Thanks to Mike Hlas for his nice column!
There’s no cause for Hawkeyes to be scornful of Cyclones other than pure rivalry reasons
Posted on Jun 07, 2010 by
Mike Hlas.
I had a phone message waiting for me Monday from someone who suggested Iowa State should just join Northern Iowa (presumably as a basketball mid-major and football FCS program).
Sure, great idea. I’m sure ISU will get right on that.
I get the occasional catty remark about ISU on this blog from Iowa Hawkeye fans, people suggesting Iowa State should go to the Mid-American Conference or something of the sort.
No real offense should be taken. Rivalries are rivalries. Hawkeyes ridicule Cyclones and vice versa, just like rivals do in
Cy looks irritated, and with reason
Florida, Texas, Oregon and everywhere else.
But I think there is a small segment of Iowa fans that really does believe Iowa State is some kind of second-class citizen in college sports. They are deluded.
In the 2000s, Iowa State went to six bowl games. Granted, none were played in January. But that’s more bowls than Michigan State, Northwestern, Illinois or Indiana went to last decade.
In the 2000s, Iowa State and Iowa played each other 10 times in football. Each side won five. No excuses. Everyone, almost, has ups and downs. Over a decade, they split 10 games.
In the 2000s, ISU and Iowa met in men’s basketball 11 times thanks to one NIT battle. Iowa won six, Iowa State five.
In the 2000s, Iowa won shares of two Big Ten football titles, while ISU won no Big 12 championship.
But in the 2000s, ISU won two regular-season Big 12 men’s basketball crowns, while Iowa won none.
As mediocre as Cyclone men’s basketball was the last three years, Iowa’s was worse.
I’ve heard many putdowns of ISU’s Jack Trice Stadium from Iowa fans over the years. Trice isn’t a great stadium. But Iowa State averaged more fans per game than 15 other teams from BCS leagues, and had similar numbers to several others, including Miami and Arizona State. Iowa State outdrew three teams (Boise State, Cincinnati, TCU) that went to BCS bowls.
That’s not eye-opening stuff, but merely a reminder that Ames isn’t exactly a football graveyard. Not when it’s coming off a five-win improvement capped by a win in a bowl game over a Big Ten team, Minnesota.
What I’m trying to say is, Iowa State isn’t some fly-by-night athletic program. It has been, overall, a competitive program in a BCS conference. To suggest it deserves to be tossed to the wayside because it could fall through the cracks if the still-theoretical annexation of six Big 12 teams is made by the Pac-10 is absurd.
If — and it hasn’t happened yet, sports fans — Iowa State is left in the cold by conference expansion, the state of Iowa will be diminished whether non-sports fans believe it or not. Maybe it will happen, maybe not. Maybe it’s inevitable.
But if you think it’s a good thing, you may not be a reasonable person.