The criticism of Fran seems totally misdirected. His recruiting isn't an issue. The kids fit what he wants to do on the offensive end.
The problem with Fran is similar to Prohm, they can ONLY win one way- they need to put up big points. Would be curious to see data on Fran's win % where Iowa scores: < 65, 66-75, 76-85 & 85+.
Good coaches find ways to win if they score 65 or 85. Because their teams can defend, rebound, be physical, etc.
I started at the 2012-13 season (most of Lick's recruits were gone). Here are the totals from 2012-2023: Total W-L = 223-139
Less than 50pts = 0-4
50-59 = 3-18
60-69 = 19-46
70-79 = 70-44 (he is only 50% since 2016-17 season)
80-89 = 76-20
90+ = 55-7
22 TOTAL WINS when scoring less than 70 points.
I then did the same for Iowa State (again, starting at the 2012-13 season). I also broke down our 3 coaches' totals.
Total W-L = 215-149 (CFH= 76-29; CSP= 98-94; Otz= 41-26)
Less than 50pts = 1-6 (H= N/A; P=0-1; Otz= 1-5)
50-59 = 6-29 (H=0-2; P= 2-18; Otz= 4-9)
60-69 = 23-40 (H=5-5; P= 9-26; Otz= 9-9)
70-79 = 67-59 (H=20-16; P= 31-40; Otz= 16-3)
80-89 = 81-12 (H= 35-5; P= 35-7; Otz= 11-0)
90+ = 37-3 (H= 16-1; P= 21-2; Otz= N/A)
30 TOTAL WINS when scoring less than 70 points. (Only 2 of those wins came during Prohm's final TWO years). Still, although we have had 8 fewer total wins than Iowa, we have 8 more wins than they do when scoring less than 70 points.