***Official 2024 NCAA Men’s Basketball Tournament Thread***

NYCYFan

Well-Known Member
Mar 18, 2024
493
660
93
i.e...ISU against UAB then?
Somewhat similar. I'm just stating why I think people are high on Illinois. Teams that can score and have veteran guards tend to be favored come tournament time. It doesn't mean that Illinois, or any team, can't be picked off early.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dahliaclone

Cyhig

Well-Known Member
Nov 29, 2017
3,259
6,835
113
Fun bunch of games to kick off the tourney Tomorrow.

View attachment 125947
Easy to pull for Long Beach St. Don Monson gets fired from his job right before the conference tournament, but he is allowed to still be the coach through the end of the season. The team then wins the conference tournament.
It's a fun story, and these are the types of stories that become legendary this time of year (sister jean, for example)
 

jcyclonee

Well-Known Member
Apr 12, 2006
23,270
26,180
113
Minneapolis
For the record. Sanford has a player (Nathan Johnson) from Waukee and is a huge Cyclone fan. Hope he burns the Jayhawks
56fbf50b-0003-4c33-b9d7-1912f1bb2938_text.gif

The name is so close
 

Halincandenza

Well-Known Member
Oct 24, 2018
9,434
10,262
113
There is an interesting article in the athletic about Jokic and the point center and college basketball and Hoiberg is a big part of it talking about how Royce White was the first version of this in the NCAA.

 
  • Like
Reactions: SolterraCyclone

jcyclonee

Well-Known Member
Apr 12, 2006
23,270
26,180
113
Minneapolis
Nice to see Virginia's undeserved inclusion blow up in the committee's face. A team that had one quality win since November.

Gotta stick up for my local team St. John's. Won 6 in a row including beating Creighton and then gave UConn one of their toughest games all season. There's no way you can tell me that Virginia deserved to be in over St. John's, it's just more nonsense about rewarding OOC wins many months ago over how a team is playing currently.
Virginia should have been left out. Indiana State should have been in.
Northwestern should have been left out. St. John's should have been in.

I'd like to say these were just bubble-related teams but I don't think St. John's and Indiana State belonged on the bubble.
 

EnkAMania

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Dec 31, 2013
1,257
1,760
113
Seattle
I've collected all the tidbits of what the national championship team looks like since 2002 and made a wacky rating system.

CriteriaScore - All Time
KenPom Top 2521
4 seed or better20
KenPom Top 25 AdjOff20
Week 6 AP Top 1220
KenPom Top 40 AdjDef20
Team Rankings Top 6 (Team rankings started in 2007, so I pro-rated the number)18.375
Elite 8 Coach19
Lowest KenPom rank loss <10018
Reg Season or Conf Champ18
6 or fewer losses17
3 Pt % >35 (This was adjusted after the line moved back)15

Iowa State just missed the Team Rankings Top 6 and 3 Pt %. So Purdue and UConn are tied for first. The worst team in the tournament is Texas A&M.
 

CloniesForLife

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Apr 22, 2015
15,613
21,025
113
I'm not sure - it's at altitude in SLC and Samford runs 12 guys and pushes the pace a lot. If they are able to get KU running, they can get Dickinson and others tired, and then if they make 3s they could make it competitive.
Didn't realize it was in SLC
 

Klubber

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Apr 11, 2006
1,783
2,101
113
Aurora, IL
The amount of 'experts' that have Illinois going far in their brackets is mindboggling to me. They aren't bad but they aren't great. I have this weird sense they kind of remind me of our season we lost to UAB. Team that was 'hot' late winning their league title and everyone jumped on the bandwagon and many had us going very far that year. Dunno...not saying they are gonna lose to Morehead State but I really really don't see them beating BYU.
The UAB comparison is one I've thought of as well. Illinois and that ISU team both were/are really bad defensively, but with high scoring offenses.

Only difference is the opponent. UAB just wasn't that good that year and got bounced 2nd rd. I watched Morehead last week in their conference champ game and they looked really good; not a team I'd want to see 1st rd.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dahliaclone

jcyclonee

Well-Known Member
Apr 12, 2006
23,270
26,180
113
Minneapolis
The UAB comparison is one I've thought of as well. Illinois and that ISU team both were/are really bad defensively, but with high scoring offenses.

Only difference is the opponent. UAB just wasn't that good that year and got bounced 2nd rd. I watched Morehead last week in their conference champ game and they looked really good; not a team I'd want to see 1st rd.
How is Illinois at rebounding? By my recollection, what killed ISU that game (more than anything) was terrible, terrible rebounding.
 

