I like the briefness of the post. Right to the point.
Craig McDonald transferring
- Thread starter FeedBreece
- Start date
I like the briefness of the post. Right to the point.
Yeah, not sure what's going on with the secondary room/CMcD at this point, but prefer this to the lengthy 3-4 paragraph BS about how much they loved Iowa State and Ames even though they're leaving with ample eligibility, that we get with most guys
I don't think that McDonald is that much better than Verdon. He just has an advantage in experience. Verdon played a lot of QB in HS and has been at ISU less than a year. He's going to be a good player, but I would guess he's still pretty raw.
The briefness of the post and fact that we heard nothing prior is telling that it was a sudden, unexpected move. I mean even the players who are with him everyday were surprised.
The Eisworth scout was one of the best our staff has done so far. And there are a lot of good ones (Enyi, Purdy, Rose, Kolar, X, Will McDonald, etc.). If they get anywhere close to that on Thompson, we don't have to worry much about Safety depth.
I feel kind of bad for Eisworth. I feel like we kind of "used him up". I think the way he played took a huge toll on his body and he left ISU not the same player that arrived. Let's hope he has new life in the NFL.
Could probably say the same of Mike Rose. He played too many snaps at the collegiate level. Played as a true FR
I don't disagree with the idea that many guys (King, Amos, Miller, Antoine, etc.) left for playing time. I believe Isheem Young would have started next year (we start 3, I think he would have been one, maybe i am wrong, will never know now). So, I would argue, we now have lost 2 guys that would be starting next year, two guys that may even be drafted in the next few years.
Bottom line, in just about every stat, the DBs in the Transfer Portal out performed the DBs returning. Does this mean a guy like Porter or one of the new guys coming in won't be able to out perform what the guys that transferred out would have given us in 2022? Obviously not. But we lost a lot of depth, a lot of snaps, and a couple starters in my opinion.
Games Played in (with DB Stats Recorded):
Total: 109
Return: 42
Transfer: 54
Grad: 13
Tackles (Not counting Porter's 13 on ST):
Total: 356
Return: 130
Transfer: 166
Grad: 60
Turnovers (INT/Fumble Recoveries):
Total: 10
Return: 0
Transfer: 8
Grad: 2
(Forced Fumbles: 4 total, 2 Return, 2 Transfer)
Bottom line, in just about every stat, the DBs in the Transfer Portal out performed the DBs returning. Does this mean a guy like Porter or one of the new guys coming in won't be able to out perform what the guys that transferred out would have given us in 2022? Obviously not. But we lost a lot of depth, a lot of snaps, and a couple starters in my opinion.
Games Played in (with DB Stats Recorded):
Total: 109
Return: 42
Transfer: 54
Grad: 13
Tackles (Not counting Porter's 13 on ST):
Total: 356
Return: 130
Transfer: 166
Grad: 60
Turnovers (INT/Fumble Recoveries):
Total: 10
Return: 0
Transfer: 8
Grad: 2
(Forced Fumbles: 4 total, 2 Return, 2 Transfer)
Last edited:
We lost a ton in the DB room (wrote another post with details). Bottom line, I believe we are a developmental program. We have guys like McDonald who played 1 game in 2020, develop in 2021 into what would have been a game 1 starter in 2022.
Guys like King probably were being passed up by guys behind them. But with all the attrition, I would argue even some of those guys would likely be on a 2 deep right now.
Yes, we have guys like Porter (special teams a year ago), the Juco Transfer, some true freshmen, we all hope will be great pieces. But our DBs forced 10 turn overs and had 356 tackles a year ago. We have more tackles (166) in the portal than returning to the team (130). Of the 10 turnovers, 8 were from guys in the portal the other 2 were Eisworth. None return.
Even if the Juco kid is good I think we lost 2 guys that would have started (Isheem Young, McDonald) and a ton of depth which is critical - separates good/great from ok/bad teams.
I wouldn’t read too much into it….people make changes all the time and there’s probably 20 different variables that all played a part in his decision. I don’t think this reflects on CMC or Coach Broom.
I help run a small company and we see the same thing: people leave because they get their feelings hurt, or someone didn’t greet them when they thought they should, or a competitor offered them a little more money (even though we offer a better culture and work environment in my biased opinion), they break up with their significant other…and on and on. Then you factor in these are 19/20 year-old kids were dealing with in college. I don’t envy CMC’s position.
