The Painful Cyclone Realization

twocoach

Well-Known Member
Jan 13, 2014
5,335
28
48
Omaha
It was more of a piece to say look how good we had it last season with Niang, Kane, and Ejim and how little drama we faced
Again, last year's team didn't accomplish anything that this year's team isn't on pace to do except play an even easier non-con schedule. They haven't lost ground. Last year wasn't able to beat KU in Hilton, this year's team did. The only thing this year's team did that was a step back was lose @Texas Tech and over the course of a 30+ game season that's a nothing. The only mistake made was assuming that this year's team would continue on the same continuous rise of the previous two seasons with no dips down when the reality of losing Kane and Ejim made that a very formidable task. No team in the sport continues on a straight line trajectory up year after year after year. It's a two or three steps forwards, one step back process that many appear to be too impatient to handle. Overall, ISU has made progress forward this year by showing themselves that they can beat Kansas. With many pieces returning and no major roster losses heading into next year, ISU should be poised to continue their rise next year with more steps forwards than backwards. Be patient.
 

CycloneErik

Well-Known Member
Jan 31, 2008
108,178
53,435
113
Jamerica
rememberingdoria.wordpress.com
Exactly.

I didn't read the OP's posted article, but I did read the first 15 posts. Is it just me or do most of the loudest critics, and quickest to rush to judgment against the team (or in some cases praise the team) seem to be the newest members of the CycloneFanatic fanbase?

They seem to have the most recent "Join Dates", which suggests to me that the success has bred a "new" Cyclone fan (some might label them "bandwagon" fans) that only know great success. Also, these fans seem to be the most extreme in their emotions. Two such posters, not this OP to my knowledge, but a couple other posters I've observed, seem to swing from praising the team to criticizing the team based on one game.

It's a fascinating (some might say annoying) phenomenon.

Carry on.

It's some of that. Also, some of the most passionate f-word defenders are very aggressive in their complaints about basketball.

Overall, just a lot of people choosing not to notice that we're having a very good season, poised to make the NCAAs for the history-making 4th straight time, and looking like about a 3 seed in the process. Things are excellent, but people aren't seeing it (as opposed to the f-word sport).
 

cycloneworld

Facebook Knows All
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Mar 20, 2006
30,192
22,545
113
Urbandale, IA
I know that we're having a great season, mostly better than last year, but this roller coaster play is nothing like we've seen since Hoiberg got here

What roller coaster play? Outside of Tech and South Carolina (SC loss was meaningless), we have lost to the #2, #12, #14, and #15 RPI teams. All of them away from home (3 on the road, 1 neutral).
 

twocoach

Well-Known Member
Jan 13, 2014
5,335
28
48
Omaha
I know that we're having a great season, mostly better than last year, but this roller coaster play is nothing like we've seen since Hoiberg got here
So starting last year 14-0 followed by losing 4 of 5 followed by winning 7 of 8 followed by losing back to back followed by winning the Big 12 tourney and making the Sweet Sixteen isn't considered roller coaster play?
 

wonkadog

Well-Known Member
Apr 17, 2006
4,857
399
83
Ames, IA
I thought this was the guy that got into a ruckus with BDK on here one time...

Nah, that was in the lunch room when their 2 crowds had to cross paths to get to where they were going to sit. It was ugly, corn dogs and fruit cocktail everywhere.
 

Wesley

Well-Known Member
Apr 12, 2006
70,923
546
113
Omaha
Again, last year's team didn't accomplish anything that this year's team isn't on pace to do except play an even easier non-con schedule. They haven't lost ground. Last year wasn't able to beat KU in Hilton, this year's team did. The only thing this year's team did that was a step back was lose @Texas Tech and over the course of a 30+ game season that's a nothing. The only mistake made was assuming that this year's team would continue on the same continuous rise of the previous two seasons with no dips down when the reality of losing Kane and Ejim made that a very formidable task. No team in the sport continues on a straight line trajectory up year after year after year. It's a two or three steps forwards, one step back process that many appear to be too impatient to handle. Overall, ISU has made progress forward this year by showing themselves that they can beat Kansas. With many pieces returning and no major roster losses heading into next year, ISU should be poised to continue their rise next year with more steps forwards than backwards. Be patient.

