It really depends what you are looking for. I've been extremely happen with Dish. The Hopper is awesome, and the auto-hop function is absolutely incredible. But if you watch a lot of nfl football and want the NFL sunday ticket, its only available on Directv. As far as cyclone coverage goes, I think for the most part it is pretty equal. Dish does not get the FCS channel, but lets all pray we never end up on that channel ever again.