Burton's minutes

Chitowncy

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
Jan 14, 2009
2,292
1,572
113
Ames
Agree most of the time but last night he was even making some good things happen on defense, like steals, blocks, and knocking the ball loose. He's been getting more consistent lately and when he's as dominant as he was last night he just has to be in there (at least down the stretch). I feel sorry for Jameel, he's just not the same shot blocking menace in the middle like he was last year and not the same money guy on alley-oops either. Have to think the tendonitis is affecting his play and we have to get him healthy if possible. George seems to be forcing things a little too much down the stretch and maybe if Burton was in there it would help George. We need to get this figured out so Burton is getting more minutes, at least when he's playing as well as he has been lately.

I agree; it seemed to me watching it live that Burton was solid on defense. Our team doesn't create too many turnovers naturally and Burton did it pretty well. He also bodied up his bigger opponent several times and was quite physical.

I think Jameel's knee is still bothering him too. On that alley-oop Niang threw to him toward the end of the game, it just went off Jameel's fingertips. I don't think he's jumping or moving as well as he was prior to the injury.
 

kingcy

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Sep 16, 2006
22,803
3,686
113
Menlo, Iowa
Last season people ******* that McKay needed more PT. This year he is getting the PT and he is not as affective. Maybe the coaches know what they are doing with the rotation.
 

Wesley

Well-Known Member
Apr 12, 2006
70,923
546
113
Omaha
I agree; it seemed to me watching it live that Burton was solid on defense. Our team doesn't create too many turnovers naturally and Burton did it pretty well. He also bodied up his bigger opponent several times and was quite physical. I think Jameel's knee is still bothering him too. On that alley-oop Niang threw to him toward the end of the game, it just went off Jameel's fingertips. I don't think he's jumping or moving as well as he was prior to the injury.
Tendonitis left knee. His jumping foot?
 

Cyclone1985

Well-Known Member
Nov 18, 2008
1,912
235
48
40
Grimes
Matt Thomas was typically guarding WV's best driver on the perimeter. In today's college game staying in front of someone is more of challenge than ever given perimeter fouling rule changes. Defense is not as simple as not letting a driver get past the primary defender - it is also about the secondary defender and that is where ISU defense most often breaks down. Thomas's defense has been fine.

If you are looking at productivity on the offensive end and on the boards, it is not even close - Burton well out out-performed everyone. I mean, the guy had more rebounds in 16 minutes than any other player in the game. Given the deficiencies of the team in this game as it progressed, it is hard to come up with any reason why Burton would play 16 minutes.

This is the key. Last year Mckay was a rim protector, not this year. And I don't think Nader even knows what help side defense is. The only person that helps is MT -- unfortunately, he is usually guarding their best shooter so they dish it to him for an easy jump shot.

Burton had 6 boards, 2 blocks and 1 steal in 16 minutes.
McKay had 4 boards, 2 blocks and 0 steals in 30 minutes.
Nader had 5 boards, 0 blocks and 0 steals in 38 minutes.
 

SolarGarlic

Well-Known Member
Jan 18, 2016
6,309
9,618
113
This is the key. Last year Mckay was a rim protector, not this year. And I don't think Nader even knows what help side defense is. The only person that helps is MT -- unfortunately, he is usually guarding their best shooter so they dish it to him for an easy jump shot.

Burton had 6 boards, 2 blocks and 1 steal in 16 minutes.
McKay had 4 boards, 2 blocks and 0 steals in 30 minutes.
Nader had 5 boards, 0 blocks and 0 steals in 38 minutes.


Niang is one of our best help defenders. That says a lot. When Georges wants to/isn't sucking wind, he's an above average defender.
 

cyclone1975

Well-Known Member
Feb 4, 2007
1,102
122
63
Ankeny
If Prohm benches McKay and starts Burton there is legitimate chance that McKay will be so upset he either gives us absolutely nothing the rest of the season or, as threatened via twitter, shuts it down and thinks about himself for the rest of the year. Heck, he might even start doing that if Prohm started taking him out during the last few minutes of the game.
 

AllInForISU

Well-Known Member
Nov 24, 2012
4,622
4,930
113
Last season people ******* that McKay needed more PT. This year he is getting the PT and he is not as affective. Maybe the coaches know what they are doing with the rotation.

The funny thing is, he is averaging almost identical numbers per game in conference play this year as he was last year. The only 2 differences are shooting percentage us 51% as opposed to 58% and his minutes are up 5 minutes per game.

Overall, his numbers are up, but that is obviously due to lower competition in non-con.
 
Last edited:

cyclone1975

Well-Known Member
Feb 4, 2007
1,102
122
63
Ankeny
If Prohm benches McKay and starts Burton there is legitimate chance that McKay will be so upset he either gives us absolutely nothing the rest of the season or, as threatened via twitter, shuts it down and thinks about himself for the rest of the year. Heck, he might even start doing that if Prohm started taking him out during the last few minutes of the game.

