Big 12 Conference Realignment

MugNight

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Jul 27, 2021
2,233
4,083
113
It’s not because it was a freeking global pandemic. Guess what, the Big12 is made up of a bunch of southern/red states. I’m not going to get political here but if you can’t look at the makeup of the big ten states/schools vs the Big12 and figure out why the conferences approached things different then were just not going to be able to get anywhere.

Totally agree that I have no problem holding OSU out that year but again it was a pandemic season that is a compete and total outlier. TCU got in 2 seasons ago when the same people on here were screaming about how it had zero chance of happening because of bias but the games do matter and thus TCU got in.
2020 was an absurd year, and yes the XII is generally redder than the B1G* but there are arguments about the Rust Belt I’m not gonna post here because it’s irrelevant.

IIRC, the big issue with OSU is that Indiana won the B1G won the East that season but the league crumbled and removed the min 6 game requirement for a conf champion. Yes, OSU beat IU by a touchdown head to head. But rules are rules and from where I stand, the B1G bended its rules to push the Buckeyes ahead.

All I’m saying i would be furious if I was a Hoosier. And Cyclones and Hoosiers have a lot more in common that Cyclones and Buckeyes (even if casual fans confuse us all the time ;))
 
Last edited:
  • Agree
Reactions: FriendlySpartan

CyCrazy

Well-Known Member
Dec 17, 2008
27,065
15,299
113
Ames
It was a Covid year. It doesn’t count and you can’t draw anything from it. No one does, it’s why everyone got an extra year of eligibility because the year was so far off what you can expect. I have zero problem with you saying TCU should have gotten in and I even agree but it’s also a covid year that you legit can’t extrapolate anything from.

Covid year didnt count? Big 12 and SEC sacked up and played. B10 only did when pressured. Doesnt count my arse.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: 2speedy1

FriendlySpartan

Well-Known Member
Jul 26, 2021
9,611
10,101
113
38
It was an outlier for the B1G maybe. The rest of us, not so much. The "global pandemic" didnt effect our lives as much as some wanted it to. The only time it did is when we let others control us and our decisions.

You might be fine with holding out OSU, that year, but the thing is, it still happened. They still got special treatment. You can deny it happened and say you are fine with ignoring it, but all that does is prove you want to ignore the obvious bias and special treatment. It is really convenient that you just want to ignore that.

Comparing OSUs special treatment to TCU in 23 where they obviously earned their way in with only 1 loss, but also ignoring the season where both TCU and Baylor were left out is rich. It just shows how biased you are, and its cute that you are willing to ignore the single most obvious season and playoff that completely shows the special treatment the B1G gets.

**** the Big Ten. Tired of the bias and their holier than thou attitudes and treatement.
Not going to cave this by getting political but your first paragraph tells me everything I need to know so appreciate that
 

jdoggivjc

Well-Known Member
Sep 27, 2006
61,625
23,880
113
Macomb, MI
Not going to cave this by getting political but your first paragraph tells me everything I need to know so appreciate that

Yeah, not trying to cave it either, but people who are of the opinion that COVID didn't affect our lives never were aware of the situation in hospitals in big metro areas, such as Detroit, where I live. My wife, who needed an emergency surgery during the height of COVID for an unrelated issue to COVID, had to settle for a hospital bed in a crowded hallway because the hospital was overrun with patients infected with COVID who up to that point didn't think COVID was a big deal and as a result were dying due to the illness and their own stupidity. It was that way for years.
 

Cymark86

Well-Known Member
Dec 2, 2023
382
378
63
57
When outkick idiots are using the word “controversial “ for the Big 12 getting one, I really can’t see the committee being likely to consider two very many times.
100% agree. But we’ve done ourselves no favors by being pretty much non competitive in the playoff. Cements the narrative whether true or not.

And we have helped the cause with our spitting the bit against Hawks. I think we’ve had overall better talent the last 5 years and yet….
 

jctisu

Well-Known Member
Jun 11, 2017
8,726
10,674
113
I’m officially confused. Many loud mouths on here have said our COVID season didn’t count and try to minimize what we accomplished that year. Now I see some of those same folks saying how the COVID season was legit because it helps their argument against the Ohio State inclusion and this ongoing battle with our Spartan fan visitor. Well which is it?

And yes I don’t think Ohio State had any business being in the CFP that season.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FriendlySpartan

Cloned4Life

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Mar 5, 2006
3,606
3,366
113
The national narrative changes when the Big 12 starts to win…
And some people think the Iowa game on our schedule somehow isn’t as important as conference games…

The Big 12, collectively, has to find a way to win as many non-conference football games against P4 as possible. Year after year. Early season, bowl games, whatever. It’s one of the most critical ‘things’ for the conference…
 

2speedy1

Well-Known Member
Jan 4, 2014
6,634
7,487
113
I’m officially confused. Many loud mouths on here have said our COVID season didn’t count and try to minimize what we accomplished that year. Now I see some of those same folks saying how the COVID season was legit because it helps their argument against the Ohio State inclusion and this ongoing battle with our Spartan fan visitor. Well which is it?

And yes I don’t think Ohio State had any business being in the CFP that season.
Wait, you have heard, Cyclone fans say the covid year didnt count? Or our inports? Because if you have or do hear a Cyclone fan saying that year doesnt count, please Slap them as hard as you can.
 

HFCS

Well-Known Member
Aug 13, 2010
75,663
65,957
113
LA LA Land
Wait, you have heard, Cyclone fans say the covid year didnt count? Or our inports? Because if you have or do hear a Cyclone fan saying that year doesnt count, please Slap them as hard as you can.

