*** Official Iowa State Season Thread ***

67CY

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2006
4,509
3,194
113
Conditt is a square peg that Prohm has been trying to jam into a round hole for 3 years. Conditt is your classic rim runner, a big who loves to run and play in space. He should be playing for an uptempo team somewhere, or only be used when we go uptempo (which we don't, of course).

Rather than try to coach him on skills to make him more effective in this role, and then use him in that role... Prohm has been trying to turn him into a Jared Homan type space heater.

That's why you see him "regressing". He is being coached/developed in the OPPOSITE way of what he should be. I would say Prohm has ruined any chance for GC4 to play professionally anywhere. He wasn't going NBA, but he could have had a nice run in Europe. CPS just killed his development and any professional career potential. Absolute malpractice.

My 2 cents, I could be wrong.
Same thing he did to Jameel M
 

Cyinthenorth

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Mar 29, 2013
15,912
11,988
113
36
Dubuque
I'd say my logic extends to GC and the freshmen too, at least for this past game. Those guys, as at least rotation players, know with 8 guys they can't afford to just be a placeholder. So they maybe pushed in ways they wouldn't ordinarily push.
That makes sense. Harris got a little happy trigger too, but somebody had to try to score other than Bolton, so I don't place too much criticism there.
 

Clonefan32

Well-Known Member
Nov 19, 2008
23,555
26,009
113
That makes sense. Harris got a little happy trigger too, but somebody had to try to score other than Bolton, so I don't place too much criticism there.

There were undoubtedly some bad shots taken. But I imagine Bolton and Harris looked around and figured "welp, if no one else here is going to score I may as well give it a go".
 
  • Like
Reactions: atlantacyclone

CascadeClone

Well-Known Member
Oct 24, 2009
10,938
14,061
113
I agree. I'm not sure where it's coming from that Conditt was going to be the next coming of Craig Brackins or Marcus Fizer. .....I think his ceiling was Jameel McKay.
I'm certainly not arguing he was expected to be anything like those two guys, don't think anyone really is. But he absolutely could have (should have!) been a McKay type, and would have had more time in the system to learn some other skills - rebound better, maybe a 3pt shot, idk.

Instead we've asked him to do everything he is bad at, and scold him for doing what he is naturally good at. THAT seems to be what CSP specializes in wrt player development.

"You are a terrible shooter with dreadful form? Well, then fire away Nix! I am sure eventually you will hoist up two in a row with the same technique!"

"Kind of a lose handle there, huh, Rasir? Well, let's make you the point guard! You'll get the hang of it sooner or later!"

"Solo, you're a little undersized, so let's have you body up whatever 280lb monster Kansas is putting out there tonight! That will help you learn to be taller!"
 

Rural

Well-Known Member
Feb 3, 2010
43,238
36,474
113
I'm certainly not arguing he was expected to be anything like those two guys, don't think anyone really is. But he absolutely could have (should have!) been a McKay type, and would have had more time in the system to learn some other skills - rebound better, maybe a 3pt shot, idk.

Instead we've asked him to do everything he is bad at, and scold him for doing what he is naturally good at. THAT seems to be what CSP specializes in wrt player development.

"You are a terrible shooter with dreadful form? Well, then fire away Nix! I am sure eventually you will hoist up two in a row with the same technique!"

"Kind of a lose handle there, huh, Rasir? Well, let's make you the point guard! You'll get the hang of it sooner or later!"

"Solo, you're a little undersized, so let's have you body up whatever 280lb monster Kansas is putting out there tonight! That will help you learn to be taller!"


We've managed to go ofer for people that can go the boards.
 

Clonefan32

Well-Known Member
Nov 19, 2008
23,555
26,009
113
I'm certainly not arguing he was expected to be anything like those two guys, don't think anyone really is. But he absolutely could have (should have!) been a McKay type, and would have had more time in the system to learn some other skills - rebound better, maybe a 3pt shot, idk.

Instead we've asked him to do everything he is bad at, and scold him for doing what he is naturally good at. THAT seems to be what CSP specializes in wrt player development.

"You are a terrible shooter with dreadful form? Well, then fire away Nix! I am sure eventually you will hoist up two in a row with the same technique!"

"Kind of a lose handle there, huh, Rasir? Well, let's make you the point guard! You'll get the hang of it sooner or later!"

