***2023-24 College Football Thread***

qwerty

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Apr 3, 2020
7,693
11,638
113
60
Muscatine, IA
I’m too lazy to round up all the links but it also happens all the time and isn’t called. Here is one example.


KF said in post game that DeJean waves his arm in his normal running posture so I rewatched the return. Other than pre-catch, I must have missed him waving his arms in a circular motion while he ran.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BCClone

theshadow

Well-Known Member
Apr 19, 2006
19,976
19,638
113
I’m too lazy to round up all the links but it also happens all the time and isn’t called. Here is one example.



"Illegal hand signal" ? That's proof that this guy has no ******* clue.

Almost as bad as the "illegal fist in the back" BTN StudentU wrestling production several years ago. (P.S. They meant "stalling".)
 
  • Like
Reactions: carvers4math

ca4cy

Well-Known Member
Dec 6, 2009
7,101
9,118
113
North Central IA
It kind of looked like an RPO with no PO in the vicinity.
Yup. Drag a TE to that side with him and it has a much better chance of success. One thing Miami always has is speed. Even a good running qb is going to have a tough time getting to the edge if they don't bite on the fake.

On a different note, dozens of passionate Stanford fans out this evening to watch their freaky ass band.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: carvers4math

kentkel

Well-Known Member
Apr 12, 2006
5,407
5,630
113
57
I’m too lazy to round up all the links but it also happens all the time and isn’t called. Here is one example.


Before posting, perhaps you SHOULD do more research to back up your "it happens all the time & isn't called" argument. I have no sympathy for your Hoks since it was technically correct according to official rules. You can legitimately whine on this site when you get jobbed on actual bad calls (ex: our 2017 game vs KSU when 3 flags were picked up and waved off by refs that were NOT the ones who threw the initial flag - the last one where Alan Lazard was being mugged by a CB would have resulted in a first down assuring us a victory).
 
  • Agree
Reactions: ca4cy

CY88CE11

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Oct 25, 2012
5,411
5,743
113
The Des
Yeah, I don’t disagree. My only point is it’s a bit obtuse to act like it’s some obvious call that would get made by 100% of officiating crews. But to your point, I saw the video that one time 8 years ago something similar happened so I acknowledge that while extremely rare it is possible to make that call. It doesn’t make it less disappointing to me that they changed the outcome of a game over this. I mean, it seems to me like the ratio of how often that call would get made vs not made is not even close to 50-50 but it will take someone with more time than me to go compile how often every weekend something like that happens and isn’t called.
They literally didn't change the outcome of the game. Iowa had the ball at midfield with 100 seconds and 3 timeouts left. All they needed was a FG. The top 127 D1 football offenses win that game.
 

alarson

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Mar 15, 2006
59,514
74,266
113
Ankeny
They literally didn't change the outcome of the game. Iowa had the ball at midfield with 100 seconds and 3 timeouts left. All they needed was a FG. The top 127 D1 football offenses win that game.

Yeah, when Minnesota punted to them from where they were, I thought it was over even before the run back. Iowa would go get a FG and escape with a narrow win.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: GTO and CY88CE11

CY88CE11

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Oct 25, 2012
5,411
5,743
113
The Des
Yeah, when Minnesota punted to them from where they were, I thought it was over even before the run back. Iowa would go get a FG and escape with a narrow win.
I even said in the thread that DeJean would return it for a TD. The Boats played it too conservatively, but it worked out.
 

MountainManHawk

Active Member
Sep 10, 2015
236
193
43
45
KF said in post game that DeJean waves his arm in his normal running posture so I rewatched the return. Other than pre-catch, I must have missed him waving his arms in a circular motion while he ran.
I saw in Cooper’s post game interview he made similar comments, saying he was just trying to keep his balance and keep from going out of bounds or something since he was so close to the sidelines. I think the reality is probably just that he was full of adrenaline in the moment and wasn’t really thinking.

I’ve spent too much time tonight reading about the play and I’ve come to the conclusion that it’s just unfortunate. I acknowledge by the letter of the rule that can be called. I think the intent of the rule is so people don’t try to game it and give ambiguous signals that could be interpreted as maybe a fair catch.

But you can’t convince me that any Minnesota player thought that was a fair catch signal and for that reason similar stuff happens all the time and is almost never called - especially not overturning what was called on the field to change the winner of the game when we started out reviewing to see if he stepped out of bounds…
 

MountainManHawk

Active Member
Sep 10, 2015
236
193
43
45
They literally didn't change the outcome of the game. Iowa had the ball at midfield with 100 seconds and 3 timeouts left. All they needed was a FG. The top 127 D1 football offenses win that game.
I don’t think any Iowa fan disagrees that the offense is an embarrassment. Instead of trying to get into FG range with the offense, we should have just tried to recreate the punt return every down by putting Cooper on offense and long snapping to him and telling everyone else to just block.