*** Stranger Things Mafia Game Thread ***

Cyclonsin

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Dec 4, 2020
2,394
4,951
113
36
Savannah, GA
Since Psy’s dead ( I got you buddy) let’s play a game, rank the following in terms of most sus: Salty, Cubs, Vikes, SCN, Clonies. Go!!!
I still think Vikes is my #1. People piling on azhuth yesterday for no solid reason other than "he's been quiet" didn't help ease my suspicions.

Beyond that, I don't get a strong feeling one way or the other about the others. But I'll be a good sport and play along:

2) Cubs
3) Clonies
4) JM
5) SCN
6) Sallty
 

JM4CY

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Aug 23, 2012
37,981
74,783
113
America
I still think Vikes is my #1. People piling on azhuth yesterday for no solid reason other than "he's been quiet" didn't help ease my suspicions.

Beyond that, I don't get a strong feeling one way or the other about the others. But I'll be a good sport and play along:

2) Cubs
3) Clonies
4) JM
5) SCN
6) Sallty
I see what you did there noob…..
 
  • Love
Reactions: Cyclonsin

bsaltyman

Drinker of Ames Lager
SuperFanatic
Sep 20, 2012
3,752
5,710
113
Ames, IA
My gut feeling is that JM is mafia. Not just because he was gunning for me yesterday, or his strange rescind and the re-vote for Azhuth, or because the mafia hit his nemesis PSY last night. JM just seems dirty this game.

Vote JM4CY
 

SCNCY

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Sep 11, 2009
10,730
8,538
113
37
La Fox, IL
Since Psy’s dead ( I got you buddy) let’s play a game, rank the following in terms of most sus: Salty, Cubs, Vikes, SCN, Clonies. Go!!!

Sounds like something Mafia would do. Select a list of innos with maybe one mafia in order to drive us off course. Super Sus.

Vote JM4CY.

If You are mafia, I am pretty certain that one person in that list is also Mafia.
 

JM4CY

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Aug 23, 2012
37,981
74,783
113
America
My gut feeling is that JM is mafia. Not just because he was gunning for me yesterday, or his strange rescind and the re-vote for Azhuth, or because the mafia hit his nemesis PSY last night. JM just seems dirty this game.

Vote JM4CY

Sounds like something Mafia would do. Select a list of innos with maybe one mafia in order to drive us off course. Super Sus.

Vote JM4CY.

If You are mafia, I am pretty certain that one person in that list is also Mafia.
kylo-ren-more.gif
 

Cyclonsin

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Dec 4, 2020
2,394
4,951
113
36
Savannah, GA
Anyone find it odd mafia didn't hit north?
Once Eleven's instakill is used up isn't she basically just a regular inno? Kind f like Steve, but without the need to say hair, bat, or babysitter.

That said, if North isn't Eleven, then that was an incredibly strange instakill.
 

JM4CY

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Aug 23, 2012
37,981
74,783
113
America
Sounds like something Mafia would do. Select a list of innos with maybe one mafia in order to drive us off course. Super Sus.

Vote JM4CY.

If You are mafia, I am pretty certain that one person in that list is also Mafia.
So trying to create conversation which often leads to gaining info about whose mafia is sus?
 

Fitzy

Tracer Bullet
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Apr 8, 2014
8,440
4,420
113
La La Land
Day 3 Vote Count

3 - JM4CY - bsaltyman (8:41 a.m.), SCNCY (8:45 a.m.), cyclonespiker33 (8:59 a.m.)
1 - gipper2001 - ISUCubswin (8:09 a.m.)
1 - bsaltyman - discydisc (8:11 a.m.)
1 - cyguytillidie - CycloneNorth (8:21 a.m.)
0 - ISUCubswin - cyclonespiker33 (8:35 a.m., rescind 8:59 a.m.)
 

cyguytillidie

Well-Known Member
Feb 9, 2010
11,349
309
83
34
Des Moines
Vote Vikes
Theory time.

Vikes was weird day 1 with the randomizer plan. He is currently my #1 suspect, hence vote yesterday and today. Working under assumption that he’s maf, Clonies has some interesting voting history through 2 days.

On Day 1andomizer plan was outlined and followed my majority by mid morning. Writing is on the wall that all but 1 will have 2 votes. Mafia knows this. Opportunity to vote their own. Clonies gives Vikes 2nd vote mid afternoon. 5 others at the time had 0 or 1 votes at time of his vote (yes discy, I acknowledge I was one of those 5).

Day 2 - Michael killed. Votes are moving. Vikes out to an early lead with azuth with 3 votes each. Clonies gives spiker his first vote at 3pm instead of breaking the tie. Later, with no other votes on spiker, Clonies moves his vote to SCN. At the time of that vote, Vikes and Azuth are again tied this time with 5 votes each. Clonies vote for SCN puts him at 3. Doesn’t break tie up top but brings another lunch candidate to the top. Gives Vikes a possible lifeline without drawing too much attention.

If Vikes is mafia, Clonies is my vote the next day.
 

JM4CY

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Aug 23, 2012
37,981
74,783
113
America
Theory time.

Vikes was weird day 1 with the randomizer plan. He is currently my #1 suspect, hence vote yesterday and today. Working under assumption that he’s maf, Clonies has some interesting voting history through 2 days.

On Day 1andomizer plan was outlined and followed my majority by mid morning. Writing is on the wall that all but 1 will have 2 votes. Mafia knows this. Opportunity to vote their own. Clonies gives Vikes 2nd vote mid afternoon. 5 others at the time had 0 or 1 votes at time of his vote (yes discy, I acknowledge I was one of those 5).

Day 2 - Michael killed. Votes are moving. Vikes out to an early lead with azuth with 3 votes each. Clonies gives spiker his first vote at 3pm instead of breaking the tie. Later, with no other votes on spiker, Clonies moves his vote to SCN. At the time of that vote, Vikes and Azuth are again tied this time with 5 votes each. Clonies vote for SCN puts him at 3. Doesn’t break tie up top but brings another lunch candidate to the top. Gives Vikes a possible lifeline without drawing too much attention.

If Vikes is mafia, Clonies is my vote the next day.
I get weird vibes from vikes as well. What makes me wonder is psy was balls deep on him yesterday. Psy is a known inno and got wacked. Why would mafia want to wack psy and then draw attention to vikes like that if vikes is mafia?
 

Fitzy

Tracer Bullet
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Apr 8, 2014
8,440
4,420
113
La La Land
Day 3 Vote Count

3 - JM4CY - bsaltyman (8:41 a.m.), SCNCY (8:45 a.m.), cyclonespiker33 (8:59 a.m.)
1 - gipper2001 - ISUCubswin (8:09 a.m.)
1 - bsaltyman - discydisc (8:11 a.m.)
1 - cyguytillidie - CycloneNorth (8:21 a.m.)
1 - VikesFan22 - cyguytillidie (9:29 a.m.)
0 - ISUCubswin - cyclonespiker33 (8:35 a.m., rescind 8:59 a.m.)
 

cyguytillidie

Well-Known Member
Feb 9, 2010
11,349
309
83
34
Des Moines
I get weird vibes from vikes as well. What makes me wonder is psy was balls deep on him yesterday. Psy is a known inno and got wacked. Why would mafia want to wack psy and then draw attention to vikes like that if vikes is mafia?
How’d you know PSY was inno?