** Halloween Party Mafia **

cyfanatic13

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Dec 19, 2008
11,462
10,625
113
How would I tell the innocent? Say 'HEY EVERYONE AKA INNOCENT, KC IS THE JAILOR!". Ya, if I did that KC would have died the same was.

And it's strategy fool. Nobody needed except KC I wanted to keep the information as I needed it. Ya I lied to say I hadn't jailed yesterday, so now went to it today.
A bit convenient to say you were in fact jailed after the jailer died and can’t refute it.

I suppose if anyone else was jailed N5 they could step up, but being jailed certainly equal innocent. My vote is going to stay for now unless someone has a better theory
 

Cyclonsin

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Dec 4, 2020
2,380
4,918
113
36
Savannah, GA
feelings-i-am.gif





Plus it's probably all these people who don't play besides just votes, like MJ4Cy.
This is a huge huge thing to me right now.

It feels like there's a bunch of players that haven't even been mentioned or contributed beyond voting yet. And here we are tearing ourselves apart for them.

I suspect everybody with a pulse at this point.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: JM4CY

Cyclonsin

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Dec 4, 2020
2,380
4,918
113
36
Savannah, GA
This is a huge huge thing to me right now.

It feels like there's a bunch of players that haven't even been mentioned or contributed beyond voting yet. And here we are tearing ourselves apart for them.

I suspect everybody with a pulse at this point.
Took a glance at the names who have been quiet, are still alive, and don't have anything that clearly exonerates them and have landed on this:

Rescind Farnsy; vote Gipper

Probably naive of me to believe Farnsy.

But, for the love of God, someone better at this please come up with a more viable theory.
 

mj4cy

Asst. Regional Manager
Staff member
Mar 28, 2006
31,813
14,783
113
Iowa
feelings-i-am.gif





Plus it's probably all these people who don't play besides just votes, like MJ4Cy.

If I don't have any info I think is helpful I'm not just gonna make stuff up lol. Every game i have talked more I get labeled mafia as well.


Furthermore I don't do as well in mafia games with too many roles, rules, ans variations. my brain just can't comprehend it all.
 

andybernard

Well-Known Member
Oct 22, 2009
3,143
1,588
113
If I don't have any info I think is helpful I'm not just gonna make stuff up lol. Every game i have talked more I get labeled mafia as well.


Furthermore I don't do as well in mafia games with too many roles, rules, ans variations. my brain just can't comprehend it all.
Ditto. I tried to come up with a theory on day 2. Came up with a list of 3 that I suspected, and so far...0/2. The only one left from my original list is GBlade, which... why not.

Vote GBlade.
 

ISUCubswin

Well-Known Member
Mar 3, 2011
24,243
7,141
113
My Playhouse
I find it fascinating how openly ridiculous Sins day 3 was yet there is zero traction for that theory.

Again.

6 votes for Psy, 3 votes GBlade.

Sin says Psy is inno and GBlade is sus.

Then proceeds to vote Cubs, while GBlade sees 2 more votes NOT FROM SIN to close the gap and nearly save Psy.
 

MeowingCows

Well-Known Member
Jun 1, 2015
39,995
40,766
113
Iowa
Trying to decipher theory out of this infighting is tough, but god damn Farnsy cant **** this up a whole lot worse. The vote for fitzy (which was later pulled off) was another cherry on top.

I find it fascinating how openly ridiculous Sins day 3 was yet there is zero traction for that theory.

Again.

6 votes for Psy, 3 votes GBlade.

Sin says Psy is inno and GBlade is sus.

Then proceeds to vote Cubs, while GBlade sees 2 more votes NOT FROM SIN to close the gap and nearly save Psy.
Still the best one I see so far. Vote sin again.
 

ISUCubswin

Well-Known Member
Mar 3, 2011
24,243
7,141
113
My Playhouse
I have no issue voting farnsy out

But it bothers me the silent people (mj, Andy) seem to have zero input and don’t seem to follow any theories
 

Cyclonsin

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Dec 4, 2020
2,380
4,918
113
36
Savannah, GA
I find it fascinating how openly ridiculous Sins day 3 was yet there is zero traction for that theory.

Again.

6 votes for Psy, 3 votes GBlade.

Sin says Psy is inno and GBlade is sus.

Then proceeds to vote Cubs, while GBlade sees 2 more votes NOT FROM SIN to close the gap and nearly save Psy.
I was more concerned with voting for the person I suspected most than saving someone I was leaning inno on (and wrong about, mind you) at 1:15 PM.

