Reputation-wise, maybe. That said, Pusilic has talent that neither Dempsey nor Donovan have, though. Pusilic has pretty much spent his entire career playing and training with the best clubs in Europe, whereas both Dempsey and Donovan had to work their asses off in America just to get looked at over there. That should tell you what the best in the world thinks of his talent.
By the end of his career, Pusilic will have far surpassed both.
That is also why I used the word "prodigy" - Pusilic is; Dempsey and Donovan weren't.
The only one I'd put him with recently is Howard.