We need to keep building with people that actually want to be here…if you don’t want to be here, best of luck to you and there’s the door.
I help run a small company and we see the same thing: people leave because they get their feelings hurt, or someone didn’t greet them when they thought they should, or a competitor offered them a little more money (even though we offer a better culture and work environment in my biased opinion), they break up with their significant other…and on and on. Then you factor in these are 19/20 year-old kids were dealing with in college. I don’t envy CMC’s position.
We need to keep building with people that actually want to be here…if you don’t want to be here, best of luck to you and there’s the door.
So then add to the conversation if you know all the answers. How do you know Heacock isn't switching things up?
have not read all 13 pages here, so sorry if I am repeating something already said.
April 20th: McDonald announced his planned camp on twtter...
April 28th: McDonald says "camp has been postponed due to weather check new date" (it was supposed to be Apr 30th not sure if there was bad weather in the forecast? I live out of state now so do not keep up with the weather)
April 30th: He is in the portal
Maybe the camp did get postponed "due to weather" and it is just a coincidence that he entered the portal a couple days later... but that seems really odd.
Did ISU know about the camp? What made him change the date? Did they ask him not to have it?
Something happened in the 10 days between announcing a football camp and then suddenly changing the date, and transferring.
They could be unrelated (maybe he had full approval / support from ISU coaches to run the camp). Trevon Howard (still on the team) was also supposed to participate along with "other" ISU athletes. So, let's see if the camp goes forward on May 21st (new date) and if any ISU football players participate.
Also, CM and Trevon Howard seem to be big on the NIL stuff. This is not a bad thing - more power to them, hope they make a bunch of $. But I could also see this as a situation where he was offered an opportunity to make more... again, may have nothing to do with a pay-for-play deal ("NIL") but if he signs with a mid tier SEC team or a team at the "neb" type of level (lots of fan support, likely trying to compete) this is exactly the type of player you go after. You are not going to out bid tex a&m, tOSU, etc. for top guys. But you don't need to. You grab rising talent from good programs pay them and they burn their free transfer. So, unless they want to sit out a year you have them for the rest of their eligibility.
April 20th: McDonald announced his planned camp on twtter...
April 28th: McDonald says "camp has been postponed due to weather check new date" (it was supposed to be Apr 30th not sure if there was bad weather in the forecast? I live out of state now so do not keep up with the weather)
April 30th: He is in the portal
Maybe the camp did get postponed "due to weather" and it is just a coincidence that he entered the portal a couple days later... but that seems really odd.
Did ISU know about the camp? What made him change the date? Did they ask him not to have it?
Something happened in the 10 days between announcing a football camp and then suddenly changing the date, and transferring.
They could be unrelated (maybe he had full approval / support from ISU coaches to run the camp). Trevon Howard (still on the team) was also supposed to participate along with "other" ISU athletes. So, let's see if the camp goes forward on May 21st (new date) and if any ISU football players participate.
Also, CM and Trevon Howard seem to be big on the NIL stuff. This is not a bad thing - more power to them, hope they make a bunch of $. But I could also see this as a situation where he was offered an opportunity to make more... again, may have nothing to do with a pay-for-play deal ("NIL") but if he signs with a mid tier SEC team or a team at the "neb" type of level (lots of fan support, likely trying to compete) this is exactly the type of player you go after. You are not going to out bid tex a&m, tOSU, etc. for top guys. But you don't need to. You grab rising talent from good programs pay them and they burn their free transfer. So, unless they want to sit out a year you have them for the rest of their eligibility.
Last edited:
I don't think we should read too much into the briefness of the post. Some people are just more direct.
Like someone else said above, I appreciate the brevity of the post. I don't need to read three paragraphs of fluff and you thanking everyone from the RA in your dorm to God for the great year you had in Ames.
It went from NFL bound to D1 safety and was pushed to May 20 something. Which im guessing isnt happening anymore.
My7on7 Football Leagues, Training, and Tournaments
www.my7on7.com
Latest posts
-
-
RELEASE: ISU head coach Matt Campbell's contract extended through 2032- Latest: Blackhawk6515
-
-
If ISU could schedule KSU as non-conference, would you want them to?- Latest: 1TwistedCyclone
-