"Solo, you're a little undersized, so let's have you body up whatever 280lb monster Kansas is putting out there tonight! That will help you learn to be taller!"

"Lindell you had a great freshmen year. Dynamic scorer with a bunch of upside. I think I like the role of 25 mpg 6th man for you."
 

madguy30

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Nov 15, 2011
57,412
55,326
113
"Lindell you had a great freshmen year. Dynamic scorer with a bunch of upside. I think I like the role of 25 mpg 6th man for you."

'Cameron, seems like less is more and you're at your best when you're just out there playing basketball, so here's a bunch of things to think about when or if you're out there.'

*I realize there were other things that kept him from being a bigger part and ultimately it was up to him, but when the chance arose he was a shell of his first year.

And I know that Solo had his hand injury, but since CSP admitted to not playing him enough earlier in 2016-17:

'Solomon, even though we just need SOMEBODY in the middle to help this this roster of fairly regular NBA players, you need to earn your minutes instead of learning by playing'.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CascadeClone

NoCreativity

Well-Known Member
Nov 12, 2015
12,491
10,806
113
Des Moines
'Cameron, seems like less is more and you're at your best when you're just out there playing basketball, so here's a bunch of things to think about when or if you're out there.'

*I realize there were other things that kept him from being a bigger part and ultimately it was up to him, but when the chance arose he was a shell of his first year.

And I know that Solo had his hand injury, but since CSP admitted to not playing him enough earlier in 2016-17:

'Solomon, even though we just need SOMEBODY in the middle to help this this roster of fairly regular NBA players, you need to earn your minutes instead of learning by playing'.
Lard was checked out mentally that year. I dont blame him though, guy averafed almost a double-double as a freshman in the best conference in basketball. He paid his dues then when he is cleared for full participation, Prohm still decides to hold a grudge against him the rest of the year.

He did the same thing with Talley that year who could have been a solid contributer off the bench.

Same issues with McKay in 2016. Prohm gets paid to win basketball games and put players in the best possible situations to succeed, not be a school guidance counselor.
 

CycloneErik

Well-Known Member
Jan 31, 2008
108,178
53,435
113
Jamerica
rememberingdoria.wordpress.com
Lard was checked out mentally that year. I dont blame him though, guy averafed almost a double-double as a freshman in the best conference in basketball. He paid his dues then when he is cleared for full participation, Prohm still decides to hold a grudge against him the rest of the year.

He did the same thing with Talley that year who could have been a solid contributer off the bench.

Same issues with McKay in 2016. Prohm gets paid to win basketball games and put players in the best possible situations to succeed, not be a school guidance counselor.

We're due for a weird suspension right about now.
 

Cyinthenorth

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Mar 29, 2013
15,912
11,988
113
36
Dubuque
'Cameron, seems like less is more and you're at your best when you're just out there playing basketball, so here's a bunch of things to think about when or if you're out there.'

*I realize there were other things that kept him from being a bigger part and ultimately it was up to him, but when the chance arose he was a shell of his first year.

And I know that Solo had his hand injury, but since CSP admitted to not playing him enough earlier in 2016-17:

'Solomon, even though we just need SOMEBODY in the middle to help this this roster of fairly regular NBA players, you need to earn your minutes instead of learning by playing'.
Cam was not good his SO year. He kind of looked like George Conditt now. Incredible foul rate and horrible attitude/body language the entire time he was out there. Not sure what it about Prohm's culture, but something obviously lacks big time. If you are deemed to have poor character, you don't play in some of these guys cases. Not sure what it is about GC, other than he just has not progressed.
 

xboxfever

Well-Known Member
Nov 4, 2008
13,246
6,890
113
Lard was checked out mentally that year. I dont blame him though, guy averafed almost a double-double as a freshman in the best conference in basketball. He paid his dues then when he is cleared for full participation, Prohm still decides to hold a grudge against him the rest of the year.

He did the same thing with Talley that year who could have been a solid contributer off the bench.

Same issues with McKay in 2016. Prohm gets paid to win basketball games and put players in the best possible situations to succeed, not be a school guidance counselor.
Lard didn’t play because he smoked weed all day in his apartment (apparently in the nude a lot too) and played video games. He was late/didn’t show up to practices and didn’t put forth a lot of effort. That’s coming from a first hand account from one of his teammates. I’ve never been a fan of Prohm, but he did everything imaginable to help Lard but Lard just couldn’t see the light. Prohm deserves a lot of credit for trying to help Lard.
 

