Petras gets blasted by Barstool

CyJack13

Well-Known Member
May 21, 2010
12,666
1,665
113
This year Iowa's offense is HORRIBLE. In the past it has just been boring, but it complemented what they did on defense & special teams. It's not trendy in today's college football game, but Kirk has won with defense & special teams. The 5 years prior to this season, Iowa was 28-16 in Big10 play. Remember, this is the first year Campbell has beaten Ferentz. Kirk Ferentz must be doing something right at Iowa!

Sure Lincoln Riley's great offensive teams at Oklahoma were fun to watch, but their defenses were HORRIBLE. Like the saying goes- more than one way to skin a cat!

Yeah they have really good defenses and special teams. That's how they are winning. If they had an above average offense, they might actually have been more than a Fake ID team as Cowherd aptly put it.

Read your last paragraph compared to how you describe Iowa's offense. Would you ever say Oklahoma having a, in your words, horrible defense complimented their offense? I mean it's the same argument, OU's defense got the ball back to their offense quicker by letting the other team score, which compliments an explosive offense. That sounds just dumb as saying Iowa's terrible offense compliments their good defense.
 

isucy86

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2006
7,871
6,451
113
Dubuque
Yeah they have really good defenses and special teams. That's how they are winning. If they had an above average offense, they might actually have been more than a Fake ID team as Cowherd aptly put it.

Read your last paragraph compared to how you describe Iowa's offense. Would you ever say Oklahoma having a, in your words, horrible defense complimented their offense? I mean it's the same argument, OU's defense got the ball back to their offense quicker by letting the other team score, which compliments an explosive offense. That sounds just dumb as saying Iowa's terrible offense compliments their good defense.
The only problem with your logic- Iowa's bad offense didn't make it easy for opponents to score. While Oklahoma's bad defense allowed opponents to score easily.

Not a hard concept, a 20-10 win counts the same as 34-10. Ferentz has had success doing the former with a mediocre offense.
 

BillBrasky4Cy

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Dec 10, 2013
15,408
28,046
113
Until the last couple years, Iowa's offenses have complimented their approach to winning- above average defense, special teams and run game. They were bland offensively, but it didn't matter because they were above average where they wanted to be.

The last couple years that 3 legged stool is missing a leg - an elite OL. The whole foundation of Iowa's program takes a hit without a great OL that enabled them to run consistently. For Kirk's 20 years, their passing game was opportunistic. Their QB's don't throw interceptions, they complete the easy passes and they complete long passes off play action. After all Stanzi, Beathard and Stanley all made NFL rosters.

It seems Iowa's talent evaluation of recruits has been poor, basically since Brian Ferentz became OC. Didn't their best OL, Tyler Lindebaum, come to Iowa as a DL?

Up until last year the Iowa defenses were a bit of fools gold too though and prior to Taylor they had had several punting problems. Iowa has absolutely FEASTED on poor QB play and offenses for like the last 5 or 6 years. Yes, they have been good but they have also been exposed multiple times too.
 

Frak

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Apr 27, 2009
10,790
6,020
113
Up until last year the Iowa defenses were a bit of fools gold too though and prior to Taylor they had had several punting problems. Iowa has absolutely FEASTED on poor QB play and offenses for like the last 5 or 6 years. Yes, they have been good but they have also been exposed multiple times too.
That Punter has won them multiple games. Including against us last year. Crazy that one special teams player can make that big of a difference, but he has. This year, their offense is bad enough that he can't cover up for them like he did last year.
 

Kinch

Well-Known Member
Sep 19, 2021
3,233
2,842
113
And keep in mind, those numbers (defense and offense) come against the Big 10 west. If Phil Parker was coaching in the Big 10 east, I really doubt if the defense would put up elite numbers that they do against Northwestern, Minnesota, Nebraska and Illinois.
 
  • Like
Reactions: besserheimerphat

BigTurk

Well-Known Member
Dec 17, 2013
2,281
2,730
113
And keep in mind, those numbers (defense and offense) come against the Big 10 west. If Phil Parker was coaching in the Big 10 east, I really doubt if the defense would put up elite numbers that they do against Northwestern, Minnesota, Nebraska and Illinois.

Good point. Doesn’t Purdue light them up every year?
 

JM4CY

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Aug 23, 2012
33,673
64,980
113
America


FixedUnknownKodiakbear-size_restricted.gif
 
  • Like
Reactions: JBone84

Mick Mars

Well-Known Member
Mar 19, 2017
250
321
63
58
And keep in mind, those numbers (defense and offense) come against the Big 10 west. If Phil Parker was coaching in the Big 10 east, I really doubt if the defense would put up elite numbers that they do against Northwestern, Minnesota, Nebraska and Illinois.
This nails it- the solid defense, special teams, strong running game, and winning the turnover game is a perfect recipe to beat these mediocre teams most years. And they don't drill people like Hayden used to because, much like ISU currently, they will be in just about every game but so will the opponent- that system of play almost guarantees close games in today's college game. In the last 13 seasons Iowa has played the league bully of this era, Ohio State, only four times. They have benefited amazingly from an unbalanced schedule.

Basketball is similar in a different kind of way- Fran's teams can't guard to save their a..es but they score a bunch of points well enough to beat BAD teams like Penn State, Minnesota, Northwestern, Nebraska and last year, Maryland, and pile up 8-10 "league" wins.
 

Latest posts

Help Support Us

Become a patron