Gas Grills

Sousaclone

Well-Known Member
Apr 29, 2006
1,853
1,179
113
North of Seattle
My parents probably owned three gas grills before they bought their Weber and they were pretty much junk. They finally bit the bullet and spent the money on a basic three burner weber. 10 years later that thing is still going strong. The only thing they've done to it is replace the bars that cover the burners (they finally rusted out a year ago. they still served the purpose but they looked like they were going to crumble at any moment) and I think this year they might have to replace the grill grates. The grates could probably last another year or two if I had to guess but they are starting to rust on the bottom and they are definetly losing some material. The only preventative maintenance they do is, uhhh, I guess they might hose it off once a year. Oh, and they sometime put a cover over it. That's mainly in the winter though. Granted when I grill during the winter the cover is a pain to get back on as it gets stiff. So normally it sits uncovered during the winter. They do pull it up under the covered portion of the deck though.


That thing still kicks on the first try (unless it's cold (i.e a couple of weeks ago when I grilling in 15 degree weather) and then it might take two pushes on the starter (original starter). Cooks well, puts out tons of heat (It can get the middle burner cover to glow red with all three burners on high), cooks relatively evenly. One side of the grill is hotter than the other, but it doesn't have distinct hot spots, more of a gradual transition.

Oh as far as the gas vs. charcoal debate, while charcoal may "taste" better, you can't beat a gas grill for speed, convinence, and ease of use. I have a hard time believing anybody here can get a charcoal grill fired up to cooking temperature faster than you can get a decent gas grill. Charcoal is nice if you've got the time or are cooking at your typical backyard BBQ party but it's hard to beat a gas grill, especially if you are only cooking a small amount, trying to do things at different temperatures, or need to sear something then let it cook slowly after that.

If you can afford it, spend the money on the weber.

One big thing to keep in mind is that all stainless steel is not the same. From what I saw online, the charbroils and perfect flames of the world are made with lower quality stainless that will still eventually rust. I saw this first hand on my uncle's several year old grill. I think someone linked this and tore it back down already, but I think the about.com reviews are pretty good.
Before you Buy a Gas Grills - Updated for 2007 - Best Gas Grills - Gas Grill Reviews - Gas Grills

That's a good point also. If you can find a decent magnet (not a thin refrigerator magnet but one with a little bit of thickness), take it with you. If I remember correctly a magnet will not stick to "good" stainless steel. A lower grade stainless has more carbon in it, which is more magnetic, whic in turns rusts. That's what the guys at work said when they were talking about buying grills. If a MatE or someone along those lines can confirm or deny that it would be great. As a CE, we don't really get into metallurgy.
 
Last edited:

Kyle

Well-Known Member
Mar 30, 2006
4,074
119
63
If you can afford it, spend the money on the weber.
Probably good advise. You don't hear people complain about their Webbers, and many have them for well over 10 years and still love them. You also know the customer service and parts will still be around since Webber isn't going anywhere.
 

CYdTracked

Well-Known Member
Mar 23, 2006
18,688
9,492
113
Grimes, IA
Weber charcoal all the way. Only gas one I use is a small one for tailgating because it's less messy to transport. Tastes a lot better on charcoal and if you get one of those charcoal chimneys it takes maybe 10 minutes to get some hot coals to start grilling.
 

jumbopackage

Well-Known Member
Sep 18, 2007
5,479
249
63
I guess I'll put it this way: I've never heard of anyone complaining about a weber, outside of the price.

It's the only brand of grill I can say that about.
 

ISUFan22

Well-Known Member
Apr 11, 2006
33,922
904
113
Denver, CO
Thanks much folks.

Questions about how we use the grill - all the time would be putting it mildly. I've had to scale back my use some - especially since the older grill is on the open deck instead under a covered patio in our old house. Windy and/or cold days kill me. Otherwise, I'd be grilling 12 months a year and I'm looking for a grill that I can do that with.

BvK - I did gather the guy doing the reviews on bbq.about.com was a grill snob. He and the site did have the grill I'm after rated very highly as well. Good to know Consumer Reports agreed. I am aware of the recall on the hose, it's for grills sold mid-year '07 through Feb. '08 - for the 2007 models. I printed out that recall info already. What I saw said the issue was corrected for the '08 models.
 

Chad

Active Member
Sep 10, 2007
469
29
28
Ankeny, IA
I know this thread is old, but what did you end up getting? I have been looking at gas grills at Home Depot because I have a lot of HD gift cards. I like the Weber Genesis, just not sure about the burner configuration. The three burners run right to left, and the controls take up space on the side table. I'm wondering if left to right burners create long narrow grill zones rather than wider short zones if they were running front to back. The other options I can find are a Weber Summit for nearly twice the price of the Genesis, or a Char-broil but I'm not sure about infrared grilling and the build quality of Char-broil. My current Char-broil is on it's third set of burners and I have read of similar issues so I don't want to repeat that.
 

zumbro clones

Well-Known Member
Jan 31, 2007
1,774
316
83
Southern Minnesota
We have a Vermont Casting 3 burner grill. It's fairly simple but does a great job. We have had it 3 years now. We use it quite a bit and haven't had any problems at all.
 

DeBruzzio

Active Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Feb 6, 2009
370
165
43
Fort Dodge native
I have had a Weber Genesis for 10 years +. The east to west configuration is great. I do a lot of indirect cooking with the middle burner off and get great results with pork, turkey, and chicken.

With burgers, steaks etc, I cook directly and use how ever many burners are needed.

So I would recommend it highly.
 

TruClone

Well-Known Member
Mar 25, 2009
2,159
647
113
Quad Cities
Let's face it: Friends don't let friends cook with propane. My FIL threw out his gas grill the day after he saw my "method" for cooking with charcoal. Once you learn how, it's just about as convenient as gas, too.

You can do anything with charcoal that you can do with gas, only the food tastes good with charcoal.

Yes. I just got the Weber Performer, which is charcoal that is ignited by propane. No need for lighter fluid, just turn on propane for 5 minutes and the charcoal is ignited.
 

nboltz

Member
Apr 9, 2006
169
5
18
Ames
Has anyone tried the Big Green Egg?


I have one, it's the best grill I've ever owned. I gave away my Weber gas grill when I purchased the Big Green Egg. There is nothing like cooking a ribeye for 5 minutes at 600 degrees. That's a really good steak.