Tyrese Hunter Entering the Transfer Portal - NIL Speculation

IsUaClone2

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
May 12, 2006
2,808
1,756
113
81
Northville, MI
I have questions.
1. Can shoe companies form their own collectives? I would find this especially offensive if they did and then the NCAA dropped pending charges because the previous perpetrators did nothing different than what is now permissible; pay a few bucks to the IRS and the slates would be clean.
2. Can collective agents sign a number of kids, then shop groups to schools? It would turn coaches from recruiters to fundraisers.

I find this first NIL process disheartening for two reasons. First, ISU will not be competitive with the blue bloods because our donor-base is smaller in numbers and have fewer resources. Regional NIL opportunities are smaller because of the smaller population base.

Secondly, if you broke the fan base into those who were fans because they loved the school and underdogs (Hearts) and those who want to be associated with winners or tradition (Braggers), I think you'd find the percentage of Hearts to Braggers is higher at ISU than many other schools. The current NIL process really benefits Braggers. It may make marketing sense but it really damages school loyalty.
 
  • Winner
  • Like
Reactions: LindenCy and NWICY

Gunnerclone

Well-Known Member
Jul 16, 2010
75,683
80,078
113
DSM
Nobody is saying it’s a celebrity endorsement or that it matters that people like or trust Nijel Pack. You’re saying it’s a good use of $800k because it’s “getting their name out there”

In order for this to get their name out there, people have to be aware of the story. The number of people hearing about this is small, because Pack going from KSU to Miami is a tiny blip on the sports radar and is zero outside of sports. And that doesn’t even consider how few that are aware of the story are going to get the LifeWallet aspect of the story.

The only way they are getting pub is in the “hey, for some reason this company is spending $10m on getting college boys to play sports in Florida,” sort of way.

I’m a Big 12 basketball fan following NIL closely, and until 5 mins ago and searching it again I thought it was NerdWallet paying Pack.

That’s funny because people here have me believing Nigel Pack is the greatest player in the history of college basketball.
 

awd4cy

Well-Known Member
Dec 29, 2010
28,014
19,627
113
Central Iowa
It will be worse than that. Hilton will be legitimately unsafe for him. It will be ugly and ISU will end up looking bad because of decisions and circumstances he made.

He really needs to pick a school out of conference and 500+ miles away.
Eh, so be it.
 

Halincandenza

Well-Known Member
Oct 24, 2018
9,434
10,262
113
I have questions.
1. Can shoe companies form their own collectives? I would find this especially offensive if they did and then the NCAA dropped pending charges because the previous perpetrators did nothing different than what is now permissible; pay a few bucks to the IRS and the slates would be clean.
2. Can collective agents sign a number of kids, then shop groups to schools? It would turn coaches from recruiters to fundraisers.

I find this first NIL process disheartening for two reasons. First, ISU will not be competitive with the blue bloods because our donor-base is smaller in numbers and have fewer resources. Regional NIL opportunities are smaller because of the smaller population base.

Secondly, if you broke the fan base into those who were fans because they loved the school and underdogs (Hearts) and those who want to be associated with winners or tradition (Braggers), I think you'd find the percentage of Hearts to Braggers is higher at ISU than many other schools. The current NIL process really benefits Braggers. It may make marketing sense but it really damages school loyalty.
Yes shoe companies can endorse players and give them money.
 
  • Informative
Reactions: IsUaClone2

AuH2O

Well-Known Member
Sep 7, 2013
13,054
21,050
113
That’s funny because people here have me believing Nigel Pack is the greatest player in the history of college basketball.
No it doesn’t matter. Spending millions on getting pretty much anonymous college athletes in a sea of transfers to go play at colleges no one pays attention to is great marketing.

Winning in the dark, marketing style.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: CYDJ

WalkingCY

Well-Known Member
Sep 26, 2008
6,895
2,592
113
Kansas City
Look at Zion. He got paid to go to Duke and KU was working with Adidas to get him to be a Jayhawk

Which begs the question, should ISU be looking for a replacement for Nike? They basically see ISU as a bottom rung of their schools that they outfit. And I also believe it has been shared here on CF that ISU doesn't see a whole lot of money from Nike in the first place, so they sure as hell have NEVER been steering any athlete to go to school in Ames.

Shouldn't ISU leadership talk/look at other companies that could possibly help out out more? (Under Armour for instance?)
 
  • Creative
Reactions: isufbcurt

CRcyclone6

Well-Known Member
Bookie
Dec 27, 2007
12,152
4,098
113
54
Cedar Rapids
Which begs the question, should ISU be looking for a replacement for Nike? They basically see ISU as a bottom rung of their schools that they outfit. And I also believe it has been shared here on CF that ISU doesn't see a whole lot of money from Nike in the first place, so they sure as hell have NEVER been steering any athlete to go to school in Ames.

