The guy gave it his all when he was here and delivered some epic wins. Former players LOVED playing for him (Mahoney and Woody said this on one of their podcasts). Whether it was coincidental or because of his teams' play, I would argue it was his tenure that kicked up the ISU tailgating scene to be elite in the country which CMC saw and made him want to coach here (fan passion). You could tell Rhoads' time was up (and he knew it as well) but he gave it his all until the end and set up Campbell for the greatest stretch in ISU football history (many of Rhoads recruited players were part of the beginning of this run). Bashing CPR is dumb and those fans probably weren't fans before Chizik and didn't know what ISU football came from.
What part of my post is bashing him? I’m using his own words he said. I agree with most of your sentiment. And slightly disagree about giving it all given his own quotes when it comes to recruiting and competing in Ames Iowa at the tail end of his time here. Most of his last season I was still ready to give him another year, but when he said those things on top of how that KState game ended changed my tune and he needed to go. Also, I’ve been going to games since ‘96 so can certainly say I’ve been a fan since before Chizik.
The only thing I’d bash him for is wearing that hard hat at the end of his last game at Iowa State after getting beat down by West Virginia. That was a bit embarrassing.