I just don’t think he has it unfortunately. Going to be a career AAA guy I'm afraid.
Yup, he's kind of in that same mold as Killian and Wesneski where they look good at Iowa but just can't sustain it when they get to the big league. It's another reason why I'm not overly concerned about trading prospects at the deadline if it results in meaningful additions. How many times have we seen the Cubs hold onto guys that could have netted something in a trade and then when they finally get a shot in Chicago they fizzle out and lose a ton of trade value that they once had. Canario and Killian are prime examples as that was thought to be a decent haul of prospects SF gave up for a rental of Bryant. Probably could have flipped Canario for something when he was on a heater in AAA before he got his first taste of the big leagues then a couple years later he was DFA. Can probably find plenty of examples of guys we held onto too long over the past 10 years that that were once thought of as top guys in the Cubs system that didn't amount to much. What are the odds that Alcantara or Caissie turns into a stud once they get a chance and not wind up becoming another Canario or Nelson Velazquez. Caissie is probably as high of value as he's ever been right now and before Alcantara got hurt he was trending that way too.
Cam Smith may turn out to be a stud that we wish we had held onto especially if we don't resign Tucker and Shaw struggles to hit at the MLB. It's the price to pay for a superstar like Tucker but I'd be curious what other names besides Smith were discussed. The Cubs have really struggled to bring up talent through the minors that become major contributors since 2016. If you look at this current roster Horton and Palencia are the only 2 pitchers that came up through the Cubs minors. Position wise Happ, Amaya, Hoerner, Shaw, and PCA (kinda) are the only ones. I struggle to think of guys in recent memory that are gone now after we traded the 2016 core away. Given the track record of the past 10 years I'm kind of at a point if you have to sell the farm now to compete then why not as we haven't exactly been building teams with the farm system lately anyways.