I've got really mixed feelings on this subject. First, I do like Mac. The thing that worried me the most when he got here was whether he could recruit at a major conference level, I think he's proven that he can.
But then there are numerous red flags that go along with his tenure. Losing player(s) every year, a team with quite a bit of front line talent getting killed on the boards with regularity, the team's lack of improvement as the season progresses, (stagnant offense, very poor spacing, no apparent spark at any time).
I'd like to see him stay and suceed, but how long so we wait? I really thought we'd have a legitimate shot at a top-half conference finish and a tourney spot, now I'm not so sure we deserve a watered-down NIT bid the way we're playing.
Finally, one rebound for CB? If you can't motivate him then SIT HIM DOWN!! Maybe he's too nice a guy.
Sadly, maybe he should go.