AuH2O

Well-Known Member
Sep 7, 2013
13,027
21,014
113
There are some circumstances when I think assessment of an injury is valid, but it should be narrow and have only minor effect on selection/seeding.

Random fictional example - if a significant contributor misses a stretch of games, then returns to the lineup, and the performance of the team during his absense (taking into account metrics) varies significantly from the rest of the season results, maybe you take it into account. Any adjustment shouldn't involve a major swing either way.
Disregard them altogether. At what point do you draw the line? How do you take into account this for that teams’ opponents?

We are on here complaining about the stupid seeding and selections that only happen because the committee has flexibility and discretion.

There’s zero reason to have a committee pick teams at all. Just have them determine the criteria and weighting, go by resumes only, make it transparent and get the hell out of the way.

Discretion on these committees only exist to change the result when the model doesn’t churn out the answer they want.
 

Klubber

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Apr 11, 2006
1,783
2,101
113
Aurora, IL
How is Illinois at rebounding? By my recollection, what killed ISU that game (more than anything) was terrible, terrible rebounding.
They've been good in their conference games on the glass. That said, there are a lot of bad rebounding teams in the B1G this year.
 
  • Informative
Reactions: jcyclonee

Halincandenza

Well-Known Member
Oct 24, 2018
9,434
10,262
113
Using KP history as a guide there are really only 4 teams from the East Region that can make a final four, UCONN, ISU, Auburn and San Diego State. and UCONN is the only team with the parameters to win a championship. Although, if you look at history, most returning champs don't make it out of the first weekend and rarely make it beyond the sweet 16.
 
  • Like
Reactions: nrg4isu

DSM4Cy

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Apr 4, 2006
2,589
3,213
113
Altoona, IA
Using KP history as a guide there are really only 4 teams from the East Region that can make a final four, UCONN, ISU, Auburn and San Diego State. and UCONN is the only team with the parameters to win a championship. Although, if you look at history, most returning champs don't make it out of the first weekend and rarely make it beyond the sweet 16.
Parameters are made to be broken, plus it hasn't been that long since Florida repeated. But you are right, that is an exception.

However, if you want to get pickier, nearly every champion in the KenPom era hasn't just been top 40 in both offense/defense, but they've actually been top 20 in both. Only 2014 UConn (39th best offense) and 2021 Baylor (22nd best defense) buck that trend.

In fact, the majority of champions in the last 25 years have been top 10 in both categories.

If you limit to top 20 in both, this year that would leave possible champs of:
UConn
Houston
Auburn
Arizona
And that's it.

You could also stretch and include Purdue, they are 21 in defense.

This year, the only team going into the tournament top 10 in both categories is actually Auburn.

For a team like Purdue, Tennessee, Duke, North Carolina, Creighton, Marquette to win, that would only align with 2 of the last 23 champions. It's possible, just much more improbable.

For someone like us to win it all, we would be trendsetters. No one with either an AdjO or AdjD as poor as ours has won a national title in the KenPom era. Making the Final Four, though is a different threshold, certainly would be other teams like us who have done this recently.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Halincandenza

Halincandenza

Well-Known Member
Oct 24, 2018
9,434
10,262
113
Parameters are made to be broken, plus it hasn't been that long since Florida repeated. But you are right, that is an exception.

However, if you want to get pickier, nearly every champion in the KenPom era hasn't just been top 40 in both offense/defense, but they've actually been top 20 in both. Only 2014 UConn (39th best offense) and 2021 Baylor (22nd best defense) buck that trend.

In fact, the majority of champions in the last 25 years have been top 10 in both categories.

If you limit to top 20 in both, this year that would leave possible champs of:
UConn
Houston
Auburn
Arizona
And that's it.

You could also stretch and include Purdue, they are 21 in defense.

This year, the only team going into the tournament top 10 in both categories is actually Auburn.

For a team like Purdue, Tennessee, Duke, North Carolina, Creighton, Marquette to win, that would only align with 2 of the last 23 champions. It's possible, just much more improbable.

For someone like us to win it all, we would be trendsetters. No one with either an AdjO or AdjD as poor as ours has won a national title in the KenPom era. Making the Final Four, though is a different threshold, certainly would be other teams like us who have done this recently.
I believe some of those numbers are post tournament. I think pretourney the numbers Purdue is in there as well as Marquette. And this isn't KP but I believe you have to go back pretty far to find a national champ that didn't have a first round pick on the roster. I think I read there are really only 3 teams that can win it this year based on KP history and the first round pick deal and that is UCONN, Purdue and Marquette and Marquette's top guy is injured.