Will Iowa State make postseason play?

Will we make postseason?

  • Yes NCAA Tournament

  • Yes NIT

  • Not at all


Results are only viewable after voting.

ruxCYtable

Well-Known Member
Aug 29, 2007
7,371
4,373
113
Colorado
Maybe we’re missing Ward more than we thought we would.
He averaged 4/4 against the shittiest teams we'll play all year. Is he really even a loss, other than depth? Honest question, maybe he's a great defender, I don't even know.
 

simply1

Rec Center HOF
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Jun 10, 2009
45,707
34,451
113
Pdx
Sorry, I do not understand what you are saying and how it remotely relates to my question (in which I genuinely asked - is there anything, at this point in the season, that is acceptable to criticize or worry about?). I kindly ask that you block me, as I am not aware of what I am not “addressing” for you. Thanks.
No problem, please block me in return. :)
 

Gunnerclone

Well-Known Member
Jul 16, 2010
75,623
79,908
113
DSM
He averaged 4/4 against the shittiest teams we'll play all year. Is he really even a loss, other than depth? Honest question, maybe he's a great defender, I don't even know.

I think he serves a few main purposes:

1) keeps BREs minutes down so Rob can come in and do what he does best
2) he’s the only guy that plays that can really go up and get stuff. We were getting killed by A&M beating us at the high point of rebounds
3) shot blocking threat. Kind of goes back to #2 but we have no other shot blocking threats

He’s a role player, but definitely a different type of asset when compared to our other post players.
 

Cyched

CF Influencer
May 8, 2009
38,377
66,354
113
Colorado
With the youth and new pieces this team was destined to take some lumps early on. Not to diminish the brutal way the game played out yesterday.

Ultimately, I want to see these guys improve and get more comfortable playing with each other, and against stiffer competition than what they're used to. There will be plenty of opportunities for resume wins in conference play.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NWICY

wonkadog

Well-Known Member
Apr 17, 2006
4,857
399
83
Ames, IA
Best recruiting class and one of the best transfer classes in iowa state history. Returning an elite point guard who added a 3pt shot in the offseason. Idk I don’t think I’m crazy to say this is one of the most talented rosters ever on paper. Doesn’t mean it actually is or that it will translate to results but my main point is that we underachieved in Orlando big time

I don't know why this is just taken for granted. Lipsey "worked on his shot" all summer and suddenly it's a given that he is some sort of marksman. I hope so.
 

Gunnerclone

Well-Known Member
Jul 16, 2010
75,623
79,908
113
DSM
I don't know why this is just taken for granted. Lipsey "worked on his shot" all summer and suddenly it's a given that he is some sort of marksman. I hope so.

Ya I love Tamin but the number of guards that couldn’t shoot in to their Sophomore college season and then become legitimate shooters has to be pretty small. Shooting the 3 is primarily based on talent for shooting the ball. Having to make mechanical adjustments AND redefine your existing game to include a deep ball is really really tough.

“Worked on their 3pt shot” is the basketball equivalent of “much improved O-Line” in football.
 
  • Winner
Reactions: Baseline23

simply1

Rec Center HOF
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Jun 10, 2009
45,707
34,451
113
Pdx
Ya I love Tamin but the number of guards that couldn’t shoot in to their Sophomore college season and then become legitimate shooters has to be pretty small. Shooting the 3 is primarily based on talent for shooting the ball. Having to make mechanical adjustments AND redefine your existing game to include a deep ball is really really tough.

“Worked on their 3pt shot” is the basketball equivalent of “much improved O-Line” in football.
So far he’s shooting a lot better than last year.
 

alarson

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Mar 15, 2006
59,509
74,255
113
Ankeny
Ya I love Tamin but the number of guards that couldn’t shoot in to their Sophomore college season and then become legitimate shooters has to be pretty small. Shooting the 3 is primarily based on talent for shooting the ball. Having to make mechanical adjustments AND redefine your existing game to include a deep ball is really really tough.

“Worked on their 3pt shot” is the basketball equivalent of “much improved O-Line” in football.

Yeah, shouldn't expect him to be a sharpshooter by any means. The main goal for his "improvement" is mainly just being a realistic threat to hit sometimes if teams choose to sag way off the way they commonly did last year.
 

allfourcy

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Apr 26, 2012
6,950
2,983
113
Sure wish we could get Tre King more inside shots- not only is he strong but he MAKES his freethrows! Yet, as some people often say, he might be one of those 'tweeners' without a true position. He has to battle with taller guys to get a rebound and picks up often costly fouls. But back to the question by the OP: If our shooting improves across the board, I think we get in. But, if this past weekend is a truer picture of our ability of putting the ball in the hole, yikes, gonna be a frustrating year. Plenty of ball movement and open looks, but struggled shooting. But I felt that even when we were beating up on the early teams (except Milan).

