Beathard vs. Richardson

CYCLNST8

Well-Known Member
Jul 19, 2008
11,371
13,527
113
Urbandale
www.gimikk.com
1800248.jpg

Here's a clue:

GvZ6vcg.gif
 

clairvoyantdan

Active Member
Aug 10, 2015
1,052
0
36
Beathard started the bowl game and was pretty bad throughout.

Beathard looked good when they stopped rotating QB's ever series and actually let him get in a rhythm. Every Rudock series was a waste. Iowa is actually starting a RB at the RB position, and a QB at the QB position. Let's revisit this conversation after the game and then again after the season. Beathard hands down.
 

Nuts4Cy

Active Member
Mar 21, 2006
775
71
28
Give me CJB. I want a QB who is in your face when you screw up and has a swagger. Much like Drew Tate. I hate Iowa but I'd take a QB with an attitude of Tate in a heart beat.
 

CyTwins

Well-Known Member
Jan 20, 2010
80,179
65,792
113
Ankeny
Beathard looked good when they stopped rotating QB's ever series and actually let him get in a rhythm. Every Rudock series was a waste. Iowa is actually starting a RB at the RB position, and a QB at the QB position. Let's revisit this conversation after the game and then again after the season. Beathard hands down.

According to the USA Today coaches salary database, Ferentz earned about $4.1 million in 2014. That ranked ninth among the highest-paid coaches in college football.
 

Gunnerclone

Well-Known Member
Jul 16, 2010
75,682
80,074
113
DSM
I agree with this.

Sam is Busch Light- you know what you are getting, and it's okay, but you wouldn't post about it on facebook.

Beathard is the mystery foreign beer at the grocery. Might be really awesome, might be terrible. And you won't know for sure until you open it.

Can't be that great if it wasn't good enough to force it's way past the natural ice that was Rudock for two years.
 

ameslurker

Well-Known Member
Jan 21, 2013
1,419
1,222
113
37
I agree with this.

Sam is Busch Light- you know what you are getting, and it's okay, but you wouldn't post about it on facebook.

Beathard is the mystery foreign beer at the grocery. Might be really awesome, might be terrible. And you won't know for sure until you open it.

Best analogy ever.
 

intrepid27

Well-Known Member
Oct 9, 2006
6,011
5,079
113
Marion, IA
I will be curios to see How Capt Kirk responds when Beathard has a 3 interception game. He may pull in the reigns on his gun slinging QB then.

Before the 2014-15 season I heard Ex QB James Vandenberg talking to some farmers at the Farm Progress show. He told them then that Ruddock would probably play the entire season because it drives Ferentz crazy when his QB takes chances ala Beathard. Even when it works. We will see if the leopard can truly change his spots.
 

khawk4

Active Member
Jun 23, 2014
644
60
28
Can't be that great if it wasn't good enough to force it's way past the natural ice that was Rudock for two years.

The job was clearly Rudocks after he won 8 games his first year as a starter. Problem was, he regressed. And, Id say he did a pretty good job earning his (CJ) way into starting. He was a year younger, was more wild than JR, and wasnt, at first, "kirks guy"
 

CyTwins

Well-Known Member
Jan 20, 2010
80,179
65,792
113
Ankeny
And obviously worse than Rudock.

Rudock was the better QB last year, this year who knows. It'll be really interesting to see how CJB over the course of the season, especially because if he gets hurt Iowa is screwed
 

NickTheGreat

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Jan 17, 2012
10,811
4,785
113
Central Iowa
0-15 is all I need to know. And I'm a super-biased Iowa State fan. I'll take Beathard until Sam proves himself.

Safe to say if Sam had Purdue on his schedule, he'd likely have a conference win. And give me a break on the 0-15. He was THE reason we beat KU when Jantz went down.

I'm a fan of Sam, but go ahead and give him that KU game. It's not like 1 -15 would change the argument. :no:
 

khawk4

Active Member
Jun 23, 2014
644
60
28
Rudock was the better QB last year, this year who knows. It'll be really interesting to see how CJB over the course of the season, especially because if he gets hurt Iowa is screwed

He was? And dont throw out his comp %, either. Thats been proven time and time again that the comp % doesnt tell the whole story.

Im not saying he was worlds better, but if he was the better QB last year, wouldnt he still be starting at Iowa, instead of Michigan? Or do you know more than the coaches?
 

tazclone

Well-Known Member
Apr 14, 2006
10,105
1,123
113
CJB is a poor man's Steele Jantz. Upside and raw talent is there but will probably lose a couple games because of his turnovers and poor decision making
poor man's Steele....sounds just like Steele
 

clairvoyantdan

Active Member
Aug 10, 2015
1,052
0
36
Rudock was the better QB last year, this year who knows. It'll be really interesting to see how CJB over the course of the season, especially because if he gets hurt Iowa is screwed

You said yourself CJB had too small of a sample size. Rudock was and always has been a horrific QB.
In no way shape or form has Rudock ever been a better QB than CJB.