Lunardi and Palm now project Iowa State as a 4-seed as Selection Sunday nears

bawbie

Moderator
Staff member
Mar 17, 2006
54,367
47,057
113
Cedar Rapids, IA
Can you imagine being a 2-seed and having to play the winner of Kansas / Drake in the second round? I feel like either Kansas (if they get their heads on straight) or Drake would kill St Johns

Or even a 1-seed and playing the two-time national champ - or the winner of Gonzaga/Creighton. Those would be unpleasant second round matchups.
 

madguy30

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Nov 15, 2011
57,330
55,232
113
3pt defense % is largely random. BYU is a good shooting team - but it was just as much luck as defense that they went 18-36 against us and 6-28 against Houston. Hell, they scored as many points against us from 3-pt shots as they scored against Houston TOTAL.

Friday Houston had BYU uncomfortable from the start. BYU had to make the shots but Houston has the athletes to play straight up and generally guards the perimeter better. Conversely I think Houston's much more patient on offense which helped to limit BYU possessions.

Even before the injuries ISU was late getting to try to run off the shooter or tbh in some games their guards simply watched. Iirc TJ mentioned it a few times in post-game comments in regards to effort and not just putting a hand out and thinking that's enough.

I thought ISU was the most effective on Thursday when they held off the trap and just defended and wish they would have stayed with that a bit more for effectiveness and to reserve energy for late. But maybe there was something else involved to still trap.
 
  • Like
Reactions: cyatheart

bawbie

Moderator
Staff member
Mar 17, 2006
54,367
47,057
113
Cedar Rapids, IA
If you consider TTU and UK as "locks" on the 3-line; then the last 2 three seeds come down to:
Iowa State
Wisconsin
Maryland
TAMU

And we have 2 more Q1 wins that either of them (10,8,8,7). We are the only ones with 2 Q2 losses - but injuries are supposed to be accounted for, and we were down key starters in both of those losses.

We are also the highest of those 4 in NET, kenpom, BPI & T-Rank.

So I think we should clearly be on the 3-line, but I bet we get bumped to the 4. Not that it really matters - of the 5/6 seeds, Clemson is the only one would really worry me - other than I don't want another matchup with Illinois.
 

NYCYFan

Well-Known Member
Mar 18, 2024
493
660
93
So Auburn should drop then to a 2 right? Lost three of four
Ridiculous analogy. Auburn has piled up a bunch of quality wins in the last few months and lost at the buzzer against Alabama, to A&M on the road and down the wire against Tennessee. Iowa State lost to West Virginia, Kansas State and Oklahoma State.

Sorry and maybe it upsets people but Iowa State hasn't done much in the last 2 months. Two bad losses and in the last 2 months beat UCF twice, Arizona State, TCU, Cincy twice, Colorado and Kansas State. Arizona was the only quality win. Iowa State has a strong OOC resume and a strong start to the conference season but that was a long time ago now, their resume has been bleeding for a while now. Is the early season resume enough to carry them to a 3 seed? Sure, it's possible, but you can't ignore the bad two months they've had since and I'm sure the committee won't.
 

madguy30

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Nov 15, 2011
57,330
55,232
113
Ridiculous analogy. Auburn has piled up a bunch of quality wins in the last few months and lost at the buzzer against Alabama, to A&M on the road and down the wire against Tennessee. Iowa State lost to West Virginia, Kansas State and Oklahoma State.

Sorry and maybe it upsets people but Iowa State hasn't done much in the last 2 months. Two bad losses and in the last 2 months beat UCF twice, Arizona State, TCU, Cincy twice, Colorado and Kansas State. Arizona was the only quality win. Iowa State has a strong OOC resume and a strong start to the conference season but that was a long time ago now, their resume has been bleeding for a while now. Is the early season resume enough to carry them to a 3 seed? Sure, it's possible, but you can't ignore the bad two months they've had since and I'm sure the committee won't.

Will the committee pay attention to a main player missing a month, one being hobbled and another being hobbled and another missing time to sickness?

If ISU lost 3-4 non-conference games but have a better two months with a full roster what's the narrative?
 

dahliaclone

Well-Known Member
Mar 4, 2007
16,185
25,025
113
Minneapolis
Ridiculous analogy. Auburn has piled up a bunch of quality wins in the last few months and lost at the buzzer against Alabama, to A&M on the road and down the wire against Tennessee. Iowa State lost to West Virginia, Kansas State and Oklahoma State.

Sorry and maybe it upsets people but Iowa State hasn't done much in the last 2 months. Two bad losses and in the last 2 months beat UCF twice, Arizona State, TCU, Cincy twice, Colorado and Kansas State. Arizona was the only quality win. Iowa State has a strong OOC resume and a strong start to the conference season but that was a long time ago now, their resume has been bleeding for a while now. Is the early season resume enough to carry them to a 3 seed? Sure, it's possible, but you can't ignore the bad two months they've had since and I'm sure the committee won't.
What’s ridiculous is not comparing teams in the 3-5 seed range and realizing Iowa state still stands out to get a 3 over many of them not even counting our injuries.
 

NoCreativity

Well-Known Member
Nov 12, 2015
12,466
10,795
113
Des Moines
If you consider TTU and UK as "locks" on the 3-line; then the last 2 three seeds come down to:
Iowa State
Wisconsin
Maryland
TAMU

And we have 2 more Q1 wins that either of them (10,8,8,7). We are the only ones with 2 Q2 losses - but injuries are supposed to be accounted for, and we were down key starters in both of those losses.