I can't stand the Lakers but it annoys the hell out of me when people discount the bubble NBA title. You locked up the best basketball players in the world where they did nothing but focus on basketball and somehow that...makes the basketball not count??? They played a 72 game season and full 16 team playoff.

I'm generally not one of the over the top LeBron fan boys but it's the weakest argument his detractors make against him.
 

2speedy1

Well-Known Member
Jan 4, 2014
6,634
7,487
113
I can't stand the Lakers but it annoys the hell out of me when people discount the bubble NBA title. You locked up the best basketball players in the world where they did nothing but focus on basketball and somehow that...makes the basketball not count??? They played a 72 game season and full 16 team playoff.

I'm generally not one of the over the top LeBron fan boys but it's the weakest argument his detractors make against him.
In some respects, I would say it was more of a challenge to win in that year than not, so myself I give people more credit for succeeding when so much was against them.

The teams that succeeded managed to stay healthy, managed to overcome all the shutdowns, managed to play the games, and managed to come out on top. (outside those like OSU who was all but gifted the playoff while not even trying to compete)
 

jctisu

Well-Known Member
Jun 11, 2017
8,726
10,674
113
Wait, you have heard, Cyclone fans say the covid year didnt count? Or our inports? Because if you have or do hear a Cyclone fan saying that year doesnt count, please Slap them as hard as you can.
Oh I do and there have been several on this board over the years. They are the typical woe is me folks, and especially bring it out when we struggle in September. Last year after the Ohio game there were a bunch of them because “Matt’s really on the hot seat. He’s been pretty good, but the big season we had was due to COVID and we just got lucky that we didn’t get hit by it like most of our opponents.”

That type of BS.
 

jctisu

Well-Known Member
Jun 11, 2017
8,726
10,674
113
I think the Covid year was a Campbell masterpiece. He saw the opportunity presented with a disciplined team that as the season wore on avoided Covid illness that undisciplined teams could not.
Yep. This is the point. How dare we navigate the pandemic as well as we did? And lest we forget, the stories came out after the season that Covid hit us pretty hard in fall camp leading up to the Louisiana game.

And look, yes teams were depleted at times (KSU for example) but we were clicking on all cylinders including beating OU and absolutely **** stomping several others by season’s end.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kinch

2speedy1

Well-Known Member
Jan 4, 2014
6,634
7,487
113
Oh I do and there have been several on this board over the years. They are the typical woe is me folks, and especially bring it out when we struggle in September. Last year after the Ohio game there were a bunch of them because “Matt’s really on the hot seat. He’s been pretty good, but the big season we had was due to COVID and we just got lucky that we didn’t get hit by it like most of our opponents.”

That type of BS.
Uh we did get hit just like the others. We managed it better through the season. But we lost that first game that year partly because a lot of the team had been in quarranteen up to that game and had little to no practice leading up to it.

But we played, and took our licks, and get all kinds of crap for losing that game. Yet teams like OSU just flat out cancelled games to avoid losing and no one talks about it. Teams like KSU used it as an excuse why they lost, yet continue to degrade us for losing that first game, because our issues didnt matter.

Covid caused issues but for some, we dealt with them and sacked up and played. For others they hid in their closets and avoided playing cuz they might lose, then got rewarded for being too scared to play the games, because they were afraid missing a player or two might cost them the game. The entire system was a joke, and proved just how biased it is.
 

IceCyIce

Well-Known Member
Aug 17, 2009
2,631
1,643
113
Grimes
Either you guys dont understand how the playoff works or you’re being extremely over sensitive .
I guess my point was/is that Iowa State has a history of nut cup striking over the years. If it's left up to humans and TV to decide, we more often than not get hosed
 

Cyforce

Well-Known Member
Nov 24, 2009
17,217
13,063
113
Des Moines
2020 was an absurd year, and yes the XII is generally redder than the B1G* but there are arguments about the Rust Belt I’m not gonna post here because it’s irrelevant.

IIRC, the big issue with OSU is that Indiana won the B1G won the East that season but the league crumbled and removed the min 6 game requirement for a conf champion. Yes, OSU beat IU by a touchdown head to head. But rules are rules and from where I stand, the B1G bended its rules to push the Buckeyes ahead.

All I’m saying i would be furious if I was a Hoosier. And Cyclones and Hoosiers have a lot more in common that Cyclones and Buckeyes (even if casual fans confuse us all the time ;))
tOSU had the minimum required players/positions to play per the conference guidelines but chose not to play i believe Illinois so they basically said we don't feel we can field a competitive team and canceled. If it was anyone else it would of been a forfeit. But the conference caved on the rules they set.
 

cyatheart

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Nov 18, 2008
9,434
6,943
113
49
Of course it would be nice to make the playoffs and win. But that is not the point. The playing field is not level in the new playoff format, nor in the media contracts between the current P4. That is the real issue. There is no plan to make it more level. The system we find ourselves in is on the verge of ruining college athletics. Realignment is a mess, everything is on fire. That' how I see it. Telling us that we merely need to win a game, if we are so lucky to partake is not what this conversation needs. But we continue to hear it.

And I don't have an answer as to where college FB and athletics needs to go, next. Not in the current direction, that is clear to me. It is out of control and the inmates are in charge of the asylum.

To try to play dumb and just say "win the game" if you get in is being disingenuous at best.
Right, win the games. Got it. We have 1/4 of the resources that Purdue or NW has. It’s stupid.
 

cyatheart

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Nov 18, 2008
9,434
6,943
113
49
SEC has had this thing in a PERFECT spot for years.

They're very consistently the best conference but they've maneuvered in a way where their teams don't all play the toughest schedules. I actually don't blame people for not seeing it, it works briliantly.
Correct, look at Texas schedule, very very soft. Way easier than a big 12 schedule.