NoCreativity

Well-Known Member
Nov 12, 2015
12,491
10,806
113
Des Moines
Lard didn’t play because he smoked weed all day in his apartment (apparently in the nude a lot too) and played video games. He was late/didn’t show up to practices and didn’t put forth a lot of effort. That’s coming from a first hand account from one of his teammates. I’ve never been a fan of Prohm, but he did everything imaginable to help Lard but Lard just couldn’t see the light. Prohm deserves a lot of credit for trying to help Lard.
Thanks Captain Obvious, everyone is well aware why he didn't play. My problem is the way Prohm handled him, along with Talley and McKay.

Either kick them off the team or let them play the minutes they deserve. Putting them in for 2 minutes at a time, then never seeing the floor again, while other players can continue with horrible, lazy, team last oriented basketball is not the way to motivate players with behavioral issues.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: IASTATE07

xboxfever

Well-Known Member
Nov 4, 2008
13,246
6,890
113
Thanks Captain Obvious, everyone is well aware why he didn't play. My problem is the way Prohm handled him, along with Talley and McKay.

Either kick them off the team or let them play the minutes they deserve. Putting them in for 2 minutes at a time, then never seeing the floor again, while other players can continue with horrible, lazy, team last oriented basketball is not the way to motivate players with behavioral issues.
That is not what you said at all. You said he payed his dues and Prohm punished him for it. He didnt pay his dues. He was lazy, smoked weed all day and didn’t put anywhere near the time and effort as everyone else on the team. He shouldn’t have played period.
 

NoCreativity

Well-Known Member
Nov 12, 2015
12,491
10,806
113
Des Moines
That is not what you said at all. You said he payed his dues and Prohm punished him for it. He didnt pay his dues. He was lazy, smoked weed all day and didn’t put anywhere near the time and effort as everyone else on the team. He shouldn’t have played period.
Him and Talley were both suspended, then allowed back on the team. So you're telling me Prohm suspended both of them, nothing changed at all, and Prohm just let them come back with no change in behavior? I dont believe that for one second. If they hadn't made progress he would have kicked them off the team.
 

NENick

Well-Known Member
Feb 14, 2017
2,578
4,297
113
Lard was checked out mentally that year. I dont blame him though, guy averafed almost a double-double as a freshman in the best conference in basketball. He paid his dues then when he is cleared for full participation, Prohm still decides to hold a grudge against him the rest of the year.

I keep finding myself having to type things that sound like I'm supporting CSP, but the inaccurate BS isn't needed. Lard played and got multiple fouls essentially EVERY TIME HE PLAYED! He couldn't stay on the court!

Thanks Captain Obvious, everyone is well aware why he didn't play.

Snarky and stupid.
 

Thompsonclone

Well-Known Member
Dec 13, 2008
4,026
3,405
113
Ames
Him and Talley were both suspended, then allowed back on the team. So you're telling me Prohm suspended both of them, nothing changed at all, and Prohm just let them come back with no change in behavior? I dont believe that for one second. If they hadn't made progress he would have kicked them off the team.
He also wouldn’t have played Lard so much against Ohio State if his issues were really that bad. Meaning I think the whole “Lard was a bad teammate and cancer to the program” talk was so overhyped. He was eligible to play and Prohm didn’t play him. Lard wasn’t perfect by any means but if you play the guy, I’m sure his overall attitude is going to be way better. Prohm played him as a freshman and Lard seemed to stay out of trouble. Starting sitting a guy for little reasons and it’s hard to reel him back in. That team could have been so dangerous if Haliburton, Wigginton, THT, Shayok and Lard were given the freedom to play together. Jacobson and NWB are perfect bench guys if you ask me.
 

alarson

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Mar 15, 2006
59,620
74,480
113
Ankeny
Lard didn’t play because he smoked weed all day in his apartment (apparently in the nude a lot too) and played video games. He was late/didn’t show up to practices and didn’t put forth a lot of effort. That’s coming from a first hand account from one of his teammates. I’ve never been a fan of Prohm, but he did everything imaginable to help Lard but Lard just couldn’t see the light. Prohm deserves a lot of credit for trying to help Lard.

Some of our best teams under hoiberg smoked a ton of weed, at least according to a friend who lived in the same building with some of them. Usually had better games if theyd been smoking the night before.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: NoCreativity