We are also the highest of those 4 in NET, kenpom, BPI & T-Rank.

So I think we should clearly be on the 3-line, but I bet we get bumped to the 4. Not that it really matters - of the 5/6 seeds, Clemson is the only one would really worry me - other than I don't want another matchup with Illinois.
I just don't see any way Maryland or A&M are slotted above us. I think we get the last 3.

A&M is ranked 22nd on Torvick, I just don't see it at all.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: Cyclonepride

Cyched

CF Influencer
May 8, 2009
38,423
66,446
113
Colorado
Can you imagine being a 2-seed and having to play the winner of Kansas / Drake in the second round? I feel like either Kansas (if they get their heads on straight) or Drake would kill St Johns

Or even a 1-seed and playing the two-time national champ - or the winner of Gonzaga/Creighton. Those would be unpleasant second round matchups.

While I hate the "we are Iowa State" mentality, feels like we would've gotten stuck with that had we been on the 1/2 line.

Obviously anything can happen, and the 6/11 winner will not be a slouch. But a 3 seed feels somewhat "insulated" until the second weekend.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dahliaclone

MartyFine

Well-Known Member
Jul 7, 2009
15,255
24,213
113
Warren Co., IA
I wouldn't be surprised at Iowa State being a 4 and part of it has to do with the uncertainty surrounding Gilbert and Lipsey's status. They also have 2 bad losses to K-State and Oklahoma State and only one quality win in the last 2 months which was the win against Arizona at home. Not a lot of meat on the resume unfortunately with the added in question marks of the committee trying to figure out which Iowa State team we're going to see in the tournament with the injury concerns looming so I think a 4 seed is a strong possibility.

It's too bad because after that Kansas win on January 15th, the Cyclones were tracking to a 1 seed but the last 2 months have been a relative disaster tbh.

Except we are to look at the entire body of work. NET has ISU at 9, KenPom at 10, BartT at 8. Good night people...
 

WastedTalent

Well-Known Member
Oct 22, 2012
7,195
4,425
113
40
I still can't believe we allowed BYU to shoot 50% from 3 on 36 attempts. I know we were down our 2 best perimeter defenders, but if the drop off is that steep...we are going to need both guys for our Thursday/Friday game.
Think a 13 or 14 seed is as good as BYU?
 
  • Like
Reactions: madguy30

Cyched

CF Influencer
May 8, 2009
38,423
66,446
113
Colorado
I do think Gilbert will play the first game, even if it's on a pitch count.

If you sit him, and we get upset? You've now inadvertently ended his college career.

Why I'm glad I'm not a coach.

Lipsey could be in an iron lung and he'd still try to play, so I'm expecting him to go.
 

GrayerNot Mayor

Active Member
Oct 18, 2016
57
110
33
I do think Gilbert will play the first game, even if it's on a pitch count.

If you sit him, and we get upset? You've now inadvertently ended his college career.

Why I'm glad I'm not a coach.

Lipsey could be in an iron lung and he'd still try to play, so I'm expecting him to go.
Groin pulls/strains suck. Slow to heal and easy to re-aggravate. Let’s hope at least one of the two can get near full speed by Th/Fri - but our B12 tourney roster may be near what we have for the Dance. Get the rabbits foot(feet) out.
 

madguy30

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Nov 15, 2011
57,330
55,232
113
I still can't believe we allowed BYU to shoot 50% from 3 on 36 attempts. I know we were down our 2 best perimeter defenders, but if the drop off is that steep...we are going to need both guys for our Thursday/Friday game.

Allowed?

Even if wide open all the time that's an exceptional hit rate.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Acer88

NYCYFan

Well-Known Member
Mar 18, 2024
493
660
93
What’s ridiculous is not comparing teams in the 3-5 seed range and realizing Iowa state still stands out to get a 3 over many of them not even counting our injuries.
I don't think it's so controversial to say that Iowa State COULD get a 4 seed. I'm not saying that they won't get a 3 seed but if they are a 4, it's not so egregious because their resume in the last 2 months has not been good while others have caught up to them.
 

madguy30

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Nov 15, 2011
57,330
55,232
113
I don't think it's so controversial to say that Iowa State COULD get a 4 seed. I'm not saying that they won't get a 3 seed but if they are a 4, it's not so egregious because their resume in the last 2 months has not been good while others have caught up to them.

Are these resumes over the last month or two much better?


Penn State on senior day. Ouch.

Losing at TCU. Ouch.


 

Cyinthenorth

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Mar 29, 2013
15,896
11,979
113
36
Dubuque
3pt defense % is largely random. BYU is a good shooting team - but it was just as much luck as defense that they went 18-36 against us and 6-28 against Houston. Hell, they scored as many points against us from 3-pt shots as they scored against Houston TOTAL.
Is it random? I think some teams just defend the 3 point line well and some really don't. Our selling out to trap defense creates a lot of nice looks for opposing teams. Byu in particular has fed on us the last 2 years.
 
  • Like
Reactions: agentbear

Cloned4Life

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Mar 5, 2006
3,612
3,370
113
I don't think it's so controversial to say that Iowa State COULD get a 4 seed. I'm not saying that they won't get a 3 seed but if they are a 4, it's not so egregious because their resume in the last 2 months has not been good while others have caught up to them.
Since that fun KU home game, we’ve beat one NCAA tourney team :confused: