Disappointing season

quasistellar

Well-Known Member
Feb 29, 2016
3,353
4,765
113
We didn't just lose one starting point guard. If Lipsey wasn't hurt Kelderman probably doesn't see the floor. We had 3 really good guards and a solid 4th in Heise. You can't really expect more depth than that. I'm sure the staff was hoping Nojus would be able to contribute but freshman are a crap shoot. He was a top 100 talent that didn't pan out this year. That's why transfers are such a hot commodity.

the Nojus thing was actually pretty disappointing. If he couldn't see the floor this year with all the injuries, I have major concerns.
 

madguy30

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Nov 15, 2011
57,270
55,164
113
I don't know how anybody can argue that it wasn't a disappointing season. I mean for Christ sakes, at one point we had realistic expectations of a one seed, achieving something that it literally never been achieved at this school before, and instead the team doesn't even make it out of the first weekend. Yes, obviously injuries play a role, but it doesn't change the fact that when you compare how it started to how it ended, really the last month to month and a half of the season, it's been a pretty big bummer. And part of the frustration is that it feels like some of the talent of these guys just was wasted. Especially when the offense just looks lost, like it did a big chunk of last night.

Even when they were projected as a 1 seed Tarvik (which isn't everything but at least is a calculation) had them at like 7-8 losses so they were probably going to not sustain it to get a 1 seed.

Jay Bilas got ripped for saying back then that this team could beat or lose to anyone, and I think he was pretty spot on. They had the moving parts to be difficult for good teams to beat, but not the athleticism to automatically win.
 

Cyched

CF Influencer
May 8, 2009
38,368
66,341
113
Colorado
Pessimists die earlier, but we've evolved too far for them to not die early enough.

Glass half full, glass half empty. You give me 2 drops of beer and it's full enough for me.

If it's 1, it might not be enough.

That’s not nearly enough beer

Now I’m pessimistic again
 

alexssdean12

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
May 23, 2018
414
595
93
31
This season was a disappointment. I still enjoyed following this team and feel great about where our program is at.
You said what I couldn't say when I created this thread. We can be two things at once, content and excited about where this program is overall and also incredibly disappointed in how this season turned out.
 
  • Winner
Reactions: Cyfan1965

Clonefan32

Well-Known Member
Nov 19, 2008
23,486
25,934
113
I think it's possible for two things to be true at once. It's possible to be very thankful for the program stability we have and the fact we have been in the Top 25 and safely in the tournament the last 4 years. Alot of programs never recover from a year like Prohm's last year. You look at once proud programs like Syracuse, Notre Dame, Okie State, Florida State, TCU, etc.-- they are totally dead in the water.

You can also acknowledge that there's another gear we have to figure out a way to kick into. We thought we maybe had it this year, and we didn't. I do think we have to reevaulate depth and the way we play and practice. That was a tired team we saw tonight. And I think you can also acknowledge that TJ's insistance on playing as hard as they do while also cutting off his bench at 3 is a questionable coaching method. He's got to figure out a way to force some depth.

He's the right guy for the challenge and I have no doubt he's up early this morning trying to figure out what went wrong. So a disappointing season? Yes, it is based on where we thought we'd be in December. But it's also a bit of a splash of cold water to realize there are some things conceptually that need to change.
 

1SEIACLONE

Well-Known Member
Jun 2, 2024
2,707
2,493
113
63
Ames Iowa
The short answer is they'll all be gone.
You really cannot blame them, they come here to play, not sit and cheer. It's the way the sport has changed, either play me or I am going somewhere else, that will. With the transfer portal, immediate eligibility and pay for play, most of these players are not going to stay at any school if they are not getting playing time or a large bag of money.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BCClone

NorthCyd

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Aug 22, 2011
21,149
35,694
113
Player development is a concern. The best athlete in the team, Watson, didn't see the floor much all year. And what about Indrusaitis? Rock?
There are plenty of examples of players that have seen tremendous growth under this coaching staff. CuJo, Bob Jones, Ward to name a few. Not everybody has the ceiling to be a high major D1 player.
 

