Has Conditt tweeted at anyone else besides Harris and Brown? Maybe he’s the good luck charm to bring Brown here.
These are 18-22 kids, I don’t even think you can say scores that look like blowouts couldn’t be flipped. Small failures can cascade and cause major disasters. Prevent the first few small failures, and no one notices a thing. That’s what happened last year without Haliburton.ISU was 10-13 up to the point TH was hurt, went 2-7 down the stretch. Looking at the schedule, flip the FAMU, WVU, and OSU x2 wins if TH was healthy. The rest of the games were blowouts, and those aren't being flipped with TH. So optimistically a fully healthy TH makes last years team 16-16. Maybe they don't flip one of those games and they would be 15-17.
Do you think Shayok has the legacy he has if he has this roster to play with as opposed to Wigginton, THT, Hali? NWB?
I am NOT questioning Shayoks talent/abilities, dudes a hell of a player AND deserves his NBA spot. But when you have NBA talent around you, it opens you up and allows you to have more success.
Brown does not have NBA talent around him and game planning against this team will be extremely easy UNLESS we add 2-3 Brown like players.
dont know if he tweeted but he definitely was reaching out and talking to CartonHas Conditt tweeted at anyone else besides Harris and Brown? Maybe he’s the good luck charm to bring Brown here.
So basically you're assuming the absolute worst. None of our guys will be eligible or we will not fill this roster with eligible talent, you don't think Blackwell and Foster will attribute much, and Jackson, Solo, Conditt and Bolton will not improve much..My argument this whole time has been he’s good, I don’t foresee him being a program changer like some seem to be making him out to be. There’s no bar to be moved. With the current roster, I see us being a 9-12 win team and with Browns addition, becoming a 12-15 win team.
Where you and I are different
- I am not including Harris on the roster until he gets his waiver
- I am not banking on at least 2 freshmen to come in and have a huge impact as freshmen
- I am not predicting everyone on the roster has huge strides in development, as Haliburton is probably the only player Prohms coached at Iowa State who from year 1 to year 2 became a noticeably better player.
Shayok ran the show in KC his Sr year. Opened up a lot of eyes to his his **** making abilities. He was making everything easier for everyone else a lot of that season, not the other way around.
So basically you're assuming the absolute worst. None of our guys will be eligible or we will not fill this roster with eligible talent, you don't think Blackwell and Foster will attribute much, and Jackson, Solo, Conditt and Bolton will not improve much..
Also, a problem with Prohm has been his ability to keep guys around, especially the talented ones. So in the case of Lard, Wigginton, and THT, those guys would've undoubtedly improved had they stayed on the team for more than just two seasons.
Right right, I was saying in general. We are going to get a guy or two that will be eligible for next year. We're not going to roll with what we have currently and hope for the best. If all of those things you said happen then sure, I could see us being terrible. But it's still worse case scenario.None of our guys will be eligible? The only guy who I said I'm not assuming he will be eligible is Harris, because...wait for it...he hasn't received a waiver and is not eligible.
I HOPE he becomes eligible. But he currently is not eligible.
Right right, I was saying in general. We are going to get a guy or two that will be eligible for next year. We're not going to roll with what we have currently and hope for the best. If all of those things you said happen then sure, I could see us being terrible. But it's still worse case scenario.
If Brown can get help push us into the tournament, he is a program changer. Look at the 2021-22 roster. If we make it next year, the program pivots!My argument this whole time has been he’s good, I don’t foresee him being a program changer like some seem to be making him out to be. There’s no bar to be moved. With the current roster, I see us being a 9-12 win team and with Browns addition, becoming a 12-15 win team.
Where you and I are different
- I am not including Harris on the roster until he gets his waiver
- I am not banking on at least 2 freshmen to come in and have a huge impact as freshmen
- I am not predicting everyone on the roster has huge strides in development, as Haliburton is probably the only player Prohms coached at Iowa State who from year 1 to year 2 became a noticeably better player.
