Okay, everything should be finalized. Moved the roster structure back to essentially default settings: 1 each around the diamond, as well as 1 "corner" infielder, 1 "middle" infielder, and 5 outfielders, plus one UTIL guy.
9 active pitchers, with 2 of them needing to be relievers. Since there are 12 of us, I added 0.5 points for holds, so closers are still more valuable but high-end relievers that don't close will have some value that way too.
I also followed the suggestion above and dropped Wins and Losses to 3/-3 points, and awarded 2 points to a Quality Start.
Sorry for all the tinkering. I haven't played in a points league before.