Depends on what price range you are looking at, but there are quite a few areas in West Ames that are nice. We looked in the Hillside area (just west of South Dakota, south of Lincoln Way by the basketball facility) and the new development that is north off Lincoln Way way out west. With both of those you are close to Lincoln Way/Hwy 30. Because we have school age and younger kids, we chose NW Ames in the Gilbert School district. We are close to county line road which runs N-S between Boone and Story counties--you can take back roads to get to Boone.
As far as commutes go, we live in the absolute worst place for my husband to commute to his office by Valley West Mall. When we first moved to Ames his job was here in town, but unfortunately he was in an industry that hit a low point after we moved. The next job landed him in DSM. But we love our neighborhood and the schools here. We are closer to family here than if we moved to DSM and yes, we hit as many athletic events as we can. Right now my oldest is a ball girl for the volleyball team. We figure if Fred could start as a ball boy and work his way up, our daughter can do the same in volleyball.

it is fun for them to be able to interact closely with college atheltes. They would not have those same opportunities if we lived closer to hubby's job.