Listening to CW and Blum's Sunday pod.....I think the fan base is tired of playing in this bowl and getting snubbed for opponents every time.
We have played Tulsa and now Memphis twice. Yes, I would rather play a Kentucky or an Auburn or Texas A&M.
Plus I was at the Liberty Bowl in 2017 and while the win was fun, we have been so unlucky with weather down there and Liberty Bowl Stadium is a dump.
I get your point about opponents, that’s the big downside here.
But I keep hearing the “the stadium is a dump” line for why this isn’t a good bowl game for ISU. Who cares what the stadium is like…that Memphis/ISU matchup in the dump of a stadium was a top 10-20 fun experience for me and I’ve attended well over 150 Iowa State football games. Conversely, the UNLV stadium was amazing but that didn’t contribute to making it a top ISU game to watch in person.
Bowl games and games like at UNLV are fun because of the total fan experience and not the quality of the stadium, or even the opponent at times.
My guess is that many people that are vocally complaining 1) haven’t been there before and 2) have no intent on going.