1) Because Toledo will never have an opportunity to play in a BCS playoff. And Yes ISU is a longshot too. But they do have a more viable path with an opportunity to compete in a conference that at least is 1 of 5 considered for the playoffs.
2) He was and the move to ISU still allowed him to work with young men at higher level with lots of untapped resources and to achieve things underheard of when talking ISU football
3) I am not sure what that question means. So I will simply say, when having to work with millionaires, the ability to influence are more challenging. Harder to change the culture of an NFL team vs a collegiate one. You depend more on GM's and guys who write checks than you do your own staff.
Best I got. And you are right, he could reach a point in his life where his approach to things will change.
While ISU doesn't pay the BIGGEST money, it's better than Toledo as well. From the topic of this thread we know CMC is not all about the money, but there's a big difference between around 1M at Toledo and 4M at ISU. It would be like the Lions offering him 16M instead of 8. Harder to pass up.
The financial support of the program seems to be a HUGE thing for CMC as well. ISU has raised salaries for his assistants consistently. That means his guys stick around longer and he can do his best work as a coach. At Toledo with continued success he would lose assistants regularly. That's just how things go at that level. Everyone needs to build there resume so they can get a better job.
Matt noted the fan support at ISU when he took the job. I know there are great fans at Toledo, but these were the numbers for 2018:
"The University of Toledo finished No. 1 in the Mid-American Conference in home football attendance for the second consecutive season with an average of 21,352 fans per game in 2018, well above the MAC average of 15,532. The Rockets totaled 149,462"
CMC saw sellout crowds (or nearly) for Paul Rhoads to play a noncon game against Toledo. That has to have made think about what he could do with that kind of support. And he proved it 100%
SO many things go into decisions like these.