As a KU fan, does not your fan base have this problem every year. Your expectations are so high and losses to Temple and UK probably caused a few rants. How do your fans react?
 

connorferg9

Member
Staff member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Apr 28, 2013
33
1
8
Some people judge this team based off of the players on this team, and get upset about things like focus, urgency, and effort when they aren't there.

Some people judge this team off our results during the McDermott era. The people that do this are far happier.

What I want most for this team is for them to live up to their talent level. The effort, focus, and urgency have not been consistent with this squad and that is what upsets me. Fred and the players say the same.

this is what i was trying to get people to do, the age of the users on CF have obviously seen more terrible seasons than I have.
 

Clonefan94

Well-Known Member
Oct 18, 2006
11,204
6,258
113
Schaumburg, IL
It was more of a piece to say look how good we had it last season with Niang, Kane, and Ejim and how little drama we faced

I take it you didn't start watching last season until the Big 12 tournament? There was plenty of drama about how we had to come back to win so many games that should have been blowouts, plenty of drama when we dropped 3 in a row, plenty of drama when we lost to KU twice during the regular season.

I guess it's nice that everyone expects us to be Kentuckyesque now in our play, but come on. Let me repost something I posted earlier. ISU has made the NCAA tournament a Whopping 16 times, we made it to the final four once, when there were 8 total teams in the tournament and if we get there this year, this will be the first time ever that we've made it into the tournament four years in a row.

Can we please start enjoying the ride to the top as opposed to assuming we are already there and ******** when things don't go 100% how you expect?
 

twocoach

Well-Known Member
Jan 13, 2014
5,335
28
48
Omaha
As a KU fan, does not your fan base have this problem every year. Your expectations are so high and losses to Temple and UK probably caused a few rants. How do your fans react?
Not to this severity. Every fan base has their "I want it now, I want it every year and no loss is acceptable" goofballs. Most KU fans have seen enough examples of seasons that have worked out in the end to not lose their minds. KU started the 2003 season 3-3 and still played in the ncaa title game. They won the title in '88 as a #6 seed. They managed to extend the Big 12 streak in '13 despite losing on the road @TCU in a game where they looked like they had never played the game of basketball in their lives. then to balance it out they've had teams that looked unstoppable lose early in the tourney. They're simply no rhyme or reason to it sometimes. We've been riding this roller coaster as a fan base for 25+ straight years so we're probably more numb to it now. Maybe some ISU people thought that life as an upper tier basketball program would be smoother and less erratic with less bumps and peaks but it really isn't. It's actually worse because you think your team is capable of great things. There won't be this same volume of overreacting freakouts if ISU makes the tourney every year for the next decade+. People get used to even the craziest roller coasters if they stay on it long enough.
 

twocoach

Well-Known Member
Jan 13, 2014
5,335
28
48
Omaha
Some people judge this team based off of the players on this team, and get upset about things like focus, urgency, and effort when they aren't there. Some people judge this team off our results during the McDermott era. The people that do this are far happier. What I want most for this team is for them to live up to their talent level. The effort, focus, and urgency have not been consistent with this squad and that is what upsets me. Fred and the players say the same.
Most NBA teams don't consistently perform to their level of talent, let alone college teams. And most fans don't have a truly realistic assessment of exactly how talented a roster really is. Is this year's ISU team really so much more talented than last year's that they should be expected to perform better significantly than last year?
 

Clone_12

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Apr 11, 2006
2,987
318
83
No. But I also don't expect guys to stand around and watch when a shot goes up, or to slack off on defense, while getting outscored by 28 in a 20 minute stretch...no shame in losing in Norman, but it was embarrassing how it happened.
 

4theCYcle

Well-Known Member
Jul 14, 2013
2,362
1,258
113
Urbandale, IA
Even worse is sportstalkcrap or cyber..... He needs to stfu. Same as the cyclone nation guy.

