent threads (homepage) lists only replies to the top 10 most recent replies. I feel like I miss out on some very good threads and discussions, simply because they are pushed out by the latest betting board (you need help if you are gambling on European soccer).
How about on the homepage, list the recent threads by category. For example, list the 10 most recent threads for basketball. List the 10 most recent for football, the 10 most recent for off-topic, etc., but list them all on the homepage. You might have to condense some of the forums a bit, (currently there are 22, maybe condense down to about 12, politics could go into off-topic, betting board could merge with gaming, etc.) but it could easily work. That way you can go to the last 10 threads of what you want to read about (I love to read
MBB threads), and not have to try and find the thread because it has been replaced by the days latest Cubs score.