Feels pretty weak, but if that's the best you've got I won't exactly miss participating in this clusterfuck of a mafia. Just keep it close to learn something more than "Cyclonsin is a regular inno."
 

ISUCubswin

Well-Known Member
Mar 3, 2011
24,243
7,141
113
My Playhouse
I was more concerned with voting for the person I suspected most than saving someone I was leaning inno on (and wrong about, mind you) at 1:15 PM.

Feels pretty weak, but if that's the best you've got I won't exactly miss participating in this clusterfuck of a mafia. Just keep it close to learn something more than "Cyclonsin is a regular inno."
And you never were looking out for Cupid?
 

Colorado

Well-Known Member
Aug 29, 2008
2,464
1,294
113
Colorado
If I don't have any info I think is helpful I'm not just gonna make stuff up lol. Every game i have talked more I get labeled mafia as well.


Furthermore I don't do as well in mafia games with too many roles, rules, ans variations. my brain just can't comprehend it all.
This is 100% me as well. I'm too trusting of other people when they claim innocence. Any any time that I have been more vocal in a mafia game, I get accused of being mafia.
 
  • Winner
Reactions: mj4cy

Cyclonsin

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Dec 4, 2020
2,380
4,918
113
36
Savannah, GA
And you never were looking out for Cupid?
Nope. I haven't heard a peep from anyone special. I can't contribute a thing other than my own cockamamie theories, which have all been horrendously wrong so far. So you're not risking much if y'all axe me.
 

JM4CY

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Aug 23, 2012
37,898
74,615
113
America
I get that farnsy is mucking up the game some but I think it's stupid to vote out a (potentially) inno just because he's bothering people, which seems to be the primary argument. I don't think farnsy would so active and crazy if he was mafia.

Today's conversation has made me cool on sin because of the last point above but I've been sus of him this whole game and don't have anything better to go on right now. vote sin and can be convinced to move elsewhere if something of actual substance comes out today besides the "vote farnsy because he's annoying cubs" theory.

I do think it would be most prudent to try and get pressure on the less active players and see what turns up because THAT is where I think a good chunk of mafia are hiding.
 

cyfanatic13

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Dec 19, 2008
11,462
10,625
113
I'm going to revisit something from earlier in the game when I left a hint that I was a reg inno and a few seemed to not pick up on it. This list isn't automatically saying they aren't a reg inno, but Ctown seemed to pick up on it so I don't think it was too tough to figure out

Fitzy- later in the day after being called out by Ctown, said he now realized what we meant (after it was blatantly spelled out). I was inclined to believe him at the time but as the game goes on I get more and more sus. Not ready to pull the trigger yet but it's something to remember as I would assume he's a good enough player to actually pick up on the hint

Colorado- said my hint made me more sus not less. Well now he's on MY sus list. Additionally, he had a late vote on psy (mafia) on Day 2 when it already looked like it was going to be Sara or WDSM (both innos) and then didn't vote for Psy (mafia). He's also been very quiet after the first couple days.

JM4CY- also wanted someone to explain what I was referring to. Sus list

There are a few others that didn't pick up on it that have already died. One was a reg inno, the other two were specials

Inno leans: Ctown, ItsCyence

I would encourage others to look into past posts/votes and not just blindly follow along voting for someone. However, for the reasons listed above, I'm going to rescind Farnsy and vote Colorado
 

andybernard

Well-Known Member
Oct 22, 2009
3,143
1,588
113
I have no issue voting farnsy out

But it bothers me the silent people (mj, Andy) seem to have zero input and don’t seem to follow any theories

Lol... because all of the input and theories have done us so well.

I stated my theory right off the bat and tried to follow it without just throwing out pointless votes. So far, it's gotten me nowhere. Turns out, it's tough to know what's going on when you don't have a role and the specials don't help.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: Cyclonsin

PSYclone22

Visual Analytics Mercenary
SuperFanatic
Aug 15, 2012
5,101
3,211
113
Des Moines
Day 7 (7 of 19 votes)

3 - Cyclonsin - Cubs (7:08am), andybernard (11:43am), JM4CY (12:06pm)
1 - cows - JHUNSY (9:10am)
1 - Cubs - Farnsy (9:45am)
1 - Gipper - Cyclonsin (11:15am)
1 - Colorado - cyfan13 (12:36pm)
0 - GBlade - andybernard (11:31am rescind 11:43am)
0 - Fitzy - Farnsy (9:15am rescind 9:45am)
0 - Farnsy - Cyclonsin (9:58am rescind 11:15am), cyfan13 (10:01am rescind 12:36pm)