That lottery pick also was hurt for 1/3 of the season and due to missing on Zion and Terrence who transferred force to rely on two raw freshman.
Next years team is going to be starting 3 new players and changing 6 (imo improved) in the rotation from last year. It just isn't downgrading from Hali play the first 20 games it is also improving from Nixon and Jacobson play for all 33 games. It won't be close to the same team, and I expect Tre and Rasir to improve from last year too.
Assuming you add Brown or one more high level transfer to mitigate TH's loss and incoming freshman class ISU contribute will be better than 12 wins. NIT or bubble is more likely than less than 10 wins.
(And there would be 2 more schollys available to improve.)
If Brown can get help push us into the tournament, he is a program changer. Look at the 2021-22 roster. If we make it next year, the program pivots!
You’ve moved the bar several times.
First it’s he cannot make us NCAA bubble (otherwise nit bubble) I said I don't think he could take us from an NIT bubble team to an NCAA bubble team, then it’s top half of Big 12 I said I don't believe he takes us from a 8/9 seed to a top half of the Big 12 team then equal to Shayok’s legacy you compared him to Shayok's legacy, I was saying I completely disagree, you must have completely misunderstood. You seem to not say what you mean?
He's good and I'd take him.
But based on stats and what I see from his tapes, I don't think he takes us from a team on the bubble of the NIT to on the bubble of the NCAA tournament.
Hope I'm wrong.
I guess what I’m saying is he’s good, but I’m not going to be drinking the kool aid. I don’t see this guy being a Deandre Kane (Deandre Kane was a boss AND had NBA talent playing with him) or being the program changer some are making him out to be. This roster, as is, is an 8/9 finish in the Big 12 (unless you believe these freshman will light the world on fire) and I don’t think this guy, single handedly, puts us in the top half of the Big 12, like some seem to be making it out to be.
Imo that team still was one of the best in ISU history!!
Guys, we’re greatly overestimating what’s needed to make the Tournament, let alone the bubble. It doesn’t take a roster without flaws or even terribly good coaching. And it certainly doesn’t take a lottery pick. Having a sound team goes a lot further than having a lottery pick.
Prohm has flaws, but come on! He’s previously accomplished this task of improving a lot after losing a lot, just two seasons ago. If we find someone to be that Shayok talent and leadership role, we’ll be AT LEAST a ******* bubble team.
Do you think Shayok has the legacy he has if he has this roster to play with as opposed to Wigginton, THT, Hali? NWB?
I am NOT questioning Shayoks talent/abilities, dudes a hell of a player AND deserves his NBA spot. But when you have NBA talent around you, it opens you up and allows you to have more success.
Brown does not have NBA talent around him and game planning against this team will be extremely easy UNLESS we add 2-3 Brown like players.
I 100 percent know the story way more than you do. 100 percent.
ISU fan BRO DOWN!!!!!!
Yes, I see you moving the bar. How are you not?I think reading comprehension may be an issue - please review bolded parts in your above quote that I responded to.
Then proceed to the quotes below for evidence. Read carefully.
Yes, I'm planning for the season to go as this roster is currently made up. When players are added to the roster, my expectations change. As I said, 9-12 win team without Brown, 12-15 win team with Brown. Harris is eligible, expectations raise. Prohm adds guys who will be able to contribute, expectations raise.
I just know exactly what happened and who the players were with this one. I don't expect others to know. Everyone can disagree with me if they want. That's fine but I know what really happened.
Opened up a lot of eyes to his his **** making abilities.
So we're NOT just a single digit win team next year now? Or we ARE s single digit win team if nothing else happens? You've made some really strong statements in this thread that are really testing the boundaries of both sides of the spectrum but I'm guessing the only thing that hasn't changed is you think CSP always has and always will suck?
What is your definition of a program changer?
21-22The NCAA tournament that happens to be in the year 2021? Or are you saying we will have to wait until the 2021-2022 season before you believe we will make the tournament? Just wondering