Surprised about our lack of depth. Biliew is only contributing spot minutes to rest others and apparently Watson even less. Very little contribution. Tough to win 3 games in 4 days playing 7 guys. Although A & M seemed to survive w/o starters.

We've all seen this before, tho. Gotta believe in our coaches.
 

t-noah

Well-Known Member
Feb 2, 2007
19,771
13,412
113
I wonder if the reason we are struggling with shooting is because the players have tired legs? We know our team pushes hard in practice, and the off season program is brutal. Maybe the cumulative effect from all of that plus 3 games in 4 days has worn the guys down. Overtraining does hurt performance. I also worry about Tamin, he is logging a lot of minutes. Anyway, just a theory as to why we are struggling.
I agree, and was wondering the same, in my last post. As hard as TJ pushes the defense and conditioning, it's a bit of a head scratcher why more players didn't get minutes during the ESPN Tournament. If you have depth, supposedly, use it.
 

ClonesTwenty1

Well-Known Member
May 23, 2018
17,810
21,820
113
I was, but I've never seen just a disparity in a guy's advertised ability's and actual out put. He's contributing absolutely nothing at this point. You can see he hustles, but he's just completely lost.
I’m still baffled by this. I very much understand where people are coming from saying give him time and he will come around… but Omaha was a top 15 recruit nationally. Those guys normally go into their universities and are big time contributors right away. We all know Omaha has the athleticism, but did his year away from prep school hurt him this bad for preparation? I really hope he can figure it out and quickly, because we need him and a lot of us fans thought he would possibly be one of our better players this season.
 

Sigmapolis

Minister of Economy
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Aug 10, 2011
26,920
41,624
113
Waukee
I find it interesting the poll is about 75% to make the NCAA tournament right now.

Which is almost on the dot where the computer models have it.

"Wisdom of the crowds" and that whole thing.
 

AuH2O

Well-Known Member
Sep 7, 2013
12,999
20,962
113
My concern is TJ took scrubs the last 2 years and maximized the most out of them. This is his most talented team in his time here and our 3rd best 3 point shooter is hitting 20% from 3.

So we got worse at defense to get better at offense, and our offense is absolute pure dog ****.

It is so incredibly insulting that multiple times this tournament teams had 5 guys crash the paint fully aware no one was a threat outside.

It’s fixable, but learning how to shoot a basketball is much more difficult, imo, than any other aspect of the game.

Can you imagine if Tamin didn’t improve his scoring ability from last year? Jesus.
A college coaching staff isn’t going to have much to do with a guy improving shooting, and it sure as heck isn’t going to happen in season. It’s almost completely about a guy putting in crazy amounts of work in the off-season. There’s a reason under the same coaches some guys improve and some don’t.

But what a staff needs to be able to do is figure out how to get their good three point shooters more good looks, their guys that can attack the rim more matchups and sets that give them space to attack and finish or kick, their guys with post moves some mismatches and kick opportunities, etc.

Obviously the more offensive skill you have the easier it is. If MM is getting a bunch of good looks from 3 or mismatch opportunities in the low post but just missing, so be it. If Gilbert or Tamin are getting opportunities to get switched on to by a big and attack but not finishing, so be it. But that isn’t happening very consistently at all. But if the offense ends up with the guys the defense wants shooting taking the shot, that’s not good offense. No team has five shooters, most have 1-3.

ISUs offensive makeup is pretty typical. One elite shooter, one good shooter (Tamin), two guys that can get into the paint extremely well (Gilbert and Tamin), and a couple guys that are decent around the rim.

TJ is an elite recruiter, great at getting guys to buy in, great at defensive strategy and coaching. Just need the offensive coaching to come along. ISU is only a few games in with the first offensively skilled roster TJ has had. It’s not there yet, but it will improve. Even great coaches have flaws that they need to work on. MC is an awesome coach, but he isn’t good at clock management.

Hate to be “Trust TJ” guy, but I trust he’s going to figure it out.
 

CyPunch

Well-Known Member
May 3, 2019
4,707
11,988
113
Sandy Springs, GA
Ya I love Tamin but the number of guards that couldn’t shoot in to their Sophomore college season and then become legitimate shooters has to be pretty small. Shooting the 3 is primarily based on talent for shooting the ball. Having to make mechanical adjustments AND redefine your existing game to include a deep ball is really really tough.

“Worked on their 3pt shot” is the basketball equivalent of “much improved O-Line” in football.

It seems like you are implying his shot hasn't improved. Wut?
 

Latest posts

Help Support Us

Become a patron