And so it begins... NIL

cayin

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Apr 11, 2006
10,114
10,379
113
So wouldn't schools located in lower population states like Iowa be at a disadvantage because there is not as many businesses as the higher population areas? For example, if one school is close to 500 business and the other is close to 200 businesses it would seem there are more opportunities for kids to earn more money if they go to higher population areas. Nebraska is a lower population state, but their fan base will do whatever it takes to help the players with NIL. Plus, they do not have another school in state to compete with like we do.
 

Sousaclone

Well-Known Member
Apr 29, 2006
1,853
1,179
113
North of Seattle
I'm concerned that student athletes will get into trouble with the IRS and cause all kinds of lifelong issues. Hopefully these folks brokering big time deals will help them out with taxes and such.

Yeah, this has me slightly worried. I can see a bunch of kids getting taken advantage of or being given horrible advice. It seems to happen a bunch in the NFL and other pro level sports. Can only imagine what it'll be like with a bunch of kids who are 4-5 years younger and don't have the support system (even if it itsn't great) that the pro leagues have for their rookies.

Maybe the tax lawyers and accountants can really get in on the game at that level? "I'm Brock Purdy and I get my Taxes done at {insert name of tax company done here}"
 

cayin

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Apr 11, 2006
10,114
10,379
113
I am for athletes being free to capitalize. I am for the end of the anti-competitive practices that the NCAA has employed for years. If that means that the pendulum swings towards the athletes, hooray!

And if Iowa State is unable to cope with the change in landscape, I'll be sorry about that. I tend to believe that people like Pollard are very good at what they do. And rolling with the punches and making the best of it is exactly what they get paid to do.
anti competitive practices of the NCAA? So we don't want a level playing field in college football? IMO, the only difference in programs should be donor money to the athletic department. TV, it should be the same for every P5 school across the nation. We shouldn't have a P5 league dying on the vine like the Pac 12. College Football needs a governing body otherwise get used to the SEC and Big 10 getting even more money and resources than everyone else.
 

Larzz

Active Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Jul 14, 2014
207
46
28
Cedar Falls, IA
You would think, but I have a 50 year old client who just throws the 1099's away no matter how many times I tell him I need each and everyone of them.

I did some contracting work for 2 years in my late 20's and made a comedy of errors when it came to being 1099 worker and the IRS ate my lunch. I'm really hoping these young adults have a better go at it then I did.
 
Last edited:

Mr Janny

Welcome to the Office of Secret Intelligence
Staff member
Bookie
SuperFanatic
Mar 27, 2006
42,737
33,751
113
anti competitive practices of the NCAA? So we don't want a level playing field in college football? IMO, the only difference in programs should be donor money to the athletic department. TV, it should be the same for every P5 school across the nation. We shouldn't have a P5 league dying on the vine like the Pac 12. College Football needs a governing body otherwise get used to the SEC and Big 10 getting even more money and resources than everyone else.
Yes, the NCAA engages in anti competitive behavior. They artificially limit what a scholarship can include. They have historically controlled the movement, rights and monetization of players, while also dominating the main paths to the professional leagues. They have a monopsony and have exploited it for massive profit. That's absolutely anti-competitive.
 

DeereClone

Well-Known Member
Nov 16, 2009
8,281
9,648
113
The link to Miami and UCF says IT ALL..all of you supporting this crap..please explain how this is good for Iowa State????

I don’t think it’s good for Iowa State but I do support the players ability to make money off their NIL. If they provide value in the marketplace they should be able to capitalize on that.
 

cykadelic2

Well-Known Member
Jun 10, 2006
4,009
1,749
113
I don’t think it’s good for Iowa State but I do support the players ability to make money off their NIL. If they provide value in the marketplace they should be able to capitalize on that.
The Miami FL deal clearly violates FL NIL Law that requires NIL compensation be commensurate with market value and cannot be provided in exchange for athletics performance or attendance at Miami FL.
 

Yellow Snow

Full of nonsense....
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Oct 19, 2006
2,498
2,213
113
Osage, IA
Maybe the question should be is it good for Iowa State athletes?

The question should be, is it good for Iowa State athletes relative to another schools athletes? Of course it's good for Iowa State athletes... the ones that choose to come here. Problem is we have to get them here first.
 

stateofmind

Well-Known Member
Jul 16, 2007
6,635
4,174
113
Ankeny
So are these students professional athletes now? I guess it doesn't matter anymore? I have no idea what impact this will have. My personal feeling is that college athletics will not survive. Sure football and basketball will for the haves, but the sports that are funded by the revenue the schools make on fb and bb will drop dramatically.

I guess the majority either doesn't believe this or feels that this is natural selection. I guess if it does destroy a school like ISU I will save a ton of money not going to games and won't need to visit this site anymore.
 

8bitnes

Well-Known Member
Nov 21, 2010
2,755
2,954
113
You would think, but I have a 50 year old client who just throws the 1099's away no matter how many times I tell him I need each and everyone of them.

I clearly don't know all the details, but if I was preparing his taxes and had knowledge of this, I am not sure how I would still be doing his taxes. Aren't you a willing player in tax fraud?
 

8bitnes

Well-Known Member
Nov 21, 2010
2,755
2,954
113
I hope these players are getting assistance with fully reading and understanding these contracts. There are some horror stories of minor league baseball players being taken advantage of
 

cyfanatic

Well-Known Member
Oct 18, 2006
7,092
3,127
113
Cedar Rapids, Iowa
I clearly don't know all the details, but if I was preparing his taxes and had knowledge of this, I am not sure how I would still be doing his taxes. Aren't you a willing player in tax fraud?

Not necessarily fraud...the customer might not be taking any deductions/credits or claiming any advantage at all for these activities.
 

BryceC

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Mar 23, 2006
26,462
19,624
113
So are these students professional athletes now? I guess it doesn't matter anymore? I have no idea what impact this will have. My personal feeling is that college athletics will not survive. Sure football and basketball will for the haves, but the sports that are funded by the revenue the schools make on fb and bb will drop dramatically.

I guess the majority either doesn't believe this or feels that this is natural selection. I guess if it does destroy a school like ISU I will save a ton of money not going to games and won't need to visit this site anymore.

This is basically the Olympic model and the olympics seem to be humming along nicely.

Why will the funding for non revenue sports drop dramatically?