Do you want Campbell gone?

Do you want Campbell gone?

  • Yes

  • No


Results are only viewable after voting.
Status
Not open for further replies.

jdoggivjc

Well-Known Member
Sep 27, 2006
61,625
23,880
113
Macomb, MI
Do I WANT him gone?
no
Do i want to loose to dog $*** team like Ohio, T.O.E, or the dirty birds of Kansas?
HELL NO

Hope Matt can turn it around, right now I am not sure he can.

In spite of my post earlier - do I WANT to have Campbell fired? No - what I want for him to do is get his head out of his ass and realize that this gutless conservative approach to the game isn't working. But because I already know Campbell won't change on his own, that means changes need to be made for him - up to and including him being part of that change.
 

67CY

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2006
4,508
3,193
113
After hearing is post game interview with Eric, I don’t care one way or the other
 
  • Dumb
Reactions: CyDude16

cyclone1209

Well-Known Member
Nov 5, 2010
3,858
2,526
113
Denver
Critical of Campbell but he could have bolted a number of times. I’m as loyal to him as he’s been to us.
I greatly respect him for this too.

But I will say, if he continues this dumbass "bully ball offense that actually can't run" it will be the end of him. He will be back next year, but if it goes awful next year again he may have to be bought out. This is starting to feel Rhoads like which I can't believe.
 

awd4cy

Well-Known Member
Dec 29, 2010
27,986
19,609
113
Central Iowa
I don't think he's truly on the hot seat until next year. Coaches who can win NY6 games are worth giving a longer leash to, and a lot of our issues are correctable. But I can't say I'm confident he'll do what it takes to fix the coaching issues at this point.

He does do a lot of things well. His recruiting and development has given us our most talented teams in my lifetime, and that's probably the hardest part of the job. The defense is elite, and while you can rightfully give Heacock a lot of credit for that he's probably only staying on staff with Campbell. The odds of getting a good developmental coach with a great defensive scheme that won't bolt at the first sign of success are very, very low.

But the offensive scheme is broken, and it doesn't look like we're trying to fix it. Campbell and the staff actually have completely reworked a scheme and had success with it, they did it mid-season in year 2 with the defense, but for whatever reason he's unwilling to try that with the offense.

He's also a terrible game manager, which is really the easiest part of the job. Just hire an analyst, play some Madden and figure out what works, or just go with the more aggressive option every time since that's usually correct. Even notoriously stubborn Kirk Ferentz has significantly improved at it since his early days. Just stop playing not to lose.

TL;DR I think this can largely be fixed if he stops being stubborn, but I'm not seeing any sign that's coming soon.
Coaches who beat 4-3 Oregon teams need a longer leash
 

MyNameEhJeff

Well-Known Member
Apr 2, 2021
1,078
1,728
113
21 Jump Street
I remember the days when I was this this kind of a delusional fan. Then in 2005 we went 7-5 with a team that should have at least won 10 games, and in 2006 we went 4-8 (1-7) with a team that nearly every preseason magazine had us winning the North comfortably. A "McCarney can do wrong" kind of fan finally hit his breaking point and I finally had to jump off the bandwagon.

I have seen this story play out too many times at ISU: coach wants to prove he's the smartest person in the room and refuses to change when it's clear that what he insists on sticking to isn't working because the game has changed around him, leaving him behind.

The forced firing of Manning last year was a mandate that things had to change. Instead, Campbell has doubled down on the gutless conservative gameplans that don't work. If he was mandated to change and refused to change, that's a coach that shouldn't be coaching.
Kirk went 6-7 in year 8 and 4-8 in year 14. Firing Campbell during a rebuilding year would be a delusional thing to do. I’m glad Jamie runs our AD and not fans on this site
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Help Support Us

Become a patron