Wow, I should start picking stocks or something.
 

cstrunk

Well-Known Member
Mar 21, 2006
14,453
4,866
113
38
Longview, TX
I think giving Burton the start will only help this team when McKay gets his act together and comes back stronger. The team will come together by March at it's strongest.

Burton will be more of an impact player (moreso than he already is) and will see more minutes even when McKay is back.
 

bosco

Well-Known Member
Dec 21, 2008
9,843
7,730
113
Des Moines
With McKay suspended it'll be interesting to see which happens first Burton fouls out or passes out.
 

heitclone

Well-Known Member
Jun 21, 2009
16,620
14,413
113
45
Way up there
The funny thing is, he is averaging almost identical numbers per game in conference play this year as he was last year. The only 2 differences are shooting percentage us 51% as opposed to 58% and his minutes are up 5 minutes per game.

Overall, his numbers are up, but that is obviously due to lower competition in non-con.

Scoring and rebounding are fine but his blocks and steals are down. He is also turning the ball over much more, as you said, against worse competition overall, he's already turned the ball over more this year than last season.
 

AllInForISU

Well-Known Member
Nov 24, 2012
4,622
4,930
113
Scoring and rebounding are fine but his blocks and steals are down. He is also turning the ball over much more, as you said, against worse competition overall, he's already turned the ball over more this year than last season.

Turnovers are up in conference play .2 per game. Blocks are down .4 per game. Steals are down .5 per game. Yes they are down but not astronomically and that can be attributed to playing 5 minutes more a game.

His win share and player efficiency rating are both 3rd behind only Monte and Georges, who are obviously our 2 best players.

Basically, what I am trying to say, is that he is the same player we had last year, peoples expectations just changed unfortunately and they became almost unrealistic and it seems like he has bought into his own hype. He just really needs to realize what he is on the court, a shot blocking, rebounding, athletic freak, who will get his points on ally-oops or put back dunks.

Also, I said overall his numbers are UP. You either read what I wrote incorrectly or are selectively taking what I said and skewing it out of context.
 
Last edited:

Cyclad

Well-Known Member
Apr 12, 2006
3,011
3,732
113
What more does burton have to do to get more minutes in the second half?
I agree he needs more minutes, but cannot jump on his bandwagon yet until he plays harder all the time. He has some offensive skills, no doubt. But his defense is terrible, he does not even seem to know where to be half the time. Plus, with his mass and jumping ability he needs to be a better rebounder. Showed a little bit against WVU, but, he was not competing against any other cyclones for a rebound, only wv players. Defense and rebounding are effort things, I don't see it from him yet. One other thing.....given how he defends, he will foul out if given many more minutes; plus throw in a charge or two.
 
Last edited:

Cyclad

Well-Known Member
Apr 12, 2006
3,011
3,732
113
Matt Thomas was typically guarding WV's best driver on the perimeter. In today's college game staying in front of someone is more of challenge than ever given perimeter fouling rule changes. Defense is not as simple as not letting a driver get past the primary defender - it is also about the secondary defender and that is where ISU defense most often breaks down. Thomas's defense has been fine.

If you are looking at productivity on the offensive end and on the boards, it is not even close - Burton well out out-performed everyone. I mean, the guy had more rebounds in 16 minutes than any other player in the game. Given the deficiencies of the team in this game as it progressed, it is hard to come up with any reason why Burton would play 16 minutes.
A lot of truth in your post. We cannot guard against dribble penetration. That is a huge flaw in our team. When the first guy gets beat you are at tremendous disadvantage. They either drive to the hole, kick for the three or dish to the big guy. Leads to fouls, open shots and offensive rebounds. Tim Floyd always said the ability to dribble penetrate was the most critical skill in bb. I like the idea of us playing zone....but we are really bad at that too. Our woes focus on defense.
 

Rick

Well-Known Member
Mar 18, 2007
1,816
255
83
Ankeny
A lot of truth in your post. We cannot guard against dribble penetration. That is a huge flaw in our team. When the first guy gets beat you are at tremendous disadvantage. They either drive to the hole, kick for the three or dish to the big guy. Leads to fouls, open shots and offensive rebounds. Tim Floyd always said the ability to dribble penetrate was the most critical skill in bb. I like the idea of us playing zone....but we are really bad at that too. Our woes focus on defense.
Is it not being able to defend or not being aggressive due to the bench situation. We cannot afford to get into foul trouble so a lot of shots are easier than they should be. McKay being hurt and a little psychotic hasn't helped. His presence is nothing compared to last spring. Some his fault and some his situation. Maybe a game or two off will get his knee situation a little better. One poster referenced the lob that Georges threw in the WVU game that McKay totally missed on. He doesn't have the mobility or quickness he has had. With that said and trying to get back to Burton, if Burton plays within the game and himself we will be okay. He has a tendency of trying too much like Nader.