2forISU

Well-Known Member
Oct 8, 2008
6,249
2,210
113
On this I'll disagree. Having a 100% keyshon opens things up A LOT. He's pretty much the only guy with a handle that can create (and finish) at the rim, defend like crazy, AND shoot the occasional 3. He's really hard to defend, is a great defender, AND is extremely athletic. Lipsey just isn't quite as good offensively, and Jones is more of an outside shooter, not a finish at the rim guy. Momcilovic isn't even in the same league athletically and is just a totally different type of guard.

Gilbert is the type of player that makes a good team a contender for the final four and beyond, so finding out he's been fighting an injury (and supposedly only that even though he didn't even travel with the team??!) completely reset my expectations for this team. Then I saw the Ole Miss matchup and was gutted, since they thrive on turnovers. Lo and behold, we got our butts whooped.
I don't know if the outcome changes last night with healthy Gilbert. Ole Miss shot the ball extremely well and really got after us in the halfcourt. Even if we win last night, I think MSU would have been a large hill to climb(remind me of Texas Tech, but with a better pg). Do we have a better chance with Gilbert, yes, but it just felt like Ole Miss night.
 

NoCreativity

Well-Known Member
Nov 12, 2015
12,455
10,783
113
Des Moines
The season as a whole was an extreme disappointment. The tournament not so much. 14% of us voted they would lose in the 2nd round in that poll last week. Unfortunately the writing had been on the wall for weeks now.

I'm sorry if I come across very blunt on here and my style offends people, but sometimes I feel like people need a reality check. The reality is we don't have the horses to replace an All Big-12 second team guard,we just don't. Heise is a good bench player but we were misisbg the heart and soul of this team for 2 years now. All the drama surrounding his injury is a bad distraction, but the main issue is he's not on the floor and healthy. That's why I was being so negative in thre Keahon thread last week. Some of it is being mad at the coaching staff, some of it is being extremely disappointed in him personally.

2nd point is we absolutely should not have been a 3 seed given the circumstances. I made my views very clear last week that I thought TJ gamed the system which obviously rubbed people the wrong way even though it was true.

3rd point is you absolutely can't have a walk-on playing in the NCAA tourney. It means you failed big time at roster building. Kade gave it is all, but no serious team would have a walk-on playing significantly. Yes he held his own against Lipscomb, no he cannot compete with guards from the SEC once the competition ramps up. I'm not sure how many of you have been to an NCAA tournament game, but they play like their lives depend on it. It's whole different level.

I guess I've a at least learned to temper expectations going forward. I'm not real sure what we accomplished this year besides beating Tech on the road, the rest we were either favored in or had a horrible loss.

I guess the lesson learned is never to expect anything coming off a really good year no matter the hype or returning players. 2015 snd 2025 basketball, 2021 football are just some examples where we come off a historic season then get worse the next year.

I guess it's on to portal season at this point and see what kind of roster we can put together next year.
 

State2015

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Aug 26, 2016
1,395
3,012
113
CF is the Fox News of Iowa State sports. It's all sunshine and spin all the time. If not he loses access to the team insiders.

I hopped on Twitter and it's already "hey guys if you want good players better donate!" guilt already.
If you want to see what real disappointment looks like, let’s go ahead and field a team next year with a $0 payroll. Keep complaining
 
  • Like
Reactions: VeloClone

swiacy

Well-Known Member
Apr 9, 2009
2,206
2,002
113
Yep, disappointing. We peaked at the wrong time and injuries killed us. Don't know if we'll see another final 4 caliber roster like we had this year with the NIL landscape.
It’s a long grind & mental fatigue reared it’s ugly head too.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BigBake

Raiders70

Well-Known Member
Nov 18, 2015
1,452
984
113
Increased usage from Milan and Jefferson. Lipsey playing true PG. Other than that, maybe Nojus or one of the true freshman, maybe JT Rock.
We have no idea what the team will look like next year. The portal just opened today. I imagine Lipsey will stay. Other than him who knows who will leave or come.
 

Latest posts

Help Support Us

Become a patron