***NIL Mafia***

cyfanatic13

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Dec 19, 2008
11,489
10,660
113
Vote Count:

2- mj4cy (psy 9:36 am) (9:40 am)
1- michael (cubs 8:21 am)
1- KC (Farnsy 9:51 am)
1- Dandy (Wanderer 10:04 am)
1- Vikes (CYme 10:17 am)
 

CycloneNorth

Well-Known Member
Mar 29, 2010
3,879
1,561
113
Nashville, TN
To get more activity let's throw out who we would have recruited if we were Mafia. Also will create potential clues for later in the game as number dwindle.

I would have recruited michael. Very strong player and tends to stay under the radar so not an early target.
 

Farnsworth

Well-Known Member
Apr 11, 2006
17,368
5,864
113
Des Moines, IA
So why is this okay for you but not KC?

Just bad logic

Just vote for me if you want to already.

Also did you read the posts I made yesterday at all, I rescinded twice as a joke as it didn't matter. Both were after the comment I linked to saying rescinding is pointless. Consider my first vote the day 3 vote.
 

CycloneNorth

Well-Known Member
Mar 29, 2010
3,879
1,561
113
Nashville, TN
The mafia's successful recruit was after Day 2. Same day Fitzy threw out his moores theory which cows joined in on and apparently investigated that night.

Mafia didn't know cows was the NCAA at the time but could they still have recruited Fitzy thinking that vote/comment would have him viewed as an inno? He'd look good if moores (2nd highest vote getter that day) was voted out.
 

PSYclone22

Visual Analytics Mercenary
SuperFanatic
Aug 15, 2012
5,101
3,211
113
Des Moines
Just vote for me if you want to already.

Also did you read the posts I made yesterday at all, I rescinded twice as a joke as it didn't matter. Both were after the comment I linked to saying rescinding is pointless. Consider my first vote the day 3 vote.
I think you're innocent lol.
 
  • Friendly
Reactions: Farnsworth

VikesFan22

Well-Known Member
Nov 9, 2011
16,572
1,315
113
Ames, IA
The mafia's successful recruit was after Day 2. Same day Fitzy threw out his moores theory which cows joined in on and apparently investigated that night.

Mafia didn't know cows was the NCAA at the time but could they still have recruited Fitzy thinking that vote/comment would have him viewed as an inno? He'd look good if moores (2nd highest vote getter that day) was voted out.
This is similar logic to why I think Farnsy could have been recruited. So I'll answer your other post's question with Farnsy. But Fitzy is a good answer.
 

Clark

Well-Known Member
Jun 24, 2009
18,451
4,716
113
Altoona
It seemed suspicious to me that Michael logged in to vote, then an hour later an insta fill is announced.

Then I looked into cyfan's posting history and he went pretty much all day without posting so it may have been someone who sent in the kill much earlier. Still may be mafia, but need more evidence

gipper, farnsy and dandy's voting was pretty bad. Moores was an important enough role to stick your neck out for. They got some splainin to do. Cows hint wasn't a subtle one and yet all three were trying pretty hard to "avoid a runway"

Then you look at day 2 voting. Fitzy and Cows tied moores in the vote lead at 4:21. Then Spiker and Cubs follow with votes for ctown at 4:51 and 4:54 to push him back into the lead.

I think one of those two is mafia. Vote Spiker
 

Bret44

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Sep 8, 2009
17,303
7,889
113
Cedar River Valley
I am going to vote now, but reserve the right to change if I rememebr I am playing.

Based on North's theory Vote Vikes
 

CycloneNorth

Well-Known Member
Mar 29, 2010
3,879
1,561
113
Nashville, TN
It seemed suspicious to me that Michael logged in to vote, then an hour later an insta fill is announced.

Then I looked into cyfan's posting history and he went pretty much all day without posting so it may have been someone who sent in the kill much earlier. Still may be mafia, but need more evidence

gipper, farnsy and dandy's voting was pretty bad. Moores was an important enough role to stick your neck out for. They got some splainin to do. Cows hint wasn't a subtle one and yet all three were trying pretty hard to "avoid a runway"

Then you look at day 2 voting. Fitzy and Cows tied moores in the vote lead at 4:21. Then Spiker and Cubs follow with votes for ctown at 4:51 and 4:54 to push him back into the lead.

I think one of those two is mafia. Vote Spiker
I don't think mafia would make the gipper, farnsy, and dandy votes. Much easier to pile on a sure runaway.

I do like the Spiker/Cubs theory.
 

cyclonespiker33

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
Jan 19, 2011
15,728
9,219
113
Dandy had a decent number of votes on day 2 before a couple rescinds and someone else getting pushed up. I think it's worth getting him towards the top today.

Vote dandy
 

Cleaver

Active Member
Jul 9, 2015
573
144
43
It seemed suspicious to me that Michael logged in to vote, then an hour later an insta fill is announced.

Then I looked into cyfan's posting history and he went pretty much all day without posting so it may have been someone who sent in the kill much earlier. Still may be mafia, but need more evidence

gipper, farnsy and dandy's voting was pretty bad. Moores was an important enough role to stick your neck out for. They got some splainin to do. Cows hint wasn't a subtle one and yet all three were trying pretty hard to "avoid a runway"

Then you look at day 2 voting. Fitzy and Cows tied moores in the vote lead at 4:21. Then Spiker and Cubs follow with votes for ctown at 4:51 and 4:54 to push him back into the lead.

I think one of those two is mafia. Vote Spiker
I like where your mind is thinking on this one. I'll vote Cubs and get him pushed up towards the top as well.
 

Fitzy

Tracer Bullet
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Apr 8, 2014
8,437
4,414
113
La La Land
The mafia's successful recruit was after Day 2. Same day Fitzy threw out his moores theory which cows joined in on and apparently investigated that night.

Mafia didn't know cows was the NCAA at the time but could they still have recruited Fitzy thinking that vote/comment would have him viewed as an inno? He'd look good if moores (2nd highest vote getter that day) was voted out.
Not a bad theory, but I wasn’t the recruit. If I was in the mafia, I probably would have investigated me after that as opposed to recruit. They probably thought I could be the NCAA after that, and wouldn’t have wanted to waste a bid on me if there was a chance I was not recruitable.

I’m looking back at that day 2 vote though, and Clark is the one that sticks out to me. I believe Ctown was up by a vote late, and Clark basically slammed the door with his vote in order to prevent Moores from going home. And that was probably worth being bold about if you’re the mafia, since they would have had no more chances to recruit had Moores gone home during the day.

Vote Clark
 

cyfanatic13

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Dec 19, 2008
11,489
10,660
113
Vote Count:

3- Vikes (CYme 10:17 am) (North 10:59 am) (bret 11:45 am)
2- mj4cy (psy 9:36 am) (9:40 am)
2- Dandy (Wanderer 10:04 am) (spiker 11:54 am)
1- michael (cubs 8:21 am)
1- KC (Farnsy 9:51 am)
1- Bsalty (gblade 10:45 am)
1- Spiker (clark 11:36 am)
1- Cubs (cleaver 11:47 am)
1- Clark (Fitzy 12:52 am)