No doubt that season was an emotional roller coaster! I just don't see the need to try to trash that season as some disappointing mess because a 17 year old Freshman was wildly inconsistent, a 200+ ranked true freshman role player that turned out to be a lottery pick was... a freshman role player, and we had an NBA cup of coffee and a G league guy.
But there was lots of entertainment value, and the good outweighed the bad for sure. Otherwise that wouldn't have been a 6 seed.
It's clear Prohm is not getting it done at ISU, and I don't see anyone saying otherwise. But if people didn't get more enjoyment than frustration out of the three tournament seasons while Prohm was coach, you are probably destined to be disappointed as an ISU fan. The run under Hoiberg was incredible, but is also unprecedented in terms of consistent performance, and is going to be tough to replicate. That run also had the ups and downs you expect from college basketball, but because we were coming out of the dark ages, and the overall trajectory looked so good, it was easy to brush off the down times. Hell, the 2011-12 season was full of disasters and inconsistency, but just getting into the tournament was so awesome after missing for so many years, that is still one of the most fun seasons as a fan I can remember.