Restaurants in Ames.

CyNews

Well-Known Member
Mar 19, 2021
2,354
2,028
113
68

Freebird

Well-Known Member
Apr 11, 2006
5,568
8,321
113
So Jeff’s pizza now is like what Gumby’s was and they have something like pokey sticks called smotherella sticks and they also have the good pepperoni rolls too with garlic butter to dip in.
Jeff’s is great if you like raw pizza dough instead of crust in the middle of your pizza and some of the shittiest customer service in town.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DFWClone

SolarGarlic

Well-Known Member
Jan 18, 2016
6,315
9,629
113
Nobody thinks fast food is "expensive". Some fast food is more expensive than other fast food. If I'm getting fast food for myself, I'm trying to stay around $10. If it's more than that, it's "expensive".
 

cyfan4St8

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Jan 3, 2008
804
357
63
45
Iowa
Jeff’s is great if you like raw pizza dough instead of crust in the middle of your pizza and some of the shittiest customer service in town.
It’s ran by college kids that don’t care if you’re happy or not lol…. And we’ve ate there since Gumby’s closed a long time ago . Yeah once in awhile it’s not perfect but majority of the time it’s pretty good. Best pizza in town is by far Great Plains. We switch back and forth each week between those two places.

I would say our top restaurants in Ames go as this.

1. Ge-Angelo’s
2.Aunt Maude’s
3.Wallaby’s
4.Flame & Skewer ( you’ve got to support Moe)
5. Dublin Bay
6.Great Plains
7. Jeff’s Pizza
8. Jimmy’s BBQ (Boone)
9. Hickory Park
10. Sweet Caroline’s
11. Brick City Grill
12. Iowa Stater
13. El Azteca
14. Cafe
15. Provisions
16. Corn Bread
17. Jethro’s
18. Flip n jacks
19. The Grove Cafe
20. West town pub
21. 5 guys
22. Texas Roadhouse
23. Cafe Beaudelaire
24. Culver’s
25. Wing stop
 

2speedy1

Well-Known Member
Jan 4, 2014
6,682
7,531
113
It’s ran by college kids that don’t care if you’re happy or not lol…. And we’ve ate there since Gumby’s closed a long time ago . Yeah once in awhile it’s not perfect but majority of the time it’s pretty good. Best pizza in town is by far Great Plains. We switch back and forth each week between those two places.

I would say our top restaurants in Ames go as this.

1. Ge-Angelo’s
2.Aunt Maude’s
3.Wallaby’s
4.Flame & Skewer ( you’ve got to support Moe)
5. Dublin Bay
6.Great Plains
7. Jeff’s Pizza
8. Jimmy’s BBQ (Boone)
9. Hickory Park
10. Sweet Caroline’s
11. Brick City Grill
12. Iowa Stater
13. El Azteca
14. Cafe
15. Provisions
16. Corn Bread
17. Jethro’s
18. Flip n jacks
19. The Grove Cafe
20. West town pub
21. 5 guys
22. Texas Roadhouse
23. Cafe Beaudelaire
24. Culver’s
25. Wing stop
Ive never understood the love for Great Plains. I get that its different, but I dont find it overwhelmingly great. I never thought the dry crust with honey was great. It excessive cheese was just not great. It just wasnt that great for me.

I guess maybe I should try it again since I havent had it in 25ish years, but when I did I just was not impressed. Oversized dry powdery crust, only able to stomach if you smothered it in honey, which made it a strange mix of flavors with pizza, extra thick cheese, and not much else. Seemed kind of gimmicky.

But I know a lot of people love Great Plains, so I am not trying argue their taste preferences. I just dont know if it is because it is different or if it is really that good of a pizza.

Davinci's was the best Pizza when I was at ISU, But the cheap stuff for after drinks like Gumbys, Pizza Pit, Home Team, none winning awards were great for what they were.

Then again I am not that much of a fan of Casey's Pizza either, and for some reason people think its the best ever. Although I have found the quality and taste of Casey's depends greatly on location, there is very little consistency.

Then looking at your list not having BBops in the top 25 I would have to disagree on too. But then I have not eaten at most of those on your list.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DFWClone and Spam

cytor

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Nov 20, 2011
8,174
13,034
113
Ive never understood the love for Great Plains. I get that its different, but I dont find it overwhelmingly great. I never thought the dry crust with honey was great. It excessive cheese was just not great. It just wasnt that great for me.

I guess maybe I should try it again since I havent had it in 25ish years, but when I did I just was not impressed. Oversized dry powdery crust, only able to stomach if you smothered it in honey, which made it a strange mix of flavors with pizza, extra thick cheese, and not much else. Seemed kind of gimmicky.

But I know a lot of people love Great Plains, so I am not trying argue their taste preferences. I just dont know if it is because it is different or if it is really that good of a pizza.

Davinci's was the best Pizza when I was at ISU, But the cheap stuff for after drinks like Gumbys, Pizza Pit, Home Team, none winning awards were great for what they were.

Then again I am not that much of a fan of Casey's Pizza either, and for some reason people think its the best ever. Although I have found the quality and taste of Casey's depends greatly on location, there is very little consistency.

Then looking at your list not having BBops in the top 25 I would have to disagree on too. But then I have not eaten at most of those on your list.
Try the thin crust pizza at Great plains. It's really good and you dont need the honey.
 

ruflosn

Well-Known Member
Dec 21, 2008
1,094
674
113
It’s ran by college kids that don’t care if you’re happy or not lol…. And we’ve ate there since Gumby’s closed a long time ago . Yeah once in awhile it’s not perfect but majority of the time it’s pretty good. Best pizza in town is by far Great Plains. We switch back and forth each week between those two places.

