Creamy Jif is a must but I like mine like the old McDonalds McDLT, hot side hot and cold side cold. Peanut butter side toasted and warm while jelly side is untoasted and cool.
This thread went a lot further than I expected. I guess thats what happens when its the offseason and theres nothing but the hoks getting crushed in the NIT to watch on tv.
This thread went a lot further than I expected. I guess thats what happens when its the offseason and theres nothing but the hoks getting crushed in the NIT to watch on tv.
Always untoasted
any type of bread
crunchy or creamy peanut butter
Only my grandma's homemade strawberry jelly (Yes, I'm 36 and if I asked her right now she would make me some. She also showed my wife how to make it so I'm set for a few years.)