As I recall, the '09 UNI squad was picked by many to win the national championship. They were clobbering everybody they faced through the first half of the season ... but then they fell apart.
Anyhow, when I said that the two UNI squads were rather different ... the implication had more to do with STYLE of play. I was NOT suggesting that the 2011 UNI squad wasn't good.
I agree with you that the Clone's beat an excellent UNI squad.
So please remind me ... how exactly did I articulate a poor knowledge of the UNI squad?
I dont recall anything in your post about STYLE. Your post stated that the two UNI teams that Iowa and ISU faced "are not the same" because in 09 UNI had:SR (experienced) QB & SR leadership on the OL with a Stout Defense.
My reply to that is while the QBs may excel in different aspects of the game (Rennie is more of a runner/scrambler while the 09 QB was a passer) the two teams are pretty darn comparable.
I also think that the two teams that UNI faced were maybe not all that different. In the begginning of 2009 Iowa really didnt know what they had on offense. Stanzi played a bit as a So. but was sporadic, they were breaking in new RB's who were trying to replace NFL talent (Shonn Greene) and Iowa's starting WR was listed as Trey Strauss. The advantage here was Iowa's OL which if ISU's gets healthy in 2011 could be at least comparable to the 09 Hawks.
The morale of the story is that UNI is a good enough program that in the years where they return upperclassmen to challenge BCS schools who are trying to replace a lot of production.
I can only hope that ISU's season goes half as good as the 09 season did for Iowa