I would say our top restaurants in Ames go as this.

1. Ge-Angelo’s
2.Aunt Maude’s
3.Wallaby’s
4.Flame & Skewer ( you’ve got to support Moe)
5. Dublin Bay
6.Great Plains
7. Jeff’s Pizza
8. Jimmy’s BBQ (Boone)
9. Hickory Park
10. Sweet Caroline’s
11. Brick City Grill
12. Iowa Stater
13. El Azteca
14. Cafe
15. Provisions
16. Corn Bread
17. Jethro’s
18. Flip n jacks
19. The Grove Cafe
20. West town pub
21. 5 guys
22. Texas Roadhouse
23. Cafe Beaudelaire
24. Culver’s
25. Wing stop
If you are going to add Boone, you also have to put whatcha smoking in Luther on the list. Also, no B-Bops?
 

2speedy1

Well-Known Member
Jan 4, 2014
6,682
7,531
113
If you are going to add Boone, you also have to put whatcha smoking in Luther on the list. Also, no B-Bops?
I tried to go to Whatcha Smokin one time, everyone said it was so good but go early because they run out of food. We got there at 4:40pm. Waited for a seat until 5pm. When seated they told us they were out of all items on menu except 1. I said how can a restaurant run when they sell out of any menu items, let alone basically the entire menu before dinner time even arrives? I was told by the staff, "well you need to come early." I asked Earlier than 5pm? For Dinner? Their excuse was they smoke everything fresh each day and when they run out they run out. We left and went to Hickory Park.

Poor management. If a place cant gauge their quantities better than that, that they run out of food 4+ hours before close and before even the dinner hour, then they need someone else doing the management. Its one thing to run out of 1 thing or even 2. And run out of more as you approach closing time, but it was obvious they always run out early in the day and that day was just business as usual. So if you want to actually get food you have to go for lunch, and their is no point in them being open most times for dinner. Either that or they need to have adequate meats available.

Maybe they have done better since or have better days, but everyone I talk to says you have to go really early otherwise they run out. I dont plan to go back unless I go for lunch, which I doubt.
 
  • Dislike
Reactions: Cyclone06

JP4CY

Lord, beer me strength.
Staff member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Dec 19, 2008
74,695
95,789
113
Testifying
The talk of pizza: there used to be a stone oven pizza truck that would park in front of the bowling alley on Duff. One took a couple of minutes, it was great!
Wonder what ever happened to that guy.
 

CyCrazy

Well-Known Member
Dec 17, 2008
27,073
15,312
113
Ames
I tried to go to Whatcha Smokin one time, everyone said it was so good but go early because they run out of food. We got there at 4:40pm. Waited for a seat until 5pm. When seated they told us they were out of all items on menu except 1. I said how can a restaurant run when they sell out of any menu items, let alone basically the entire menu before dinner time even arrives? I was told by the staff, "well you need to come early." I asked Earlier than 5pm? For Dinner? Their excuse was they smoke everything fresh each day and when they run out they run out. We left and went to Hickory Park.

Poor management. If a place cant gauge their quantities better than that, that they run out of food 4+ hours before close and before even the dinner hour, then they need someone else doing the management. Its one thing to run out of 1 thing or even 2. And run out of more as you approach closing time, but it was obvious they always run out early in the day and that day was just business as usual. So if you want to actually get food you have to go for lunch, and their is no point in them being open most times for dinner. Either that or they need to have adequate meats available.

Maybe they have done better since or have better days, but everyone I talk to says you have to go really early otherwise they run out. I dont plan to go back unless I go for lunch, which I doubt.

This isnt uncommon for bbq places, well good ones. They smoke for the day and thats it. Watcha Smoking is awesome.
 

2speedy1

Well-Known Member
Jan 4, 2014
6,682
7,531
113
This isnt uncommon for bbq places, well good ones. They smoke for the day and thats it. Watcha Smoking is awesome.
I understand that, but they should be able to gauge how much to smoke better than what they do. If the consistently run out before dinner time, then they need to plan better.
 

CyCrazy

Well-Known Member
Dec 17, 2008
27,073
15,312
113
Ames
I understand that, but they should be able to gauge how much to smoke better than what they do. If the consistently run out before dinner time, then they need to plan better.

How can the accurately gauge the amount of people and food needed? I have been plenty of times and they are out of something. Big deal order something else.
 

Agclone91

Well-Known Member
Feb 5, 2011
2,874
1,005
113
Ames
If you are going to add Boone, you also have to put whatcha smoking in Luther on the list. Also, no B-Bops?
Whatcha smokin' is great, buy holy **** have their prices gone through the roof on some items. I called last night to place an order for there beef rib special (usually $29 for a dinner..expensive but an occasional treat) and was told that they are now "market price" so it would be $45. Ok, cool, cancel that and I'll just get some pork ribs. $12 per quarter rack...48 freaking dollars for a full rack!

I canceled my order all together and got cornbred. Love Whatcha Smokin', but their popularity seems to be leading to some price gouging. They seem the be the only BBQ restaurant who's "market prices" have gone completely through the roof.
 
  • Wow
Reactions: NWICY

TitanClone

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Dec 21, 2008
3,600
2,960
113
Jeff’s is great if you like raw pizza dough instead of crust in the middle of your pizza and some of the shittiest customer service in town.
Smothers with nacho and feta cheese sauce are great at 2 AM, other than that Jeff's blows. Ordering that while waiting in the fajita man line turned what would have been a ton of miserable hangovers into mild ones.