Shouldn't ISU leadership talk/look at other companies that could possibly help out out more? (Under Armour for instance?)
Go back to Pony or Reebok!
 

3TrueFans

Just a Happily Married Man
Sep 10, 2009
63,264
61,966
113
Ames
Which begs the question, should ISU be looking for a replacement for Nike? They basically see ISU as a bottom rung of their schools that they outfit. And I also believe it has been shared here on CF that ISU doesn't see a whole lot of money from Nike in the first place, so they sure as hell have NEVER been steering any athlete to go to school in Ames.

Shouldn't ISU leadership talk/look at other companies that could possibly help out out more? (Under Armour for instance?)
Go somewhere we'll be top of the food chain, a Fila or New Balance deal maybe? I don't know if they make jerseys.
 

AuH2O

Well-Known Member
Sep 7, 2013
13,054
21,050
113
Which begs the question, should ISU be looking for a replacement for Nike? They basically see ISU as a bottom rung of their schools that they outfit. And I also believe it has been shared here on CF that ISU doesn't see a whole lot of money from Nike in the first place, so they sure as hell have NEVER been steering any athlete to go to school in Ames.

Shouldn't ISU leadership talk/look at other companies that could possibly help out out more? (Under Armour for instance?)
I'd go for Apex. They gave the world these beauties:


Or maybe Tanel - they made those revolutionary 360 degree pivot cleats back in the early 90s. And I'm shocked to see that they still survive:

 

allfourcy

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Apr 26, 2012
6,950
2,983
113
Which begs the question, should ISU be looking for a replacement for Nike? They basically see ISU as a bottom rung of their schools that they outfit. And I also believe it has been shared here on CF that ISU doesn't see a whole lot of money from Nike in the first place, so they sure as hell have NEVER been steering any athlete to go to school in Ames.

Shouldn't ISU leadership talk/look at other companies that could possibly help out out more? (Under Armour for instance?)
Hmmm...like the question. Under Armour is pretty popular, too, correct?

What's going to keep 'outsiders' contributing to another school? For example, can Arkansas, LSU, Auburn, etc. donors give to each others NIL fun to help dethrone Alabama. I know, absurd idea.
 

heitclone

Well-Known Member
Jun 21, 2009
16,631
14,436
113
45
Way up there
IDk why people think Hunter getting booed is a bad look. It's college sports. Now, if there are older fans making personal comments or attacks, that's one thing but a coordinated effort from the student section is just part of the fun of college sports. Think Marcus Smart flop type of stuff. He totally deserves some flack but it doesn't have to be ruthless.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: NorthCyd

Gunnerclone

Well-Known Member
Jul 16, 2010
75,683
80,078
113
DSM
Which begs the question, should ISU be looking for a replacement for Nike? They basically see ISU as a bottom rung of their schools that they outfit. And I also believe it has been shared here on CF that ISU doesn't see a whole lot of money from Nike in the first place, so they sure as hell have NEVER been steering any athlete to go to school in Ames.

Shouldn't ISU leadership talk/look at other companies that could possibly help out out more? (Under Armour for instance?)

Kids will flock here if we can lock down that Skechers deal.
 

CascadeClone

Well-Known Member
Oct 24, 2009
10,939
14,063
113
I find this first NIL process disheartening for two reasons. First, ISU will not be competitive with the blue bloods because our donor-base is smaller in numbers and have fewer resources. Regional NIL opportunities are smaller because of the smaller population base.

Dude, we are not going to be competitive with our peers like KSU and OSU. We were never competitive with the blue bloods.

I am in wait and see mode, and I hope some rules are enacted. But if there is zero competitive balance in MBB and CFB, then I won't follow either anymore, including Iowa State. I mean, it's unbalanced now, but like 60/40 - upstarts can still rise if they get the right AD and coach and keep them around (e.g. Baylor, KSU under the Wizard). But the gap looks to be increasing by a magnitude or two. It will be a joke, and this may push the NFL-Lite model a lot more than conference re-alignment.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: CYDJ and Remo Gaggi

1UNI2ISU

Well-Known Member
Jan 30, 2013
9,112
12,237
113
Waterloo
Which begs the question, should ISU be looking for a replacement for Nike? They basically see ISU as a bottom rung of their schools that they outfit. And I also believe it has been shared here on CF that ISU doesn't see a whole lot of money from Nike in the first place, so they sure as hell have NEVER been steering any athlete to go to school in Ames.

Shouldn't ISU leadership talk/look at other companies that could possibly help out out more? (Under Armour for instance?)
I'll tell you that UNI looked a switching to UA for everything but MBB before the 2019-20 season and UA gave them a bunch of football cleats for spring practice that year and they couldn't get through practice without several blowing out during each practice. They boxed them all up and shipped them back after a week and re-upped with Nike immediately.