Yeah, bad thing is you don't have to follow that person. Lot of times I see guys responding to players or sports writers begging for them to talk about more about out team. Or they rant bc we beat this team or that team. Even if nothing is relavent I've seen people bring up ISU making themselves and the school look like jack wagons.
 

RotatingColumn

Well-Known Member
Oct 21, 2008
1,674
343
113
Although I didn't agree with the article, I want to congratulate you on pursuing your interest in writing. Also good job in taking the criticism in stride (or at least it appears you have). You gotta have thick skin to make it in the arts. Keep pluggin away..
 

casey1973

Well-Known Member
Apr 20, 2012
2,402
1,494
113
Ames
Using myself as an example am a DIE HARD CYCLONE an since CPR and CFH came on board there was plenty of hope that our teams have turned the corner, coaches that want to be here and let the hype begin. We were teased with Okie State win and then the losses started piling up in football. The basketball program has been much more successful due to CFH and his recruiting not to mention his love for Ames and ISU and the media that seems to want Iowa State to do well. Well, all of a sudden we believe we should win the Big 12, and on to the final 4. And then road losses start piling up and the frustration starts to build - here we go again. We have a great fan base, have paid our dues and deserve to bring some kind of championship home. More patience I guess. My 2 cents.
 

str8cashhomie

Well-Known Member
Jun 15, 2014
271
479
63
Fair enough. Living through the leaner years gives most older fans an appreciation and an increased patience for the ups and downs.
I'm a year older and actually go to school with this kid, and perfectly remember McDermott and Wayne. He's not a hawk troll, but he IS a fairweather fan that starting paying attention once they "actually were worth watching" and thinks just because he started a Cyclone Nation twitter account with several thousand followers, it makes him the single best source for Iowa State everything. He's got good intentions, but just doesn't know what he's talking about at all.
 

im4cyclones

Well-Known Member
Jun 14, 2010
3,937
671
113
Ames, IA
Using myself as an example am a DIE HARD CYCLONE an since CPR and CFH came on board there was plenty of hope that our teams have turned the corner, coaches that want to be here and let the hype begin. We were teased with Okie State win and then the losses started piling up in football. The basketball program has been much more successful due to CFH and his recruiting not to mention his love for Ames and ISU and the media that seems to want Iowa State to do well. Well, all of a sudden we believe we should win the Big 12, and on to the final 4. And then road losses start piling up and the frustration starts to build - here we go again. We have a great fan base, have paid our dues and deserve to bring some kind of championship home. More patience I guess. My 2 cents.

If you ever to to Hilton, take a look at the banners. We have won some championships. I assume wrestling counts as "some kind".
 

mcblogerson

Well-Known Member
Jan 19, 2009
2,252
886
113
Ohio
And I'm over here thinking this has been one of the top 10 seasons in ISU basketball history to date.

If you're butthurt about their performance just wait till you see us go on the road to Texas and Okie St next week. We'll be lucky to get one of those.
 

CYKOFAN

Well-Known Member
Mar 27, 2006
4,947
120
63
Not to this severity. Every fan base has their "I want it now, I want it every year and no loss is acceptable" goofballs. Most KU fans have seen enough examples of seasons that have worked out in the end to not lose their minds. KU started the 2003 season 3-3 and still played in the ncaa title game. They won the title in '88 as a #6 seed. They managed to extend the Big 12 streak in '13 despite losing on the road @TCU in a game where they looked like they had never played the game of basketball in their lives. then to balance it out they've had teams that looked unstoppable lose early in the tourney. They're simply no rhyme or reason to it sometimes. We've been riding this roller coaster as a fan base for 25+ straight years so we're probably more numb to it now. Maybe some ISU people thought that life as an upper tier basketball program would be smoother and less erratic with less bumps and peaks but it really isn't. It's actually worse because you think your team is capable of great things. There won't be this same volume of overreacting freakouts if ISU makes the tourney every year for the next decade+. People get used to even the craziest roller coasters if they stay on it long enough.

Well said and a lot of truth in what you've said. All teams have their ups and downs within a game and throughout the season, it doesn't mean players aren't trying or are necessarily slacking off. And I think some of our fans are so fearful of returning to the GMac years that any loss scares the h out of them.