Gas or Charcoal?

What method do you prefer when you grill?

  • Gas - as Hank Hill says "taste the meat not the heat"

    Votes: 40 43.5%
  • Charcoal - just tastes better this way right?

    Votes: 43 46.7%
  • Other - maybe you like the caveman way of grilling with an open fire on a rotisserie spit?

    Votes: 9 9.8%

  • Total voters
    92

iahawks

Well-Known Member
Sep 7, 2012
11,648
8,305
113
Usually Memorial Day and maybe Labor, Home Depot will do a 2 for 1 Kingsford deal.

Yep, I take full advantage of those too, but I love the Weber charcoal, just not for $20. For. $3.90 a bag I wanted to stock up.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: JP4CY

Cutlass

Active Member
Mar 23, 2006
373
30
28
51
Omaha
ramblingscotty.blogspot.com
I love charcoal grilling. The whole experience of getting it all set up, getting the coals going just right, and enjoying a beer or two while all that happens is great.

However, I have 2 young kids. It's all gas at the Ctown house at this point.

My kids are 11 and 13 now so it's not much of an issue, but even when they were young I liked charcoal for that very reason. It was the only time I could sit down and drink a beer in peace. "No honey, I've got to stay out here and watch the charcoal. Some kid might get burned if I don't keep an eye on it."
 
  • Winner
Reactions: cyfan21

dmdom

Well-Known Member
Oct 28, 2014
731
596
93
I never liked the "charcoal taste" when I was younger.

I learned when I was older that I didn't like the taste of lighter fluid. :confused:
I've been known to use a chimney, propane torch, weed burner or douse some paper towels in vegetable oil. No need for the fluid.
 

dmdom

Well-Known Member
Oct 28, 2014
731
596
93
You need to figure the BTU s and the square inches of grilling surface when you purchase, my gas grill will go over 600° in the sun.
I only replaced 1/2 of the original grates with the grillgrates. Half of the grill is hot enough to properly grill steak the other half cooler for veggies and garlic bread.
 

dmdom

Well-Known Member
Oct 28, 2014
731
596
93
Timely topic. I did some rearranging in the garage to get to the snowblower. So I took a group photo. They are like golf clubs, each has its purpose. From left to right .
Char Broil CB940X this thing is a tank. Cast iron grates, adjustable height of cooking surface. Tall lid height. Bought it to make beer can chickens.
Coleman camp grill. My only gas grill. Used to warm up pans of brisket and pulled pork for 11am games.
Louisiana Grills Little Louie. Pellet grill. This is my go to workhorse when grilling. The burn pot is closer to the grate, so it gets hotter than a smoker. Tricked it out with some grillgrates.
Backwoods Smoker Patio model. Insulated charcoal smoker with water pan. No longer made and hard to find. This is the only one I've ever seen in person. Good for 2 racks of ribs, or 1 pork butt. I have only used it a couple times, but have previously owned 2 other Backwoods(Gator and Piglet). Awesome cookers!
Cookshack Smokers FEC 100. Insulated pellet smoker. Can be programmed so when meat reaches a certain temp it will ramp down to a holding temp. I use it when cooking for catering jobs. Will fit 16 butts at a time.
1995 Weber Kettle with rotisserie ring. My newest toy. I refurbished it last winter and added the ash catcher. Used for tailgating to make leg of lamb, tritip, whole chickens, and pork loin.
Now to decide what to make tomorrow. IMG_20190111_32823.jpg
 

CycloneDaddy

Well-Known Member
Sep 24, 2006
8,378
7,814
113
Johnston
Timely topic. I did some rearranging in the garage to get to the snowblower. So I took a group photo. They are like golf clubs, each has its purpose. From left to right .
Char Broil CB940X this thing is a tank. Cast iron grates, adjustable height of cooking surface. Tall lid height. Bought it to make beer can chickens.
Coleman camp grill. My only gas grill. Used to warm up pans of brisket and pulled pork for 11am games.
Louisiana Grills Little Louie. Pellet grill. This is my go to workhorse when grilling. The burn pot is closer to the grate, so it gets hotter than a smoker. Tricked it out with some grillgrates.
Backwoods Smoker Patio model. Insulated charcoal smoker with water pan. No longer made and hard to find. This is the only one I've ever seen in person. Good for 2 racks of ribs, or 1 pork butt. I have only used it a couple times, but have previously owned 2 other Backwoods(Gator and Piglet). Awesome cookers!
Cookshack Smokers FEC 100. Insulated pellet smoker. Can be programmed so when meat reaches a certain temp it will ramp down to a holding temp. I use it when cooking for catering jobs. Will fit 16 butts at a time.
1995 Weber Kettle with rotisserie ring. My newest toy. I refurbished it last winter and added the ash catcher. Used for tailgating to make leg of lamb, tritip, whole chickens, and pork loin.
Now to decide what to make tomorrow. View attachment 61540
You might need therapy.
 

cstrunk

Well-Known Member
Mar 21, 2006
14,453
4,866
113
38
Longview, TX
I voted for other because I love my pellet grill. Get smoke and grill in one. I usually smoke for a while and finish it off on higher heat setting to grill it. My wife and I both agree that our Traeger has been one of the best investments we made!

I also recently bought a Traeger Junior Elite. I love it.

Smoking a steak for 30 mins and then cranking it up to finish it is my favorite thing ever.
 

cyfan21

Well-Known Member
Aug 24, 2010
1,692
1,406
113
Davenport
Charcoal for me. I will say that not all chimneys are created equal. Mine takes about 30 minutes to get going. Have noticed that the Weber version can cut that in half. My frustrations with my chimney lead me to develop a poor man’s BBQ Dragon. Take an electric heat gun and light the charcoal in about three places with it, then take a small auxiliary fan, point it where I want, and turn it on. Ready to cook in about 15 minutes tops - screaming hot. For the most part, this has put our gas grill out of business.
Why don’t you try having a cocktail while the grill heats up?
 

Blandboy

Well-Known Member
Mar 31, 2006
5,920
3,367
113
Bettendorf
Still cook on it in the winter too. Smoked a pork butt on it two weekends ago (on the grill, not the smoker) with two apple wood chunks. Worked flawlessly.

I like pork butts and I cannot lie!

Pulled pork off the Weber is a New Year’s Day tradition at our house. Nothing like down-coat cook’n to kick off a new year.
 

CtownCyclone

Midnight Rider
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Jan 20, 2010
16,831
9,127
113
Where they love the governor
My kids are 11 and 13 now so it's not much of an issue, but even when they were young I liked charcoal for that very reason. It was the only time I could sit down and drink a beer in peace. "No honey, I've got to stay out here and watch the charcoal. Some kid might get burned if I don't keep an eye on it."

I've used that angle in the past, and it's a good one.