Reese's Peanut Butter Cups vs. Reese's Eggs

[MJ29]

The small Reese's are the best shape an chockolate/pb ratio. The Trader Joes adult version of these with dark chocolate and real peanut butter are the final form evolution of the candy...then on top of it the Trader Joes versions are $1 for 9 and it's the best candy deal in the universe by miles.

I can get a small candy at a gas station for $3 or I can get 27 of these immaculate perfect PB cups at TJs and absolutely gorge myself.

The dark chocolate pb cups at Trader Joe's are my kryptonite.

 

[HFCS]

The best are the mini ones in the gold foil. Perfect PB to chocolate ratio.

i like them a tiny bit more if I keep in fridge too

 

[HFCS]

The dark chocolate pb cups at Trader Joe's are my kryptonite.

That $1 bag of 9. if it was a $3 bag of 27 I would be in serious trouble.

 

[Cyched]

Just like Oreos, the original was already perfection. Anything else is a gimmick and not as good.

With one exception for Double Stuff Oreos

 

[Mr Janny]

Yeah, I eat way more miniature cups than I ever will eggs.

That's because the eggs are huge. My wife always puts the eggs in our kids Easter baskets every year, and guess what's always leftover a week later. Hint: It ain't the Whoppers Eggs.

 

[coolerifyoudid]

I like em all, but the advantage of the eggs/trees/pumpkins is that they are generally fresher due to their seasonality. Of course, the seasonal candies tend to have a shorter shelf life.

 

[ScottyP]

The small Reese's are the best shape an chockolate/pb ratio. The Trader Joes adult version of these with dark chocolate and real peanut butter are the final form evolution of the candy...then on top of it the Trader Joes versions are $1 for 9 and it's the best candy deal in the universe by miles.

I can get a small candy at a gas station for $3 or I can get 27 of these immaculate perfect PB cups at TJs and absolutely gorge myself.

I might have to give those dark chocolate Trader Joes versions a try....

 

[Letterkenny]

With one exception for Double Stuff Oreos

There are no exceptions.

 

[cycloner29]

Reese's Blizzard is all I really need. I don't care if they use crumbled up cups, trees, eggs, or pumpkins.

 

[Cyched]

There are no exceptions.

 

[dahliaclone]

No argument here. Trader Joe's candy/snacks are unrivaled.

The best thing in Trader Joe’s (and I love a lot of things there) are these. Holy fuckballs. Crack.

Trust me

 

[RLD4ISU]

 

[Paz23]

The smaller eggs that come individually wrapped in a bag. The larger eggs, like a regular candy bar size, go too far on the PB / Chocolate ratio.

A very, very, very close second...

 

[Cyched]

Reese's Blizzard is all I really need. I don't care if they use crumbled up cups, trees, eggs, or pumpkins.

Best Blizzard flavor could be a separate poll. I'm an Oreo Blizzard guy, but Reese's is in the top 3 with cookie dough.

 

[Mr Janny]

The best thing in Trader Joe’s (and I love a lot of things there) are these. Holy fuckballs. Crack.

Trust me

View attachment 146755

I'm more partial to these:

 

[cyclones122]

The small Reese's are the best shape an chockolate/pb ratio. The Trader Joes adult version of these with dark chocolate and real peanut butter are the final form evolution of the candy...then on top of it the Trader Joes versions are $1 for 9 and it's the best candy deal in the universe by miles.

I can get a small candy at a gas station for $3 or I can get 27 of these immaculate perfect PB cups at TJs and absolutely gorge myself.

This. I love Reese's, but the Trader Joes version is the best. They are probably my favorite candy.

 

[psycln11]

Anything that doesn't involve peeling a wrapper off my candy. Hershey's Kisses are the death of me!!

 

[AgronAlum]

Can’t stand the eggs. Come at me bro.

 

[CycloneSarah]

I'm glad my family isn't the only one who has been preaching the superiority of the Reese's egg shape for the last 20+ years.

There was also briefly a Milky Way egg shape that was the best of all but it doesn't seem to exist anymore.

 

[cycloneworld]

I'm more partial to these:

View attachment 146759 View attachment 146758

What are you, 100 years old? Keep Werther’s in your pockets too?

But you are 100% right, TJ snacks rock.