*** Stranger Things Mafia Game Thread ***

[ISUCubswin]

Why?

Why do you ask so many questions?

 

[ISUCubswin]

It's 10 am on Day 2. I have zero strong opinions. Based on the limited conversations, I'd say JM is innocent. Cyfan keeps complaining so he's probably innocent. Something salty said earlier made me think he's innocent as well. That's all I've got for ya.

That could be the most mafia thing I’ve ever read in my entire life.

I have at least nearly double digit posters I’m convinced are mafia.

 

[cyfanatic13]

Why do you ask so many questions?

Walk me through how keeping it tied is a good thing?

 

[discydisc]

Since today is going to be poor for getting info from people via their votes, I have a hypothetical.

You - the person reading this - are in a party with spiker, azhuth, and Clonies. During the second night of your quest that hypothetically continues our adventures beginning yesterday at 7am, azhuth mysteriously dies.

Based on their actions thus far, who are you more sus of - spiker or Clonies? And why?

Spiker-don’t trust male volleyball players

 

[Fitzy]

Day 2 Vote Count

6 - michaelrr1 - bsaltyman (7:15 a.m.), CycloneNorth (7:17 a.m.), cyguytillidie (8:34 a.m.), CloniesForLife (8:41 a.m.), azhuth09 (8:58 a.m.), Cyclonscin (9:12 a.m.)
6 - CycloneNorth - discydisc (8:03 a.m.), cyclonespiker33 (8:06 a.m.), moores2 (8:50 a.m.), SCNCY (9:05 a.m.), GBlade (9:19 a.m.), ISUCubswin (9:33 a.m.)

 

[VikesFan22]

Vote Michael since North is an active player and he deserves to stick around.


Day 2 Vote Count

7 - michaelrr1 - bsaltyman (7:15 a.m.), CycloneNorth (7:17 a.m.), cyguytillidie (8:34 a.m.), CloniesForLife (8:41 a.m.), azhuth09 (8:58 a.m.), Cyclonscin (9:12 a.m.), VikesFan22 (10:12)

6 - CycloneNorth - discydisc (8:03 a.m.), cyclonespiker33 (8:06 a.m.), moores2 (8:50 a.m.), SCNCY (9:05 a.m.), GBlade (9:19 a.m.), ISUCubswin (9:33 a.m.)

 

[moores2]

inno leans - salty, discy, cyclonscin

Meh - psy (normally doesn't get to stick around too long as an inno, however he hosted last game so I'm guessing mafia would also let him play for a while)

cubs

vikes

 

[JM4CY]

@JM4CY since you asked: I like to ask open ended questions and allow people to answer without leading them to my thoughts.

If I say "I think SaraV and Cows are sus, what do you think SCNCY?" and SCNCY is Mafia, he'll probably just say "yes sir, both are sus, please let me follow your every move, sir".

And that's not as helpful as making people think for themselves.

I jive with you, Psy. I pick up with what you put down.

 

[ISUCubswin]

Walk me through how keeping it tied is a good thing?

If it is a runaway, mafia can just hide their votes, mafia.

 

[VikesFan22]

That could be the most mafia thing I’ve ever read in my entire life.

I have at least nearly double digit posters I’m convinced are mafia.

Come at me bro

 

[JM4CY]

It's 10 am on Day 2. I have zero strong opinions. Based on the limited conversations, I'd say JM is innocent. Cyfan keeps complaining so he's probably innocent. Something salty said earlier made me think he's innocent as well. That's all I've got for ya.

You said something that I said when I was mafia once. Makes me sus. Also, I would of considered you (and most) a better player than me so maybe I should think that is an inno thing of you to do.

 

[JM4CY]

inno leans - salty, discy, cyclonscin

Meh - psy (normally doesn't get to stick around too long as an inno, however he hosted last game so I'm guessing mafia would also let him play for a while)

cubs

vikes

Why is discy lean inno? I agree with the other two.

 

[JM4CY]

Why is discy lean inno? I agree with the other two.

Also, i thought psy was mafia last game?

 

[PSYclone22]

Cyfan13 mayored last game and I was the Tamperer. I technically mayored game before that.

 

[cyclonespiker33]

Spiker-don’t trust male volleyball players

Don't be scared of your feelings

 

[moores2]

Why is discy lean inno? I agree with the other two.

reasons.

 

[cyfanatic13]

If it is a runaway, mafia can just hide their votes, mafia.

Here's why I think we should choose one and runaway with it. This is all under the assumption that one of North and michael is demogorgon, and one is an inno. I don't think mafia would be dumb enough to risk them both being mafia.

Option A: We keep it tied, demogorgon's vote doubles, we kill an innocent, waste tomorrow voting out the other one. Maybe we could pick up some things from the mafia voting patterns, but I highly doubt it.
Option B: We runaway on one, he turns out to be the demogorgon. We take out a mafia, and we know the other one is likely innocent, forcing mafia to have to use a kill on them at some point cause we probably won't vote them out.
Option C: We runaway on one, are wrong and take out the innocent, waste tomorrow voting out the other one.

Maybe I'm wrong, but I think Option B is the pretty clear answer here. I'd love to hear reasons why if people disagree with me

 

[JM4CY]

Here's why I think we should choose one and runaway with it. This is all under the assumption that one of North and michael is demogorgon, and one is an inno. I don't think mafia would be dumb enough to risk them both being mafia.

Option A: We keep it tied, demogorgon's vote doubles, we kill an innocent, waste tomorrow voting out the other one. Maybe we could pick up some things from the mafia voting patterns, but I highly doubt it.
Option B: We runaway on one, he turns out to be the demogorgon. We take out a mafia, and we know the other one is likely innocent, forcing mafia to have to use a kill on them at some point cause we probably won't vote them out.
Option C: We runaway on one, are wrong and take out the innocent, waste tomorrow voting out the other one.

Maybe I'm wrong, but I think Option B is the pretty clear answer here. I'd love to hear reasons why if people disagree with me

Shoot our wad on one and hope we get it right. Spend the rest of the day answering the riddler's (Psy) questions. You don't answer, then you're maf-scum.

 

[cyfanatic13]

vote michael

 

[CloniesForLife]

Here's why I think we should choose one and runaway with it. This is all under the assumption that one of North and michael is demogorgon, and one is an inno. I don't think mafia would be dumb enough to risk them both being mafia.

Option A: We keep it tied, demogorgon's vote doubles, we kill an innocent, waste tomorrow voting out the other one. Maybe we could pick up some things from the mafia voting patterns, but I highly doubt it.
Option B: We runaway on one, he turns out to be the demogorgon. We take out a mafia, and we know the other one is likely innocent, forcing mafia to have to use a kill on them at some point cause we probably won't vote them out.
Option C: We runaway on one, are wrong and take out the innocent, waste tomorrow voting out the other one.

Maybe I'm wrong, but I think Option B is the pretty clear answer here. I'd love to hear reasons why if people disagree with me

Yeah I'm not understanding what valuable info we can get out of a close vote when we know one of them is mafia