Anyone else for a change at the tip?

Cardinal2001

Well-Known Member
Feb 14, 2007
8,319
2,953
113
Ames
McKay hasn't been outjumping anyone. Time to give someone else a chance.

Nader has had some outstanding alley oops, how about giving him a try? As I recall, Hogue wasn't the tallest player out there, but he won a fair share of tip offs.
 

CYcoFan

Well-Known Member
Aug 15, 2007
1,741
310
83
Ames
McKay hasn't been outjumping anyone. Time to give someone else a chance.

Nader has had some outstanding alley oops, how about giving him a try? As I recall, Hogue wasn't the tallest player out there, but he won a fair share of tip offs.

I suppose you are against winning the toss and deferring in football as well? Honestly jumping the ball to start the game would mean more if they also did it to start 2nd half.
 

SwirlyBird

Well-Known Member
Aug 2, 2015
2,977
3,072
113
I was wondering how stupid people on here could get. You are really pushing the envelope OP.
 

Frak

Well-Known Member
Apr 27, 2009
11,466
7,070
113
How about changing ball screen defense. Drew ran that play 30 times in a row. And we never stopped it.
 

RedDog

Well-Known Member
Jan 28, 2014
5,092
7,049
113
It's not all on McKay, our tip-off defense as a whole has been junk this year.
 

cloneteach

Well-Known Member
Nov 19, 2009
2,143
481
83
There is actually an article out there about KU puts a big emphasis on the opening tip and they have gained a 2% advantage because of it.

There is a chance a team could get one extra possession by winning the opening tip. There is no chance of this if you lose it. So yes, it is a bit bigger of a deal than people let on.
 

chuckd4735

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Mar 29, 2006
29,626
12,066
113
42
Lee's Summit, MO
There is actually an article out there about KU puts a big emphasis on the opening tip and they have gained a 2% advantage because of it.

There is a chance a team could get one extra possession by winning the opening tip. There is no chance of this if you lose it. So yes, it is a bit bigger of a deal than people let on.

Exactly. Winning the tip means you are guaranteed at least as many possessions on jump balls and first/second half opening possessions as the other team, and possibly one more, depending on how many jump balls there are. The team who loses the opening tip does not gain a single advantage. Now how important that is who knows, but it does have its advantage.
 

Cardinal2001

Well-Known Member
Feb 14, 2007
8,319
2,953
113
Ames
Exactly. Winning the tip means you are guaranteed at least as many possessions on jump balls and first/second half opening possessions as the other team, and possibly one more, depending on how many jump balls there are. The team who loses the opening tip does not gain a single advantage. Now how important that is who knows, but it does have its advantage.

IIRC, Hogue wasn't the original jump ball designee. He got the job after limited success. After he got a chance, he became quite good at it.

Don't get the hate for this topic. There is no animosity toward McKay, just want to get an advantage, and it's an easy try. Maybe they have done that in practice, don't really know.
 

Cyballz

Well-Known Member
Aug 20, 2009
1,265
926
113
There is actually an article out there about KU puts a big emphasis on the opening tip and they have gained a 2% advantage because of it.

There is a chance a team could get one extra possession by winning the opening tip. There is no chance of this if you lose it. So yes, it is a bit bigger of a deal than people let on.

Link? That sounds like complete ********. How is the possibility of getting one extra possession add up to a 2% advantage?
 

ISUME

Well-Known Member
Mar 13, 2012
1,890
93
48
There is actually an article out there about KU puts a big emphasis on the opening tip and they have gained a 2% advantage because of it.

There is a chance a team could get one extra possession by winning the opening tip. There is no chance of this if you lose it. So yes, it is a bit bigger of a deal than people let on.

I believe within 10 years they will get rid of the opening tip. If you watch enough games you will realize how bad some refs are at throwing the ball up.
 

cloneteach

Well-Known Member
Nov 19, 2009
2,143
481
83
Link? That sounds like complete ********. How is the possibility of getting one extra possession add up to a 2% advantage?

When you get an extra possession and average a little over a point per possession. 1.2/70 points = 1.7 % advantage.